When management decides to spill the negotiating details with any player, the implication is clear: they don't want him.
Aaron Judge gets that, as was clear at his press conference the other day, conducted in as close to gritted teeth as the California Redwood ever grits. He was surprised and clearly unhappy that Brian Cashman had leaked the details of the Yankees' final offer, because he understood full well what was going on.
The sheer totals of the money thrown around in such negotiations are staggering, of course—and immediately kill any and all sympathy for the player in question.
Thirty million a year for eight years? What idiot greedhead would ever turn that down???
And general managers like Cashman can always count on sportswriters—never noted for their industry—to simply print the whopping total. You will never see them put the amounts in any context, by writing the likes of, "Thirty million a year—or the equivalent of 10 Yankees luxury boxes," or whatever it may be.
Don't get me wrong. There are plenty of perfectly rational reasons not to offer Aaron Judge $30 mill a year for eight years, or anything like that.
It's just that only a few weeks ago, the Yankees weren't telling us any of those reasons.
Instead, we were informed—over and over again, through convenient leaks in the press and through social media—that we absolutely HAD to re-sign "Beloved Yankee Aaron Judge." It was, of course, the reason why the Yankees could not possibly fill a gaping hole by signing any of the College of Shortstops who became available as free agents this last offseason, headed by Carlos Correa.
Of course, back in the long-ago days of 2019-2020, we were informed that we could not possibly sign the likes of Bryce Harper, or Manny Machado, or Patrick Corbin, or J.T.L. Realmuto because, well, there were all these great free-agents shortstops who were going to be hitting the free-agent market!
...Pretty much any one of whom would have won your New York Yankees another 2-3 rings...
Anybody else seeing a pattern here?
But wait! The biggest lie of all is yet to come. In fact, it's already in development.
Just four days ago, a blog called "Fansided" ran the remarkable scoop that "MLB insider predicts Juan Soto megatrade to Yankees' evil empire."
https://fansided.com/2022/04/04/juan-soto-trade-rumors-yankees/
Wow, just the sort of headline that used to make our pulses race, don'tcha know!
And a real "major-league insider" was even produced, former GM-turned-"baseball analyst" Jim Bowden. According to Bowden, the Nats will fail to ink Soto to their own mega-offer, and thus "will trade him to the Yankees on Dec. 29 for a package of seven prospects that includes their [our] best prospect, Anthony Volpe."
An oddly specific prediction, that, for something that is supposed to happen over 8 months from now.
But sure, it could happen. Washington could trade the 23-year-old superstar who finished second in the NL MVP race last year for a guy who until this year has never played for a team higher than the Hudson Valley Renegades, or batted over .302 in a season.
Of course, it also could be that we'll all have to buy industrial-strength umbrellas, to avoid the copious qualities of porcine excretions that will be falling on us once pigs learn to fly on Dec. 29. But somehow, I doubt it.
Folks, this is the start of the next propaganda campaign, to justify the steady tightening of the HAL purse strings. Don't fall for it.
The Yanks have no intention of signing Judge. Maybe if it was 5 years, they could find the money. But the length? 8-10 years? Nope. The leaked terms were designed to he turned down, of course.
ReplyDeleteIndeed, Publius. What's even worse, though, is that they will NOT trade him this year for the very good package. They'll just let him go for nothing.
ReplyDeleteGallo with another awful play in the field. This guy just gets worse and worse.
ReplyDeleteAnd Sevvy actually having trouble getting the signals because of that stupid whale sound the Yanks insist on playing with two strikes. And meanwhile, Vazquez is wearing him out.
ReplyDeleteAlso Rizzo and Falafel with flubs. At least Rizzo hits. As for Falafel...
ReplyDeleteWow. I'm sure Joey Gallo has done something right this young season. I just can't think of it.
ReplyDeleteAnd Joey Whiffs with the base running blunder…
ReplyDeleteCheck out Scranton's lineup tonight. It'd take 2 of 3 from Baltimore. Remember, look at every Cash move with the idea that success in Scranton is his #1 priority, and the last dozen years make much more sense.
ReplyDelete@Bosch…shortened Spring Training is the reason…
ReplyDeleteJoey is putting on a show today, as they used to say. An easy flyball that he couldn't see, then dove for and dropped. Thrown out at second when he stopped to admire his drive. Another, highly catchable flyball banging off the wall in left...several feet to his side.
ReplyDeleteAnd we haven't even got to the three-pitch strikeouts yet!
It's everywhere, Bosch. Short ST. Extra arms on 28 man roster. And overall sense that 3rd time thru lineup is poison means 3 innings from the starter is acceptable, 4 is a pleasant surprise, 5 makes him an all star, 6 puts him in Cooperstown.
ReplyDeleteWhatever the "data" may say about his value, Joey Gallo is a bad baseball player.
ReplyDeleteRizzo!!!
ReplyDeleteCastro has a different glove…
ReplyDeleteJuly 2, 1963. Juan Marichal beat Warren Spahn, 1-0, in 16 innings, at Candlestick Park. Marichal threw 227 pitches, Spahn, 201. The game was decided on a home run by Willie Mays in the bottom of the 16th, which made him the only man in major-league history to hit at least one home run in every inning, 1-16.
ReplyDeleteI'm not making this up!
True, the high strike was rapidly making this a pitcher's era. But still!
Au contraire, Publius!
ReplyDeleteJoey Gallo got a walk today, so his all-important OBP is 1.000! Plus neither of his 2 errors were called errors.
See? If you just call everything what you want it to be, then nothing ever has to go wrong!
I wish we had an outfielder like Verdugo.
ReplyDeleteGiancarlo!!!
ReplyDeleteDidn't we get Falafel for defense? Not showing it today.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteJM, correct.
Let's hope El Chapo maintains his composure.
ReplyDeleteGod, I hope El Chapo keeps this up. Another nice 9th.
Remember last year. Mark David Chapman had the best start of the year of his entire career. Maybe of any closer's career. Then he just imploded. I hope he learned something from that.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteAnonymous B:
Below is a reply to a comment you made on another thread because 1) I don't want it to be lost and 2) because it seems like it might flow naturally following your comments above.
In response to Quentin Earl Darrington's performance of God Bless America on Opening Day, you said:
it’s not just a matter of taking a breath at a non-traditional place; he adds an appoggiatura to reach the high note. It is, indeed, impressive. Sorry to get all technical, but this is actually what I am paid to do.
I had to look up the dictionary definition of "appoggiatura" and I'm glad I did. I re-watched that video of God Bless America a few times and that's definitely it. You can even hear the effect it has on the crowd (me included) immediately afterward.
To your comments above, you're also one of those who has a great deal to offer and share. Sure, watch fewer games, completely understood. But please don't be a stranger in these parts.
Hot take after 2 games : outside of their core players, the RS look pretty crappy, especially the bullpen. Our pitching was sharp, but only 4 hits + 3 walks. Rough start for Gallo. Was surprised, but happy to see Judge in CF in the second game. We could sweep tomorrow, but then 4 games against Toronto, a much sterner test.
ReplyDeleteDon't get sucked in , folks...they may go on a run, but they're doing to do what they do best - break our hearts.
ReplyDeleteThey started the anti Judge propaganda early in this one, they really wanted to get in front of the upcoming debacle, when he signs with the Mets
ReplyDeleteOr Red Sox. Bradley Jr's a placeholder.
ReplyDeleteActually Bill Madden has an interesting take on the Judge negotiations.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.nydailynews.com/sports/baseball/yankees/ny-hal-steinbrenner-brian-cashman-aaron-judge-20220410-tx7rbsahizdw7f6h3n3kzqiwc4-story.html
Folks, it's waaay too early to start spotting "trends" regarding players or the team. If Cole and Severino stay healthy and effective, the team just be lethal. However, failure to secure a high quality centerfielder is infuriating, and could sink the ship. A guy like Luis Castillo should be the number two pitcher. If this is team playing down to its worst level Judge should, and probably will be traded. If that turns out to be the case, Hal had DAMN well better reel him back in. Unfortunately, after reading that weird Heyman article on Judge yesterday, this smells like so many "missed him by THAT MUCH" narratives that have come out of the Yankee front office over the years. But when you have a system that smacks of a socialist-communist economic system mixed with outrageous collusion then anything could happen. Sorry, I'm all over the place, but it's been along day.
ReplyDeleteThey're already starting the pr campaign for when the Mets get Judge. Fuck Hal!!! Boycott the team.
ReplyDeleteBill Madden is a tool/fool for the owners.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteI happen to be a long-time Yankees fan AND a Nationals fan. I've lived in the DC area for a long time. Was on the bandwagon for the new team long before it materialized. Born in Brooklyn, I was 4 when the Dodgers left. The Yankees were, when I was a kid, right there, Elemental to my belief system -- like the Virgin Mary, the Constitution, and Sicilian Pizza from Spumoni Gardens.
BUT: I really, really like Juan Soto.
Of course, I dismiss all trade rumors, as anyone should. And I am, and have been, a huge fan of Aaron Judge.
Having said all of that:
Check out how many games Soto played in during the 2 full seasons he's been around -- 150 and 151.
A rational approach would be: If you're going to give anyone $240 million in a contract -- or more, or even just a little less -- for any period of time, you should really, really want to give it to a great player who is able to show up and play the majority of the time.
Omit what you think about Judge and not getting the vaccine. Think about how often the guy has been hurt.
Also, also also --
Soto struck out only 93 times last year. 654 plate appearances. It's an improvement over his 2019 number.
Soto's OPS for 2019 was .940. It was .999 last year. It was a ridiculous 1.185 in '20, in a that very ridiculous season.
Judge's comparable numbers were .921 and .916. He had 158 Ks last year, in 633 PAs.
I'm still a Yankee fan first and foremost, even as they (the owner/GM/manager) make it very difficult to sustain. I'd root for the NYYs over the Nationals in a WS.
[got numbers at baseball-reference.con]
However, I want Soto on my #1 team. I realize it probably won't happen.
Yeah, in a perfect world you'd have Soto AND Judge. I don't believe that would happen, even in a dream.
But if you are a NYY fan, you have to want the guy who isn't hurt all of the time, who has cut down on his strike-outs (and as a young, young player!)......
I realize the smart bet is (a) the Yankees let Judge go, and (b) they then proceed to NOT obtain Soto and some other team signs him.
But I think -- even without Soto in the equation -- you can make a really good case to NOT give tens of millions to a guy who gets hurt a lot, and who (from here on in) is just gonna get older.
Great comments, guys. And I very much agree, Joe FOB. I've been wondering if we should trade Judge, literally for years now. I find the guy very likable—less so, after his mealy-mouthed take on the vaccine, but still, how can you not like him?
ReplyDeleteBut as you say, SHOULD we give this guy who is really too big and too fragile for the game—and now pushing 30—all that money and all those years?
I think a hard-eyed, tough, canny GM would say no, and work out some great trade for him.
But again: we run into the Cashman Conundrum. AND the HAL Equation (gotta get a better name for that one).
Cashie isn't capable of making a great Judge trade. Something like that, quite difficult for any GM, is way, way beyond his competence level.
And HAL doesn't WANT him gone. He wants Judge here all year to make sure the Yanks contend, and the fans keep coming out and tuning in.
But all of which means, we'll get the worst of all possible worlds: we'll lose one of our best players, and get nothing in return.
I would also love to have Juan Soto on the Yankees, Joe. And years ago, under the Mad King and even some others, we would have been working toward that.
ReplyDeleteHell, years ago we would have already snapped up Bryce Harper—who very much wanted to come to the Bronx, apparently—and now we would be talking about adding Juan to put the Three Giants in the OF.
But that ain't gonna happen. This Soto rumor is just a dazzle, more chump talk to make sure we stick with the team for another year, probably planted with Bowden by our favorite GM in the first place.
JFB......AND Soto is 7 years younger than Judge so a better bang for the buck.
ReplyDeleteCashman should trade one of the 2 hyped shortstops. Volpe is a top 30 MLB prospect so perhaps he would be considered the more superfluous marketable part. Of course, it would take a lot ore than that to pry Soto away from the Nats.
Horace....maybe the Hal Factor would be better than equation. Or component, consideration or calculation. I'm sure there are a few good substitutions out there.
Horace, you got it. Hal did say he needs to pay the creditors. He is a bean counter and is happy to make the wildcard and lose, hand out bobbleheads payed by sponsors and call it a season.
ReplyDelete