Traitor Tracker: .254

Traitor Tracker: .254
Last year, this date: .305

Sunday, April 20, 2025

Cashie's Choice.

 


Last season, the biggest shot heard 'round these parts, anyway, was Pete Alonso's series-winning blast off Milwaukee Brewers' closer Devin Williams, he of "Airbender" fame.

After the season, the 30-year-old Alonso, a fan favorite in NYC, could have been had for a song, a one-year, "let's see how you do" contract.

Instead, Cashie signed the guy who gave up that titanic shot.

Given a choice between Bobby Thomson and Ralph Branca after the 1951 playoff, Cashman would've signed Ralph Branca.

Given a choice between Carlton Fisk and Pat Darcy, Cashman would've signed Pat Darcy.

Given a choice between Michael Jordan and Bryon Russell, Cashman would've signed Bryon Russell.

Given a choice between Peyton and Eli Manning, Cashman would've signed Cooper.

Of all Cashman's problems in ever putting together a championship team on his own, he struggles most in coming up with a decent pitching staff. Once again, we see why.

The silver lining? Unlike Cashie's most disastrous decisions, Airbender Williams is only a one-year commitment. He can trot on back to Milwaukee, or wherever, come 2026. Don't let the air bend you on the way out.







4 comments:

BTR999 said...

I would propose flipping Williams at the deadline. It’s highly unlikely the penurious Steinscammer would re-sign him in any event, so why not take what we could get from some pitching needy teams?

And mean while? Leave It To Weaver!

ranger_lp said...

One can argue that Devin is suffering from shell shock syndrome…

JM said...

Yes!

TheWinWarblist said...

Given a choice between Peyton and Eli Manning, Cashman would've chosen gonorrhea.