For nine years, we have been making comic books. We are about to publish our masterpiece...

For nine years, we have been making comic books. We are about to publish our masterpiece...
We need your help.

Tuesday, June 2, 2026

Over the first two months, Cam Schlittler is the AL Cy Young

It's hard to discuss Cam Schlittler without bursting into tears. Guy's an angel from heaven, an emissary from God, a living saint from Weymouth, MA, the heart of Redsock Country. Every time he fans a batter, somewhere, a Boston fan throws up.

Where would we be without him? Probably 2nd place in the hot mess AL East, which is - well - where we are. But instead of being two behind Tampa, we'd be seven back, fighting off hateful Toronto. And every 5th day, our listed starter would be "TBD," if not Jake Bird. 

Yesterday, we discussed how Ben Rice has saved the Yankee offense. Today, let's go even further, some felony-grade, juju blaspheme. (Yes, I certainly fear sparking juju god retaliation, but as a teller of truth and sayer of sooth, I have no choice but to continue. Also, I should add that I recently aced my regular cognitive exam, amazing the doctors with my ability to identify a squirrel.) So here goes...

The Yankees - despite their system-draining deadline trades - have baseball's best young hitter and best young pitcher.

There. I said it. Whatever happens, it's on me. Because in all of American sports, there is nothing more freakishly fragile than a young pitcher's arm, and I just put a target on the Yankees' best hope. Dare we believe that Schlittler can last the regular season and still be bringing it in October? In this modern era, how many young pitchers do such a thing?

In February, Schlittler turned 25. Last year, combining MLB and the minors, he threw 149 innings. This year, he's thrown 72, which puts him on a trajectory to surpass 200. That should make us nervous, but the reality is that nobody in baseball knows how to handle a dominating young workhorse like Schlittler, and Boonie is gonna do what Boonie always does: Climb aboard the horse and ride until it fails.  

As of today, Schlittler ranks 5th in innings, 3rd in wins and 5th in strikeouts, with the best ERA in the AL. He would start the All-Star Game, if the Yankees let him. (They should not.)

If the season ended today, the Yankees would make the expanded playoffs - MLB's version of little league participation trophies. Schlittler would start game one of the wild card series. After 200 innings, he would face this schedule.  

Gerrit Cole would start game two. (Actually, if he keeps pitching like he has been, Cole could do game one.) Then it's Max Fried or Carlos Rodon, with Will Warren and Ryan Weathers going into the bullpen. 

The Yankees have gotten used to Cam Schlittler throwing a quality start every 5th day. But they better ease up on the pedal. When the angel flies down from heaven, you ought not ruin him.

Tonight, he stars against Cleveland. Godspeed. 

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

20 comments:

AboveAverage said...

Thank you, E.D.

You just gave me an idea for today’s game thread.

And if by any chance you ever wondered if raccoons will eat wild turkey eggs - the answer is yes.

13bit said...

Thank god for our lights-out bullpen. We're going to win it all. That, and consistent clutch hitting.

13bit said...

Without video documentation, it didn't happen.

Carl J. Weitz said...

How did the eggs get in the bottle?

AboveAverage said...

I’d share the video but I fear for the mental health of those who watch it

AboveAverage said...

It’s been a long time since a NY team has shown Cleveland who’s BOSS

JM said...

I do so like the young man's arm
I do so like it, Cam I Am

HoraceClarke66 said...

That's hilarious, Duque. Yes, I know that cognitive test. It means you have reached the level of a dog!

HoraceClarke66 said...

"When the angel woos the clay he'd lose/ His wings at the dawn of day." Or something like that. Hey, I didn't write it!

Yes, they should be careful with him, especially after the All-Star break.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Had the Mets game on in the background while I was working last night. They were playing the Mariners, who have a frightening number of good young arms. That would be our fate: get to the ALCS and get by Seattle. Just sayin'!

Hinkey Haines said...

@Carl - that was a good one.

Carl J. Weitz said...

;)

ranger_lp said...

Yanks are facing a plus .500 team. I am doing a concern...

13bit said...

Reasonable question, Carl.

13bit said...

Let's be respectful of dogs, Hoss. I know some people who are a lot dumber than a dog. By the way, did you know that most people don't know that "dumb" ends with a "B"? Bet you didn't know that.

Hinkey Haines said...

Judge day-to-day (read: out until August) with bone bruise in shoulder. Apparently bern bugging him for weeks.

The Hammer of God said...

Raccoons are ominorous - they'll eat anything. They even drink beer.

The Hammer of God said...

Dum dee dum dum!

The Hammer of God said...

Have ya'll noticed that Boone is riding Schlittler like a rented mule? Should be handling him with kid gloves. Also, our stoopid pitching coach should be encouraging him to throw more curveballs. Learn how to really change speeds and pitch. But of course, Yankee coaching don't understand any such thing. It's all about just riding a horse 'til it drops dead. Throwin' a fastball 'til it gets hit. Not much for fundamentals or strategizin', these here coaches.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

There was some bad juju in that post.😨