Wednesday, May 29, 2024

Foodstamps Hal will never let the Yankees get over the top.

All right, I'm sober now. Nothing like two grisly losses on the West Coast to serve as an intervention.


Thanks to the time difference, though, I got to see yet another indication of what the Yankees COULD be—and never will, as long as Foodstamps Hal Steinbrenner and his favorite monkey butler keep running this team.

Even as the Yanks were losing to a dreadful Anaheim Angels club, complete with a starter who had an ERA over 5 and a bullpen full of junk, the Queens Team was dropping a doubleheader to a Dodgers team that was essentially playing with one hand tied behind its collective backs (Which, I know, is painful to imagine, but bear with me.)


The Dodgers, it was reported, currently have 9—count 'em, NINE!—pitchers on the DL, including future Hall of Famer Clayton Kershaw. Shohei Ohtani DH'd all of one game out in Flushing, and went 0-5.                               
Still didn't matter. Mostly because Freddie Freeman spent the whole evening tattooing line drives all around the ballpark. Fast Freddie ended up with five hits on the doubleheader, including a homer, two doubles, and three ribbies. 

That wasn't a surprise. Freeman has been a paragon of consistency his entire career, the leading active player when it comes to career runs, hits, doubles, and RBI; a lifetime .301 hitter. He is 34 but shows no sign of slowing down, barely missing a game.


The guy we chose to sign over Freeman for first base is, of course, Anthony Rizzo, who is the same age—and who looks like he's done. This is no knock on Rizzo, a thoroughly likable individual. It's not his fault that he suffered a debilitating concussion in a freak accident (or that the Yankees unconscionably decided to keep playing him for months afterwards). He was a very good player for years, a good power hitter and an excellent fielder, a leader on a world champion team (not ours, of course).
Yet while Rizzo was a very good player, Freeman is on another plane, a no-brainer Hall-of-Famer, maybe even an all-time great. What's more, while they are the same age, both left-handed hitters  custom-made for the New New Yankee Stadium, it was clear even before Cashie re-signed him that Rizzo was a player in decline—while Freeman was not.

After Ant'ny hit .222 in the shortened Covid season of 2020—while Freeman batted .341 and won the NL MVP—Rizzo was hitting .248 in 2021, when the Yanks brought him in as an emergency acquisition down the stretch. He hit .249 with 8 homers in 49 games with the Bombers. Not a bad performance by today's standards, but hardly jaw-dropping.

Still Cashie picked up his option for 2022—never seriously looking at Freeman, who had just compiled another .300 season and led the NL in runs scored. Freeman signed with the Dodgers.

Rizzo managed to hit 32 homers in 2022—but missed 32 games and batted only .224. Nonetheless, Cashman signed him on again. Then came last year. Then came last night, when, as our Peerless Leader noted, he again looked ice cold, taking us out of what could have been a big first inning. 

Fabulous Freddie, meanwhile, turned into a doubles machine in LA, leading the NL with 47 (and a .407 slugging percentage), while batting .325 in 2022; hitting .331 last year with another 59 doubles—the seventh highest total anyone, ever has run up for two-baggers in baseball history. How many of those doubles might have flown over that short porch in our right field? We'll never know.

So why did our fabulous baseball braintrust go with Rizzo over Freeman? 

Money, of course.

Anthony was a "bargain," costing the Yanks $16 million in 2022, and $17 million in 2023 and 2024, with a $17-million team option in 2025. The Yanks can buy him out for just $6 mill before 2025—meaning that, at most, for four years of decline and injury, Rizzo will have cost them "only" $67 million, and quite possibly "just" $56 mill. 

Freeman? His Dodgers contract is for $27 mill, for 6 years, or a total of $162 million. 

For Hal, this looks like a savings of $95-$106 million. He just doesn't get it—unlike the owners of the Dodgers, who have taken big, bold risks over the past few years, and basically reinvented the financing of the sport. No matter how their risks work out—and mind you, I wish the Dodgers nothing but ill!—they will dominate for many years to come.

For Hal, a big risk is ordering the sushi. He will never do what it takes to make the Yanks anything more than a perpetual, wild-card contender. This is what is truly "unsustainable."

14 comments:

AboveAverage said...

Hoss -

Just to toss a shovelful of fresh earth into the Rizzo argument - allow me to respectfully add that The Rizz and Judge (and their hounds) are besties.

Good chemistry makes the heart sing.

….or something like that

AboveAverage said...

Absolutely agree with everything else——great post

Doug K. said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Doug K. said...

Freeman 1B 27,000,000 (11M more than Rizzo)
Harper RF 25,000,000 (7M less than Stanton)

So with a better GM and 4M our lineup 1-9 could have been

SS Volpe
CF Judge
DH Soto
1B Freeman
RF Harper
LF Vedugo
3B DJ
2B Gleyber
C - Trevino

Sigh.

Kevin said...

Horace did you read the Dodger article yesterday in "The Athletic"? It sounds like the have many of the Yankees problems, short bullpen, lineup, short lineup,defensive issues. The only difference is that the author was convinced that the owner would do what was needed at the deadline. Kinda like the Yankees did twenty-five years ago. I would be remiss if I didn't note that the hated Dodgers are probably the biggest chokers in baseball history considering rings per dollar spent.

JM said...

I like Rizzo. I do. But he is just a shadow of his primetime self. A lot of games, that's basically good enough, and the rest of the team can make up for his decline. But it's now to the point where he's helping us lose games much more than he helps us win. And that is "unsustainable."

Too bad. It didn't start with the concussion, as Hoss points out, but that definitely looks to have accelerated his slide.

Ben Rice has yet to be promoted to Scranton. DJ may help at 1B, but his bat also seems to have deteriorated badly. His defense may still be reliable, at least. But you know the Yankees. At $17 million, he's going to be in the lineup, no matter what, because they're paying him too much to bench him.

It would be more respectful to let him sit more than not and avoid an ignominious end.

13bit said...

JUST FOR THE RECORD - I still don't believe this team can do it all the way to the end nor win in the playoffs.

BUT, FOR THE SAKE OF ARGUMENT, EVEN IF THEY DID, I would - after celebrating - continue to call for the ouster of Boone and Cash. Hal will outlive us all, but Boone and Cash must go. I will never accept them, which makes me a fanatic, I know.

Mildred Lopez said...


That was not an error by Rizzo last night, not an error at all. It was a hit. Sure the ball was in his glove, and yes it bounced out, and of course it rolled away as he attempted to corral it, but the ball was purposely trying to evade him. Anyone could see that.

The right side of the infield is the iron curtain - hit the ball over there and watch it bounce around.

AboveAverage said...

GIL onda HILL WILL DEL'liver us from e-VIL!

Or he won't and we'll lose again - I mean that's baseball, right?

BTR999 said...

Excellent post Hoss - yes! With Cashman, it’s not just the bad moves he’s made, but the good ones he could’ve made but didn’t.

JM said...

Trade Gleyber. Call up Caleb.

Easy peasy.

AboveAverage said...

Anyone going to any of the games this weekend in San Francisco?

HoraceClarke66 said...

So many bad things are happening to the Metsies right now that I actually feel sorry for them. Diaz going on the DL, maybe Alonso. Ohtani homering...while most of the crowd at the Mets' own park applauds...Lopez gets ejected and hurls his glove into the stands...

I think that if they play another game, a giant hole might open up and suck them all down to hell.

(No doubt, this presages what is about to happen to your New York Yankees.)

Doug K. said...

JM - Durbin is on the IL. Hand injury.