Cashman also made noises about trying Garcia at second (idiot) due to the logjam a healthy Stanton would cause.
Yeah, well, if history serves, that won't be a problem.
“John had no guile. He didn’t understand it when people were mean to him because he could never be mean to anybody."—Suzyn Waldman
Yeah, well, if history serves, that won't be a problem.
Looks to be a long, fruitful day for the Yankee GM. Here's the schedule...
7:30 a.m. Lear jet lands outside Vegas.
8:10 a.m. Arrive at Ritz-Carlton. Unpack. Check messages. Last-minute preparations.
8:13 a.m. Call NAME REDACTED .
10:00 a.m. GM meeting gaveled to order.
10:02 a.m. Recess declared.
10:15 a.m. Open bar in the Nautical Room.
2:00 p.m. Check for calls from Hal, wife, NAME REDACTED.
2:10 p.m. Convene to the Captain's Lounge.
4:00 p.m. After multiple missed calls, finally connect with NAME REDACTED.
4:15 p.m. Uber ride to outskirts of city.
5:00 p.m. Unspecified medications from NAME REDACTED.
5:30 p.m. Concern over efficacy of medications.
6:00 p.m. Naked karaoke in barnyard.
7:00 p.m. Hobo boxing.
7:30 p.m. Fire dance welcoming Satan.
8:00 p.m. Cock fights.
8:15 p.m. Keynote address by Beastmaster.
8:30 p.m. Human sacrifice.
9:00 p.m. Pose for photos with Mr. Hegseth, Mr. Patel and Mr. Miller.
9:15 p.m. Trade Ben Rice for right-fielder.
9:30 p.m. Trade Cam Schlittler for DH.
10:00 p.m. Re-sign Trent Grisham to 10-year deal.
11:00 p.m. Vow eternal allegiance to Beastmaster.
11:05 p.m. Set fire to party farmhouse.
11:20 p.m. March through desert, shooting iguanas, pets, bystanders.
Dawn: Back to hotel for day two.
The lockout is just weeks away. There may not be any baseball next year.
It has to be done.
The goal of the lockout is to finally create cost controls by
placing a cap on spending ensuring a path to profitability that goes beyond
having the franchise value increase exponentially. Short term pain for long
term gain.
No one knows how long it will take to force the player's
union into capitulation. An athlete's career and earning window is limited so it
would appear that the owners have the upper hand but…
There will be a period of time when no money is coming in
and, for a family business like the Yankees, this will create hardship.
I’m worried about Hal and the rest of the Steinbrenners
The children will feel it the most.
Especially around Christmas.
The lockout is slated for Dec 1st.
Consequently, there won’t be any Christmas presents this year. Not good ones anyway. Just a few of the remaining Edwin Encarnacion Home Run Walk Parrots.
Perhaps, a quilt or two to keep them warm this winter, stitched from the no longer salable jerseys of Josh Donaldson, DJ LeMahieu, and Ryan McMahon.
A peasant’s Christmas dinner consisting of rat meat and
pigeon wings that, in happier times, would have found their way into the hot
dogs.
The Stadium will produce no revenue save for the meager returns of the 2026 “Bad Boy Mowers Pinstripe Bowl” on December 28th.
Too late to save
the holiday.
“Bad Boy Mowers” BTW.
That’s actually the sponsor this year.
--
Knowing this was coming Hal has taken steps to cushion the
financial shock of this tragic, self-inflicted wound .
In recent months he has:
1. Moved YES streaming from Gotham over to DAZN. Reducing costs.
Well, his costs anyway.
Yankee and Net fans now have to pay more.
Even better for Hal, fans will keep DAZN year round.
Previously a lot of Yankee fans dump YES in the off season
because the Venn Diagram showing the overlap of fans who follow both the Yankees and the Nets is laughably small. Now they can watch the Knicks and Hal gets a
slice of that pie.
2. Saved money on the coaching staff by failing to offer
raises or expensive promotions to key
bench personnel in order to retain them and prevent them from being poached by
rivals.
Hey, why should he pay for coaches if there’s no season?
Oh yeah and...
3. Sold a piece of the
team for 2.6 Billion Dollars. Cash.
--
Apparently these money
moves are insufficient.
Hal still needs the lockout. Otherwise the greedy players
union will take incrementally more!!
Think of the children!
Here are some new potential revenue streams to help the Steinbrenners
get through the next few months...
License the training rooms to 24 Hour Fitness
(Premium Pinstripe Pass! )
Who wouldn’t want to lift weights on the very machines used
by Yankee Superstars like Giancarlo Stanton?
State of the art vending machines can sell bags of Yankee
themed “Commemorative Potato Chip Bags” to help you track your progress.
Merch!
Then relax and take a schvitz in the steam room.
You know Hal sacked the cleaning staff the second the
Yankees failed to get past the ALDS again so you might be able to see a pool of
sweat left by Helios Ramos.
Take some home in a commemorative bottle.
Turn the Luxury Suites into Hotel Rooms.
They have couches. Or, even better, I’m pretty sure they have a warehouse full of Castro
Convertibles left over from their “Starling Castro Convertible Collection”, a lesser
part of their ill-conceived furniture marketing efforts that included the Juan
Sofa, and the borderline insane… Otto
Velez “Otto-Man”.
Plant Cannabis
Yankee Outfield Grass®!
That’s some primo farming space right there. The stadium is
a perfect place to grow pot. It is enclosed, gated, and already has grow lights.
The ticket windows are reminiscent of the ones used at the Cop and Stops of pre-legalization fame. Just put your money in the little bowl and slide it under the bulletproof one way glass.
The team could charge as much as $100 for a
nickel bag of “Bronx Bonger” or "Judgement Day" Sorry… Commemorative
Nickel Bag of "Bronx Bonger” or "Judgement Day” .
Should the season restart before harvest I know one left
fielder that wouldn’t mind
Congrats to Cody Bellinger, who last week won the 15th annual AL Platinum Glove, an award that somehow weighs catchers with shortstops, right fielders with second basemen, spark plugs with lug nuts, peanut butter with jelly...
It's another fukkin logarithm, obviously. Speaking for all who cannot explain what a logarithm is, let me assure you that Belly deserves his trophy, at least as much as Rex Harrison deserved his 1965 Oscar for My Fair Lady, brambling through his Broadway role, while Peter Sellers was being criminally overlooked for Dr. Strangelove. It needs to be said, people: Awards are bullshit, and that's not even mentioning the 2026 FIFA Peace Prize.
(Note: I have since learned that the award comes from fan voting, which only makes it less impressive. It's the People's Choice Award for defense.)
Listen: There is an eloquent argument to be made that the Yankees should leave Belly in left field for at least the next two years, if only so he can win more awards. He is our goalie, our sentry, our Lawrence Taylor (or, let's say it, our Arvell Reese?), and let's not disturb a genius at work, especially in our most iconic position.
That said... (clears throat)... 10 thoughts.
1. It's time to accept the Milwaukee Model - you win with speed, plate discipline, pitching and defense, defense, defense. Moving Bellinger to CF would follow that plan.
2. Belly in CF would instantly improve our defense, involving our best glove into more plays.
3. The Yankees have no other great-glove CF on their roster.
4. Trent Grisholm is gone; last year, he ran out of gas anyway.
5. Spencer Jones might someday be a solid CF, but for now, he takes bad routes and watches catchable balls drop. They assured us he was ready, but he doesn't look comfortable.
6. I cannot escape the cataclysmic terror of Jones colliding with Aaron Judge in right-center. Dear God. Such a seismic event would end Yankee civilization, as it did the dinosaurs. Belly is far less likely to run headlong into Doomsday.
7. For all his speed, The Martian, Jasson Dominguez, will never be a CF. It's not certain if he can play OF.
8. To sign or trade for a defensive CF would add to an OF logjam.
9. Moving Judge to CF would abuse him.
10. WTF? We have nobody else.
My guess is that the Yankees will go with Jones, who remains the most tantalizing prospect in the system.
So much for the Milwaukee Model, eh? It's not the Yankee way.
Okay, siddown for this. Deep breath. Clutch the grab-bar. Blink, if you see this. Okay...
Now, I'm gonna type something that will look like a transcribed Sonoran toad-lick hallucination, as if the gods of chaos are using my keyboard to spread the tomato seeds of insanity across this planet.
Let's do it - in 10 small bites.
1. The Scranton/Wilkes Barre Railriders - home to the Martian, Ryan McBroom, Zolio Almonte and 13 seasons of former future Yankee stars - are no more!
2. They are now the "Scranton/Wilkes Barre Highlanders," a throwback to the original Yankee teams of ol' New Yawk, married to the fact that there are - indeed - "high lands" in the geographical outskirst of Scranton, Wilkes Barre and Moosic, Pa.
3. Full disclosure: I have lived almost all my life an 80-minute drive from Scranton/ Wilkes Barre and - until today - have never heard the countryside described as "Highlands" or their inhabitants called "Highlanders." That just might be me. Maybe I missed it. Known to happen.
4. Also, I should note that, before they became the "Railriders," I'd never before heard that word, either. So - grain of salt, eh?
5. Also, let's be clear: There are high lands in and around Scranton and Wilkes Barre. Generally, I've heard them as "hills." But the name "Scranton/Wilkes Barre Hill People" would not have worked.
6. The "Scranton/Wilkes Barre Hilltoppers?" Or "Hill Folk?"
7. From 1989 to 2006, they were the "Scranton Red Barons," harkening back to the heyday of Snoopy, which inspired the most underrated Christmas song of all time. In it, Charles Schultz' intrepid cartoon beagle - as a WWI pilot - is forced down behind enemy lines, seemingly doomed, only to learn that yuletide joy overcomes everything. Suddenly, without warning, the Baron cries out, "Merry Christmas, my friend!" leading to a holiday toast. Christ, I'm crying, just typing it.
9. In 2007, they became the Scranton/Wilkes Barre Yankees, after luring the mother ship's Triple A affiliation from Columbus. This happened after the Phillies fled to Allentown, where Billy Joel lamented that they're "tearing all the factories down." Hey, there should be a playlist. That moved created the aptly named Lehigh Valley Iron Pigs.
10. In 2012, they became the Empire State Yankees, because the stadium in Moosic had become a mud pit and needed millions of dollars in taxpayer-funded renovations. For the entire year, the team bussed around upstate New York, playing home games in Rochester and Syracuse. I believe this was a low point in team history. For our playlist, I would submit Skeeter Davis singing "The End of the World."
In 2013 they became the "Scranton/Wilkes Barre Railriders." Honestly, I've never figured out why. Now, it's the Highlanders. Clearly, there's a three-syllable cadence thing going on. Let's hope it inspires a new generation of merch.
So, let's go, Homelanders. Wait. I mean Highlanders! Highlanders. HIGHLANDERS! From the high lands of Central Pennsylvania. Which, hopefully, Anthony Volpe will never have to visit again...
In just four weeks, Hal "Food Stamps" Steinbrenner - the most swaddled nepo baby since Jesus - will lug an iron chain to the front gate of George M. Steinbrenner Field in Tampa. He'll be joined by family consigliere Brian Cashman, holding one of those oversized padlocks that belongs in a Road Runner cartoon.
Then, together, they will kill Major League Baseball.
If any Gammonites are watching, they will be a solemn bunch, like witnesses to an execution. The padlock will click, and whatever Hal has to say - lamenting that this happened - it will be too late. His craven words will be a fart.
If Hal has anything to say, now is the time to stand and deliver.
Once the locks snap, MLB will birth another endless war, the kind everybody originally thought would last a week.
These days, every war is an endless war.
And in any lockout, Hal will be one of the biggest losers.
If the owners "win," they will impose the salary cap they've coveted for decades, and the Yankees will lose their fiscal advantage. They will become a coastal version of the KC Royals, forced into austerity payrolls that effectively kill the franchise for years.
If the players' union wins, Hal will have to do what he hates - spend his inheritance. No billionaire wants to be told how to spend his money. How do think they became billionaires? The last thing Hal wants is wide-open bidding on players. If the union wins, that's what he'll get.
And once the padlock clicks, it will be too late to speak out.
So... a suggestion...
Whatever Hal has to say - if anything - he better say it soon. He should rage against the gods, the owners, the players, you, me, our moms, I don't care, everybody - whatever!
The storied New York Yankees - his dad's pride and joy - will soon be on the chopping block. Is it really going to happen? It's up to you, New York, New York.
Hey, Juju gods!
Yeah, you!
Cut the shit. You're weirding us out. Look at the world. Everything's gone nuts. You want 10 signs? Okay, here goes...
1. Mississippi. Iowa. South Carolina... fukking Texas? Are you serious? TEXAS?
2. You know who has the No. 1 selling album in America? My Chemical Romance. (I'm not making this up.) "Welcome to the Black Parade?" Really? Again? Welcome to 2006.
3. Parts of Florida just took a year's worth of rain in two days. It's also rained like hell in Arizona. Arid-fukkin-zona. Meanwhile, yesterday, in Syracuse - rhymes with "sheer-abuse" - temps hovered near 80.
4. The President is working on the war the economy affordability chandeliers.
5. The stock market is a yoyo.
6. They're making John Wick into a cartoon series. (Reminder: I'm not making this up.)7. Bob Dylan is pals with the Pope.
8. George Stephanopolis just got his star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
9. Melania wants the Nobel Peace Prize.
10. And, um, this...
But but BUT... wanna know what hasn't changed? Are you yearning for that one restroom grab bar, that lone boulder of reality, unto which we can still perilously cling?
Anthony Volpe.
Yep, we're still waiting on him. It's been 100 years. As we sit here, with Jazz Chisholm halfway out the door and Jose Caballero still penciled in for utility IF, Volpe is still in the mix. He's our ballroom light fixture, our gold-plated arch.
In these ridiculous times, when chaos runs rampant like a biker gang in a mall, Yank fans still have something to clutch and stay afloat. Unfortunately, it has a career batting average of .225.
But hey, you never know. Volpe came within six inches of hitting the most important HR of this decade. So close, so fukkin close... Who knows? Maybe this will be his year. At least he's stayin' alive.
MLB teams have until Dec. 1 - (that's when the owners pull up the rug) - to decide the fate of Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato.
The Yanks claim to be interested.
Well... they fukkin oughta be. Guy plays 3B, a Yankee sinkhole. Last year, Ryan McMahon batted .213, Anthony Volpe moved to 2B, Cabby ran out of gas, and nobody bubbled up from Scranton.
So, who is Teruaki Sato? Ten observations...
1. He bats left, throws right, plays 3B/1B/OF and turns 28 in March.
2. He's no Goliath - -just 6'1", 207 - (by comparison, Ben Rice is 6'2", 228) - but won the Triple Crown last year in Japan.
3. Defensively, he's said to be an average 3B who might eventually move to 1B.
4. His dad was a Japanese national champion in judo.
5. His nickname is "Teru." Rhymes with "Hey, you!" (His Yankee nickname could be "Apollo Investment.")
6. He opened his career in the Japanese major leagues with two back-to-back HRs, then added a game-winning three-run shot.
7. In Japan, he's been an all-star in four of the last five years.
8. Last year, in the World Baseball Classic, he went 3-10 with three doubles. In the regular season, he hit .309 with 39 HRs and 106 RBIs.
9. Supposedly, to maximize his value, Sato's agent wants to market him as a 3B, his favorite position. That would seemingly undermine interest from the Mets and Dodgers.
10. But not the Redsocks, Angels and/or Phillies, who are letting free agent 3B Alec Bohm walk. Their GM, Preston Mattingly - (ah, shoot me) - scouted him last year in Japan.
In Japan, he wore jersey number 8, replacing Kosuke Fukudome. That's Yogi's number. (How about 88?)
1. Elon Musk is the Stevie Cohen of politics.
2. Hal Steinbrenner is the Darlene Graham of owners.
3. Ken Paxton is the Gene Mauch of politicians.
4. If last night were a game, the GOP would have used a position player to pitch the 9th.
5. If Ryan McMahon is not traded, he might be impeached.
6. Holy crap! Rep. Mark Teixiera (R-Tx) is a thing.
Jazz Chisholm
Not sorry to see Jazz go.
This picture says it all. Not just about Jazz but about a clubhouse culture where he thought it would be ok.
Billy Martin would have slapped it out of his mouth. Jorge Posada would have slapped it out of his mouth. Hell, Suzyn Waldman would have slapped it out of his mouth had she not been up in the booth.
See Ya.
So bursts another childhood fantasy.
I'm not referring to Jazz Chisholm, author of the above sad revelation, whose contractual qualifying offer yesterday was stuffed in a bottle and set out with the Japanese tide.
What died - and keeps succumbing, year upon year - is our collectively naive belief that to simply don the Pinstripes will transform a stat-sheet star into a great and hustling teammate.
Jazz is gone. As is another Yankee pipe dream.
Top Ten thoughts...
1. Over two straight winters, we've now cut ties to star second basemen with iconic first names - Gleyber and Jazz.
2. Upon their arrivals, both anticipated long and rewarding Yankee careers.
3. At the end, both were bluntly shown the door.
4. Gleyber went to Detroit in 2025 and became an all-star (16 HR, 74 RBIs, .256). Clearly, he had something to prove.
5. Wherever Jazz goes, he'll be bent upon showing up the Yankees. They have given him the wake-up wedgie that he needed.
6. Right now, the Yankee 2B position looks like Anthony Volpe or Jose Caballero.
7. One top free agent, 2B Brandon Lowe (35 HR, 96 RBI, .260) might be their guy. (He'll be 32.)
8. Increasingly, there is talk about 3B Teruaki Sato, the 2026 Triple Crown winner in Japan.
9. To get Sato, the Yankees must do what they haven't done in recent years: Outbid the Dodgers, Mets and/or Phillies.
10. This looks to be the last balls-to-the-wall free agency period before the Dec. 1 lockout. The Yankees - fortified by all that Apollo Investment cash - need to make a huge splash.
But but BUT... Hal is still Hal. And whomever we sign, get ready to watch Jazz outperform them in another city. When dreams die, they piss people off.
Once again, this we know:
Ghosts exist, flying saucers are real, money is piss, and Brian Cashman is the Yankee anti-Christ.
Every winter, every summer - every stinking year - the unstoppable force of Cashman's hubris erodes what - once upon a time, long, long ago - could have been a successful career as Yankee GM.
He rode high in the '90s, survived the 2004 disaster, won a ring in 2009, and now faces his 18th year of bad deals, every one of them worsened by the YES channel's cheerleading, which instantly proclaims every Cashman move as a work of genius.
From Alex Verdugo to Michael King, from Scott Effross to Joey Gallo, from Harrison Bader to Jordan Montgomer, from - gulp - Caleb Durbin to Devin Williams... the Mulligans just keep coming. (Heliot Ramos and Henry Lalane have entered the chat.) And Durbin - a gritty, balls-to-the-wall fireplug - might turn out to be one of the worst.
Ten sighs...
1. Three years ago, Durbin - a 5'6" Yank farmhand - tore up the Arizona Instructional League with the most stolen bases in its history.
2. Enamored with Josh Donaldson at 3B, Cashman dealt Durbin to Milwaukee for closer Devin Williams.
3. In Milwaukee, Durbin became a finalist for NL Rookie of the Year.
4. In NYC, Williams and Donaldson crapped their beds.
5. Last winter, the Brewers sent Durbin to Boston in a six-player deal.
6. Sunday, Durbin won the AL Gold Glove at 3B.
7. For Boston, Durbin - age 25 - batted .248. That's 35 points higher than Yankee 3B Ryan McMahon. He topped McMahon in every key metric.
8. Durbin's numbers are deceptive, because he endured a terrible start - (.228 in the first half, .274 in the second.)
9. Durbin cost the Redsocks $796,000. McMahon, in the final season of a six-year contract, will cost the Yankees $16 million.
10. This winter, Cashman will desperately seek to trade McMahon, while finding a 3B.
And the bonus kicker...
In mid-September, Cashman waived Oswaldo Cabrera. He was quickly snapped up by the Reds.
Also a winner: that "too small for the majors", "get rid of the little squirt" Caleb Durbin. In fact, the Red Sox had three Gold Glove winners.
Yeah, well. Whatever.
RIP Jerry Koosman.
As for Randy Levine...some people walk down the street and get called "asshole." This never happened to Pablo Picasso.
Q: Should we dare hope that Randy L. admitting it is the first step in fixing it?A: No, because you can't fix stupid.
Ten reasons why the '27 Yankees and their fans should phone it in.
1. The owner's been phoning it in for years.
2. The ownership lockout will ruin 2027 anyway.
3. Under Aaron Boone, the Yankees already tank each June.
4. Tampa regularly tanks; it works for them.
5. The Brewers, Rangers, Astros, Nats, Redsocks, Royals and Cubs all have recent world championships; at various points, they tanked.
6. Tanking would be easy; not even Cashman could mess it up.
8. One of these days, as impossible as it seems, the Mets will rise from constant tanking.
9. With our new draft picks and international spending money, we can load up with Dax Kilbys and Martians.
10. The 2027 winter is already lost, as NYC follows the Giants' march to the Super Bowl.
TOP TEN 2026 SOURCES OF YANKEE PRIDE
1. Won 93 games!
2. Runner Up in AL East!
3. Cam Schlittler!
4. Ben Rice!
5. Attendance of 3.2 million, 2nd in MLB.
6. Escaped Jeffrey Epstein files scandal. (Thus far.)
7. Hooked Apollo Investments and banked billions.
8. Burned full year of Giancarlo Stanton contract.
9. Beat the Redsocks.
10. Leaves fan base okay with impending lockout.
AND THE BOTTOM TEN (OUT OF 100)
91. Scored 13 runs in one inning against A's.
92. Max Schuemann!
93. Mets!
94. Never figured out Boone's post-game gestures to fans.
95. Dua Lipa attended game and ate hotdog!
96. Postponed CC Sabathia Jersey ceremonies.
97. Austin Wells broke up Rays playoff no-hitter.
98. Austin Wells showed hustle, going for three in Rays playoff game.
99. Anthony Volpe's playoff game-tying HR against Rays. (For two minutes.)
100. John Sterling spared from latest collapse.
Printed above in a Jumbotron font is the terrifying warning from Milwaukee manager Pat Murphy - bellowed in the champagne-soaked aftermath of the world series - to Brewers' hero Jake Bauers.
Someday, when you're unfathomably wealthy and playing for a big market team where everyone chases personal stats, you must remember this, a kiss is still a kiss, a smile is still a smile...
Sorry. Got carried away.
In this millennium, no words have more frighteningly indicted the Yankees.
Ten ugly thoughts...
1. Every Yank fan on this planet agrees with Murphy.
2. Though the owner, the management, and the YES propaganda mill would deny it, modern Yankee teams are compilations of individual players chasing stats.
3. What else explains the fixation with home runs at the expense of fundamentals? Regardless of the situation, batters take full, ridiculous swings - because that's where the money is.
4. In recent years, the Yankees have lacked one key component: A catcher. A 3B. A soul.
5. This vacuum begins at the top, where Hal Steinbrenner perpetually settles for a contending team. That lack of urgency percolates throughout the organization.
6. Even though the Yankee s are no longer baseball's biggest money pit, to small market teams and fans, they still epitomize excessive, runaway spending.
7. When players become indescribably rich, they're never the same.
8. In professional sports, you cannot buy hunger.
9. The Yankee culture will not change under this management, and the owner will not make changes, because he is comfortable with second place.
10. Yankee fans, and their opinions, simply do not matter.
That's China Town, Jake.
(Even if their longtime owner did manage to wreck the 1994 season, turn a blind eye to a generation of juicing, and stand there hopelessly unable to determine how to break a tie in the All-Star Game, in his wholly compromised role as commissioner. This Bud IS you, Mr. Selig.)—
—though reportedly, the Brewers' fine manager, Pat Murphy, asked Jake Bauers, the surprise hero of the postseason, if he wasn't glad he was no longer with that "selfish" Yankees team that played the game the wrong way.
This quote sounds so bizarre that I question its veracity. Among other things, Mr. Bauers stunk up the joint as a Yankee, a Mariner, an Indian, and a Ray, before turning in a .199 first year in Milwaukee.
The shock is not that Brian Cashman let him go, but that he didn't throw $22 million at him.
Well, good for Jake Bauers. And good for Pat Murphy. The both deserve their rings. But here are 10(?) observations on how it was the Yankees who were really exposed by this World Series.
—After an ALDS in which they kept the Yanks from so much as taking a lead for one inning, much less winning a game, the TB Rays had to grind out an ALCS against the Cleveland Guardians of Traffic, then were steamrolled by the Brewers.
—In the Series, the Rays hit .182 with 1 home run and only 5 stolen bases in 9 attempts, and committed 3 errors. They played poorly in every aspect of the game. Their starting pitchers lasted a combined 21 1/3 innings, or fewer than 5 per start, and surrendered 13 earned runs in that time.
—There was no reason to think they would do much better. While the Rays had the best record in the American League, they were only third in total WAR, at 7.9, behind both the Red Sox (14.6) and your New York Yankees (13.8).
—At no position, save for José Caminero at third, did the Rays field the best player at that position. In fact, save for RF, where they were second, no Ray ranked no higher than fifth in the league at any position.
—The greatest disparity between the Rays and the Yankees came in pitching, which is almost always the difference in baseball. The Yanks, boasting their best starting pitching in 25 years, and what rounded into a highly effective bullpen, were at 13.4 in pitching WAR. The Rays were merely 7th in the AL, at 1.9.
—In other words, with pitching ranked almost TEN TIMES better than Tampa Bay's, the Yankees could not get closer than within 4 1/2 games of the Rays over the regular season, or snag so much as a lead during their playoff series. I don't know if this has ever happened before in the history of baseball, but I would bet that it has not.
—For all the talk about "selfishness" in the Yankees' clubhouse, or Cashman's magical ability to deflect the fault to Aaron Judge—"He said nice things about Verdugo!"...Tampa Bay did not display any great advantage over the Yanks in almost any statistical category, throughout the season.
—In team fielding, the Rays fielded .984, the Yanks, .983. Tampa Bay made 4 fewer errors—the Yankees pulled off 23 more double-plays.
—In team batting the Rays led with an OPS of .728 to .720, and an OPS+ of 103-101—hardly huge differences. The Yankees actually scored more runs, 739-736, and outhomered TB, 223-169. Tampa Bay had all of 11 more steals, 164-153.
—The one big statistical difference came in clutch hitting. TB outhit the Yanks, .258-.235. Also, the Yankees were second in the AL in most strikeouts, at 1,480 and last in total hits, with 1,250. Tampa Bay, by contrast, had the fewest strikeouts in the league, at 1,145, and led all American League teams with 1,405 hits.
—In other words, here is where Cashman's disastrous insistence on playing "Three True Outcomes" baseball came clearly into play. The Rays struck out 335 fewer times, and out of those 355 at-bats, slashed 155 more hits, for an average of .463 "non-strikeout hits." (Stat patent pending.)
—Throughout the World Series, the broadcasters (and everyone else) heaped praise upon the Brewers and Rays for playing baseball "like it should be played," and rightly so.
But it's worth pointing out that the two teams in the Series just last fall—and what were obviously the two best teams in their respective leagues in 2025, the Blue Jays and the Dodgers—hit home runs by the bushelful, belting 191 and 244, respectively, during the regular season, and combining for another 19 during their seven-game set.
—In other words, there are many ways to play winning baseball. Brian Cashman is bad at all of them.
—It's not just that the Yankees stick rigidly with "Three True Outcomes" ball. It's that they don't know how to play that, either.
—The key to the Yanks' failure this postseason was that they had at least five players in their starting lineups—Austin Wells, Ryan McMahon, Jazz Chisholm, Anthony Volpe, and Trent Grisham—who had no business being there, after their repeated and abject failures all season, and in the recent past.
—Remarkably, three of those players—Jazz, Volpe, and Wells—had also made critical mistakes in the infamous, Fifth Inning Fiasco of the 2024 World Series. Two of them, along with McMahon and Grisham, were on the field to make equally disastrous flubs in the first inning of the critical, Game Two of the 2026 ALDS.
—Even more incredibly, the Yanks managed to exhaust their pinch-runners by the end of the final game in that series, put a chronically injured player who had not batted since the end of April up in the two most crucial at-bats of the season, and ended it with Trent Grisham—a player not only injured but awful—up there for the last out, in a one-run game.
The only conclusion possible from all this is that the Yankees—despite one of the greatest advantages in pitching ever seen in their league playoffs—did not even get to the ALCS not because their players were "selfish," or their clubhouse atmosphere was bad, or Aaron Judge said nice things about his teammates, or even because of the general incompetence of Aaron Boone (incompetent managers having won plenty of World Series).
It was because their general manager, Brian Cashman, made once again the same mistakes that he makes year after year, and failed to put the right players on the field—.even after their proven failures in the recent past.