Wednesday, December 18, 2024

Dear Mr. Steinbrenner: Bellinger is a start, but you cannot be done.

Dear Madam or Sir, 

First, thank you, thank you, thank you, for digging deep on Clay Bellinger's boy. I know, I know, I know... technically, it's a trade. But really, it was a purchase: You're taking on a $27 million contract. And skeptics wonder why the Cubs would give up on the guy, as they seem to have done. Doesn't matter. Cody Peteet for Cody Bellinger is a layup. You had no choice. But you followed through. Thanks. 

So, as of today, here's a 2025 Yankee batting order:

1. Jazz Chisholm LH
2. Aaron Judge RH
3. Clay Bellinger LH
4. Giancarlo Stanton RH
5-9. The cast of "Glee." (Wells, Martian, Volpe, Oswaldo, DJ)

Sir, this lineup wins 85 games. It might snag a berth in the expanded, MLB, participation-trophy wild card system. But if The Martian - or anybody, for that matter - flops, or if Judge or Giancarlo turn into Twin Tweaks, we'll spend October watching our Met overlords from below the bar.  

Sir, you cannot be done. This lineup features holes, black and potentially bottomless. We all want Jasson Dominguez to get a shot at replacing Juan Soto - it would be glorious - but we cannot expect it from a 22-year-old. Too much pressure. Too little protection. We must do right by the kid. That means not crushing him.

Sir, you will have to keep writing checks, and your wrist will hurt. There is no alternative. But you do have options among the following free agents.

Alex Bregman. A hated, deceitful Astro, but a professional 3B. Coming off a bad year. (26 HR, .260.) The Mets are on him. You can stab them. (Or, at least, bid up his price.) He's 31. Bats RH. Would move Jazz to 2B, where he should be.

Anthony Santander. Killed us last season as an Oriole. Hit 44 HRs. Career year. Still, he doesn't walk much. His OBP was just .306. Lousy fielder. Would play RF, forcing Judge to CF. He's 30. Switch-hitter, like the Martian. That helps.

Christian Walker. Gold Glove 1B, revered in Colorado, unknown to AL East. Hit 26 HR, .251. - a down year, compared to previous two seasons. Bats RH. He'll turn 34 in March. A slightly younger DJ? 

Pete Alonso. A poke in the eye to the Mets. (But they'd likely pivot to Bregman.)  He's 30, RH. Beloved in NY. Also, comfortable. 

Tanner Scott. Lefty reliever. Appeared in 72 games last year, 22 saves and a 1.75 ERA. He's 30. Remember: Pitching, pitching, pitching. We need him. 

Sir, you need at least one of the above. Better, sign two. The world needs to know that when teams poach Yankee stars - as the Mets, Jays, Redsocks, Dodgers and Padres all set out to do - it shall bring consequences. In this case, a sea-level rise in salaries. 

Sir, as the song says, "It's up to you, New York, New York." Two of the above. Any two will do. Two of the above, and we will stop talking about whazizname. 

10 comments:

13bit said...

I just got a telegram from Ebeneezer Scrooge. It says: HAL DONT CARE. STOP. SEE YOU IN 2027 STOP SCROOGE

JM said...

Jass'on is only 22. Didn't Soto have a ring by then? Wasn't Mickey a star by then? And DiMag, and Gehrig, and Ruth? Yes, unfair comparisons, but he's been discussed like he was the Second Coming of any such superstar. I don't think he is. He might turn out great, or at least really good, which would be terrific. But I don't think he's really Pantheon material. And Jesus H. Montero, kid, learn how to play the outfield.

DickAllen said...

That list reads like the “over the hill gang.”

But given the fact that the Yankees have become a retirement home for has-beens, they should all be a perfect fit.

BTR999 said...

If I had to pick 2 it would be Bregman and Scott. Corner OF and 1B are easier positions to fill, though crashman struggled to do so.

ranger_lp said...

Read somewhere that the Yanks are dangling Spencer Davis...I mean Jones...for trades...

Doug K. said...

"Christian Walker. Gold Glove 1B, revered in Colorado, unknown to AL East. Hit 26 HR, .251. - a down year,"

"Alex Bregman. A hated, deceitful Astro, but a professional 3B. Coming off a bad year. (26 HR, .260.)"

Cody 18HR .266 Yay?

HoraceClarke66 said...

Great analysis, Peerless. I guess I'd go for Pete Alonso—knows New York, eager for revenge—and Scott off that list, which really might "supercharge" the bullpen. But I doubt if we'll get either. Bregman would be all right. The guy we really need to get is Juan Soto...oh, right.

TheWinWarblist said...

None of them, or all of them put together, do not replace my Juan Soto.

TheWinWarblist said...

For the record, if these Yankees were THE NY Yankees, My Juan would be in the lineup with My Judge, My Bryce and My Ohtani. Forever and ever.

So endeth the fucking lesson.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Hear, hear, Warbler! Okay, I guess Ohtani was set on staying in LA, period. But no reason why the likes of Soto, Harper, Realmuto, Seagar, and Machado should not be in the Bronx. And maybe the likes of Yamamoto, and a couple other pitchers.