Friday, February 28, 2025

The Martian is making left field into a place of terror and suspense.

There's a new streaming sci-fi flick, The Gorge, where Anya Taylor-Joy - (last year's IT girl) - plays a gritty military sniper sent to an obscure base and told to shoot whatever emerges from a deep dark canyon, because it threatens humankind. Haven't seen it, but I like the concept. 

It describes our situation in left field - because, right now, whatever emerges may threaten the future of Yankind. 

Why do I say this? Yesterday, Jasson Dominguez botched another fly. 

This one was a misdiagnosed liner to the track, a catchable ball turned into a double - the Martian's 4th defensive goof in four games. His woes in LF have begun to shade not only the 2025 lineup, but the balloon of hype that lifted Dominguez - aka "The Martian" - all winter.

Okay, let's step back. Before I play Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald, let's acknowledge that:

1. It's still February - at least, for today.
2. We're only four games into spring training.
3. This is the time to make mistakes.
4. Dominguez is learning a new position, LF, (though it's not like he's donning a mask and cup.) 

Right now, our main problem is credibility. For years, the Yankee brain trust has hyped Dominguez as a rock-ribbed perfectionist, a tireless student of the game, with the work ethic of a team of huskies. He hungers for self-improvement, takes notes, remembers birthdays, a bone-crushing handshake, forever seeking to elevate the Yankee human condition. 

Unfortunately, over the winter, he does not seem to have worked on his defense in LF. 

Last September, he looked imperiled in left - so lost that the Yankees played a disappointing Alex Verdugo throughout the postseason. The October narrative went that Dominguez would catch flies all winter and report to Tampa with at least a clue. Something has gone wrong. Every fly ball is The Gorge. 

Having built their 2025 lineup around The Martian, the Yanks now seem to have few options, aside from sticking him in LF, closing their eyes and hoping for the best. Giancarlo Stanton's barking elbows might offer a solution:  Dominguez could become a fulltime DH. But, seriously, do we want our top prospect, age 22, without a position? Yikes.

Welp, the hype machine may giveth what it taketh away. Today, The Athletic devotes 800 words to the newest Yankee IT boy, Spencer Jones, who's having a nice spring - .286 with a HR. At 23, Jones could nicely fill the role of breakout OF prospect, if the Martian keeps flubbing flies. 

The problem: Jones last year fanned more than any 200 times, more than any Yankee farmhand in history.

We all know Jones. A former first rounder, who stands 6'6", he's been hyped for years. He'll surely start 2025 in Scranton. Last spring, the story goes, the Yankee brain trust saw a hole in his swing and began retooling his stance blah-blah-blah. That said, Spencer hit .444 in spring training last year - you can look it up - so he couldn't have looked too badly.

Welp, the Yankees have made their bed in LF, and Dominguez is sleeping in it. Whether he can wake up, that's the question. 

But if The Martian cannot play LF... holy crap, are we ever in trouble. I hope they have a sniper, because what emerges from left field could threaten everything. It won't be February for long. 

5 comments:

Doug K. said...

"Dominguez could become a fulltime DH. But, seriously, do we want our top prospect, age 22, without a position? Yikes."

Obviously not but truthfully I could live with it.

I never understood how the DH on many teams is not the lineup's most feared hitter. (Not saying JD is feared by any means. ). There have to be guys who couldn't make it in MLB because all they can do is hit. The position has hitter in its name.

Why doesn't every team find an Edgar Martinez?

Is it better to have DHs who hit .200 but can play a position? Why? Give me Edgar all day every day. And, because he doesn't play the field he can be in the lineup all day every day.

If the guy is 22 or 23 so what? Again, not talking about Jasson who might end up sucking at everything but I'll take a killer as a DH.

Jaraxle said...

It would not be the worst thing if he did become a schwaber like dh, jones has a monster year and takes lf and Stanton rides off into the sunset

JM said...

Sca-a-a-a-ary stuff, keeds.

13bit said...

I would not hold my breath, waiting for Stan to ride anywhere. He would shoot his horse and eat it before he leaves the stage. He’s not gonna go one second before his contract expires. He’s a greedy piece of crap.

Carl J. Weitz said...

I think the problem with playing LF might be in his head. According to his scouting reports, he has an excellent arm and is an outstanding fielder. In center, he had no problems handling the position. They might be better off playing Bellinger in left and The Martian in center.
Here are the scouting reports on him:

From MLB.com:
Here's what the experts at MLB Pipeline have to say about Dominguez:

Scouting grades (20-80 scale)
HIT: 55
POWER: 60
RUN: 65
ARM: 60
FIELD: 55
OVERALL: 55

"The most hyped and tooled-up international prospect in recent memory, Dominguez engenders comparisons to some of the best athletes in baseball history, such as Bo Jackson, Mickey Mantle and Mike Trout. The Yankees spent $5.1 million, all but $300,000 of their bonus pool and a franchise record for an international amateur, to sign him out of the Dominican Republic in July 2019. Some clubs officials thought he might be able to handle making his pro debut in low Class A at age 17 in 2020, but it became a moot point when the coronavirus pandemic scuttled the Minor League season.

"Dominguez not only has the potential for well above-average tools across the board, but he also has the advanced instincts and skills to get the most of them. A switch-hitter, he exhibits a smooth stroke, tremendous bat speed and strength from both sides of the plate. With precocious feel for the barrel and a mature, disciplined approach, he should hit for power and average.

"Dominguez's well above-average speed also allows him to make an impact on the bases and in the outfield. He has 30-30 potential, covers plenty of ground in center field and also features at least a plus arm. His quickness and arm strength would allow him to play almost any position and some teams even worked him out as a catcher, though putting him behind the plate would take a toll on his offensive output."

From Forbes:
Very agile and athletic, it is his speed and first-step quickness that really drew this scout’s attention. Given the new rules in MLB, it should not be difficult for Dominguez to steal bases with ease. If he gets on base enough, he could be among the league leaders in steals.

The initial challenge will be getting on base.

For this scout, Dominguez projects to be a better than average hitter, with emerging power. However, he doesn’t profile as the superstar hitter many projected when the Yankees signed Dominguez.

Defensively, Dominguez plays a solid center field. He has above average first-step quickness.

Dominguez is likely targeted to play center field for the parent Yankees, However, he projects best to this scout as a left fielder. Dominguez has a good arm.

Overall Scouting Grade: 55-a better than average major league player.

Finally, an assessment by an AL and NL scout from 2024:
“He was a different guy on the field than everybody else,” an AL scout who saw Dominguez play recently at Triple-A said on Tuesday. “He looked like he was ready. I think in the Yankees lineup, he’s probably a six or seven-hole kind of guy right now. … He’s got whack, he can run. He brings a lot of things to the table.I didn’t see anything that stood out that would say, ‘He needs more time here.’ ” (AL Scout)
An NL scout who also saw Dominguez play for Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre last month said the switch-hitting 21-year-old “looked surprisingly good for somebody who’s missed all the time that he’s missed.”

“He had pretty good at-bats, surprisingly his timing was good,” the NL scout said Tuesday. “He barreled up some balls really well from the left-handed side of the plate. I only saw one at-bat right-handed. But he looked fine in [batting practice]. Played solid in the outfield.” (NL SCout)