A teaching moment. That's what they're calling the fly ball that dropped into left-center the other day, while a discombobulated Jasson Dominguez watched. It didn't look good. Shades of Inning 5. In fact, the moment has spawned several theories regarding the young left-fielder known as "The Martian."
1) He lost the ball in the Florida sun, which anyone can do.
2) He took a bad route, which inexperienced players can do.
3) He shied away from the onrushing CF Cody Bellinger, which smart players in spring games should do.
4. He - aww, screw it - anybody got Verdugo's number?
Actually, there's no calling Alex Verdugo, or Tim Locastro, or Slade Heathcott, or any of the Lost Legion of Ledee, (as in Rickie) which has haunted the Yankee left field killing grounds since the days of - well - Cody Bellinger's dad, Clay.
Over the years, great Yankee lineups were earmarked by a) a star in CF, b) a big hitter in RF, c) a bedrock catcher, d) a big bat at 1B, and e) a jersey-filler in LF. It could be Chad Curtis. It could be Arturo Lopez. This spring, it's Dominguez, now in his 6th year as the future of the Yankees.
Since 2019, when he received the then-highest signing bonus in history - eclipsing Gary Sanchez - Dominguez has been viewed, unfairly, as our savior. Immediately, he was compared - and this is criminal malpractice for a publicist - to Mickey Mantle and Mike Trout. You can look it up. The Yankees actually churned out such bullshit, basically consigning Dominguez to a career of disappointments.
To make matters worse, in his upper teens, Dominguez bulked up. The brain trust started comparing his physique to an NFL running back (which guaranteed nothing, in terms of his ability to hit.) At one point, it was suggested that he'd play 1B - a death sentence for a kid who stands 5'9." At every step, they heaped pressure on him. You'd almost think they held that big bonus against him. (In the name of Kei Igawa, they wouldn't do such a thing, would they?)
So, here we are. At age 22, Dominguez is being handed the keys to LF, no competition. He faces a sink-or-swim spring that, frankly, could tank his and our seasons. If The Martian gets off to a bad start, a lotta shit's gonna start flowing downhill. Remember how, two years ago, we thought Anthony Volpe would thrive, and how difficult it's been for him to assume Derek Jeter's legacy?
I think Yankee fans have been subliminally programmed to expect Dominguez to replace Juan Soto. That's ridiculous. And it's dangerous.
Thus far, on the spring, he is 0-4 with a walk and a run - and a fly ball that coulda/shoulda been caught.
Listen: If Dominguez plays 10 years, and maybe makes an all-star roster, and maybe hits 200 HRs, and maybe wins a ring, that would be a fine career... for anybody else.
Insert sigh here.
Whatever happens, I probably won't live long enough to see Dominguez get called out for an ovation on Old Timers Day. He's probably the last Great Yankee Hype in my lifetime - and in the traditions of Steve Whitaker, Jackson Melian and Ruben Rivera, there have been some doozies. Still, in the lore of baseball, he is already entrenched:
There is one Babe. One Iron Horse. And now, one Martian.
That's really cool. Or really sad.
Let's hope he's a good learner. It's getting late for teaching moments.
15 comments:
"I got it...I got it...I got it...I don't got it."
Opening Day 2026: " And now.....in left field....the 2025 AL Rookie of the Year-Jasson Dominguez!"
"for anybody else" - You nailed, it, Duque. We have created such high hopes for this guy - and it's not our fault that we construct a Ruthian overlay on every poor shlep who has a hot flash in the minors. We're just fans. But I think it was Hoss the other day who pointed out that big talents usually shine early and keep shining. There are very few late-bloomers in baseball or any sport - the body won't cooperate. Board games, maybe, but physical endeavors, not so much. And this guy is possibly getting worse. Is it the "lack of focus" disease that has hit? ICS (Dirty Sanchez, for those of you who aren't familiar with Ice Cream Sandwiches) may have infected the whole organization with such a virulent strain that they are still trying to contain it, just like the measles outbreak in West Texas. Is one of our trainers the equivalent of RFK Junior, a debunker of basic baseball science? We don't know. We don't know because Brian is an idiot and Hal - despite spending a lot of money on the team - allows Cashman to remain in his job. The buck must stop somewhere and that's where I place it. I love you all.
AND DON'T FORGET - ON MARCH 28TH, WE ARE MEETING UP AT A TAVERN JUST SOUTH OF 14TH STREET AND 8TH AVENUE TO DISCUSS REALITY AND FANTASY, TO EVALUATE THE STATE OF THE YANKEE UNION AND TO WEEP A BIT INTO OUR BEER AND QUESADILLAS/BURGERS/FRIED CLAMS, YOU NAME IT.
I cannot commit to March 28, but I will try. (Will still be digging out of snow in Syracuse.) And I certainly approve of the gathering.
JD was never going to live up to the overheated hype the Yankee PR. Machine churned out. In truth, he doesn’t have to. A solid 20/20 performer should be enough (the girls in analytics are clutching their pearls at the mere thought of those stolen bases). However, he does have to learn how to catch a fly ball.
Is it a failure of the Yankees coaching? Is there such a thing as a fielding case of the yips? JD for DH?
We will do recon for a game in mid-summer.
This mid-summer game may be challenging for me to commit to and attend, however I will pretend that I’m at a game on the 28th and that this tavern is Yankee Stadium. Therefore allow me to apologize in advance for any moment where I suddenly stand up and scream, YOU’RE ALL BUMS!
I can't get over a ballplayer with years of experience in organized baseball who can't catch flies. Incredible. Hell, I was able to do it when I was younger and I didn't have any talent to speak of.
Unreal.
The great Ron Carey!
Thanks for the shout-out, Bitty, though I think that was originally an Alphonso eureka moment. But it's true—and even for board games, I think. Aren't most chess champs at their best when young?
Actually, Yankees in LF were often pretty good—and it's where we showed off our depth.
Bullet Bob Meusel—if Ruth chose to play right. Ben Chapman, George Selkirk, Tommy Henrich, Hank Bauer, Gene Woodling, Ellie Howard, Yogi, Roy White, Lou Piniella, Ken Griffey, Sr., Rickey Henderson, Hideki, Melky, Johnny Damon, Brett Gardner all took turns out there—often overlapping.
Yes, Chad Curtis was a step down. But he was platooned with the likes of Ledee, Shane Spencer, Chili Davis, Tim Raines, Darryl Strawberry, etc.
Those were the days when our quality came in bunches.
I will not be able to meet you this Friday. I have a special day and evening planned with my Lovely and Delightful Partner. Next time you crusty misanthropes.
"It gets late early out there."
Winny - it’s at the end of March!
Post a Comment