I almost hope Granderson never hits another home run as a Yankee. We gave up "Johnny on the Spot" and "An upper-decki from Hideki" for an obscure reference to a 1947 Broadway musical, Finnian's Rainbow. This is the most disappointing anticipated-quote since Neil Armstrong stepped on the moon. There must have been a thousand suggestions left on the 10,000 Yankee blogs, and this sure wasn't one of them.
From Sterling's Rainbow
TOMMY: I hadn't noticed
When thou art near
My heart feels so sugar candish
My head feels so ginger beer