Sunday, March 25, 2018

Imagine a Yankee team without one big lefty slugger. Right now, that's us.

Greg Bird was going to shock the world this summer, just as he did Andrew Miller last October. He would bat third or fourth, up high, the big lefty bat sandwiched into a thicket of right-handed power. He would see meaty fastballs, like slabs of honey-glazed bacon in a breakfast buffet, and he would uphold a Yankee tradition dating back to Gehrig - including Chris, Donny, Tino, even Daryl Strawberry on occasion - the lefty power stroke at 1B. He was our secret sure thing. Nothing could stop it. 

And now, well, thank you, juju gods. Thank you, very much.

By now, you know that Bird has flown to Gotham for MRI and divining rod tests on the same barking ankle that sabotaged most of 2017, and if you want to inspire rank Yankee pessimism, all you need do is check Bird's personal history, which reads like the ship log for the Titanic. If Bird loses another year to injuries, he will make Jacoby Ellsbury look like Iron Man Joe McGinnity, morphing into the party guest who never arrives, the player who gives prospect-huggers a bad name on fan forums. Whenever an aging veteran pops up in future trade talks, angry fans will opine what the Yankees could have gotten, if only they were willing to trade Bird when his stock was high. His name will become shorthand for unseen potential. 

Last year, the Yankees waited three months for Bird to return, to be rewarded with a great young hitting first-baseman in September. But considering the team's plans to chase a championship in 2018, it's hard to imagine them waiting on Bird a second time. 

And right now, here are the candidates for first base:

1. Neil Walker, the recently signed free-agent. He's a switch-hitter. Last year, at age 31, he hit 14 HRs and batted .265. He gets on base. It's hard to see him playing 140 games at first, but he could serve as LH platoon with...

2. Tyler Austin, 26, a righty. Last year, sidelined by his own injuries, he did next to nothing in the majors, but at Scranton, he hit .275 with 10 HRs. On the day before Bird left for tests, Austin was optioned to Triple A. He's probably back on the beam. 

3. Mike Ford, 25, who was returned from Seattle yesterday, after being chosen last December in the Rule 5 draft. He was hitting .259 with 2 HRs this spring, but was blown out by another guy in the competition for first-base. Last year, at Trenton, he hit .272 with 13 HRs, and he's known for his discerning ability to draw walks. He bats LEFT... a perfect fit, except the Yankee coaches haven't had a good chance to assess him this spring.

4. Billy McKinney, 23, a converted corner outfielder, who also bats LEFT. He hit 5 HRs this spring, but his batting average fell to .171. He was never seriously considered a candidate for 1B, not enough experience there. Now, with Ford at Scranton, he will probably get pushed back into the Scranton outfield, where he is blocked by Clint Frazier. He increasingly looks like a trade chip. 

5. Miguel Andujar, the former future Yankee third-baseman, who now was supposed to be learning first-base at Scranton. With Ford and McKinney in the mix, I don't know how the Yankees will handle this. Maybe they can play two guys at first base, let them switch each inning!

6. Adam Lind, 34, whom the Yankees released a week ago. He bats left, and was blocked by Bird. They might bring him back?

Strange how the fates work. On the day Bird leaves, Ford returns, looking exactly like what they need. Yet the coaches didn't get to see him, so he's destined for Scranton, where everything already is clogged to the pores. 

But without Bird, the Yankees big lefty-hitter is Didi Gregorius. Suddenly, we can imagine Bronx weekends with RH-starters stacked against us. Can the Yankees win without a big lefty slugger? We might soon find out. With Bird, it's hard not to think the worst. 

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

WHAT A DISASTER.

IT MAKES ME THINK, "WAS BIRD HURT THE ENTIRE SPRING?"

HE DIDN'T LOOK GOOD OR HIT THE ENTIRE SPRING, YET THE ARTICLES KEPT COMING OUT ABOUT HOW THAT DOESN'T MATTER BECAUSE HE IS HEALTHY. (EVEN BIRD CHIMED IN ABOUT THAT).

NOW, THIS (JUST DAYS BEFORE THE SEASON).

WTF IS WRONG WITH THIS GUY?

HOW DOES SOMEONE KEEP GETTING HURT, WHEN NO ONE CAN SEE (INCLUDING HIM), HOW HE GOT HURT???

I SEE THE RETURN OF ADAM LIND, WHICH SHORT TERM, MAY NOT BE A BAD THING.

.....BUT WHAT ABOUT LONG TERM?

HERE IS WHAT ELSE I SEE.....

IF BIRD IS LOST FOR 2 MONTHS OR MORE, IT PROBABLY WILL BE THE END OF HIS YANKEE CAREER.

SHORT TERM- ADAM LIND

LONG TERM- JUSTIN BOUR

WE ARE NOW GOING TO HAVE TO TRADE OUR POWER PROSPECTS ON A FIRST BASEMAN (BOUR), AND WON'T HAVE ENOUGH FOR THE "OVER THE TOP" PITCHER WE NEED IN JULY.

I KEPT SAYING WE ARE ONE LEFTY HITTER SHORT IN OUR LINEUP, (EVEN WITH BIRD).

NOW, WE ARE 2 LEFTIES SHORT. WE DON'T HAVE ENOUGH BALANCE IN THE LINEUP.

FUCKING DISASTER.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Nah, this is where we have to give Ford his shot. Not saying we're going to—but we should!

The guy is an on-base machine, and now has good power. The brass doesn't like him because he went to Princeton. Hell, I don't like him because he went to Princeton.

But what the hey...I seem to recall that we once had a pretty good Ivy Leaguer at first base. What was his name again...

Local Bargain Jerk said...


This is crappy news no matter how you slice it. The icing on the cake will come later this week when Randy Levine questions Bird's integrity and ability to play through pain.

Alphonso said...

No one has said anything about which of these names is the better first baseman. Everyone talks about offense. On base percentage; power, etc. The important thing at that spot is defense. Anything else you get is a bonus.

Is Ford a slick defender? A gold glove at Scranton? Is Lind? Is Austin? Walker is not a first baseman and if you are not a first baseman, you can't play the damn position.

Maybe we can trade him for Baumgartner., as soon as they both leave the hospital.

ranger_lp said...

No one has said why Ford was returned? Damaged goods? Ford sucks so much he can't make the majors? Seattle is being nice to us? Does anyone know that answer?

Anonymous said...

Have to agree with Fonz on this one - - having been a 1B-man, in the days when I could at least do a credible imitation of running the bases...in my book, the best 1B-men are those who are great with the glove, the throwing-arm, and the brain - - though batting lefty - - in the case of our beloved Team - - and having power is, of course, a close second.

Let's wait a bit for things to shake out, before we do anything drastic, shall we??
LB (No J) (hung-over from birthday-partying - - hope you can excuse)

Anonymous said...

NO DISRESPECT HOSS, BUT THERE IS ZERO SHOT FORD GETS ANY CHANCE TO MAKE THE BIG CLUB.

I DON'T EVEN THINK WE THINK ENOUGH OF HIM TO PUT HIM IN TRIPLE A. (HE MAY BE SENT TO DOUBLE A FIRST).

YOU KNOW HOW ONCE WE DON'T TAKE A PROSPECT SERIOUSLY, HE IS NEVER REALLY GIVEN A TRUE SHOT.

FORD IS IN THAT CLASS.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Sadly, you are probably right, ALL-CAPS. My hope, though, is that having Tyler Austin back on the big club gets him to Scranton, at least, and there he is so impressive that he cannot be denied. Hey, I can dream, can't I?

The great thing about Ford is that he would be that lefty power bat between all our righties. You add in all the walks, and yes, while I know our Dauntless Leader was joking, he is even a decent defender.

Why Seattle gave up on him? Who knows? It seems another 1B did better in the spring, and of course with reserves being so limited now, they probably didn't have anywhere to put him. We do—for now. I just hope he gets a shot.

Isiyku Abdulahi said...


I really want the world to know about this great man who brought back happiness into my life again after my husband left me and the kids 3 years ago for another women online when i contacted Dr Believe he cast a love spell for me within 48 hours my ex husband start calling me and begging for forgiveness for everything that have happened between us. I was so happy to have my family back together with love again here is the email of Dr Believe via believelovespelltemple@gmail.com a man with the great powers you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2348156148821
God bless you
I am very grateful for your help in my marriage.