Traitor Tracker: 250

Traitor Tracker: 250
Last year, this date: .307

Tuesday, August 5, 2025

The Results Are In!

While this blog lacks the resources of the New York Times and its infamous needle, the early returns on the trade deadline are in… time for a deep dive.

The Good

McMahon

So nice to see a third baseman who can really play the position. Even if his hitting reverts to the mean, give me a guy who takes away doubles all day.  Saves the pitchers, saves the pen, and it’s nice to see “Wow” plays.

The Good With a Caveat

Bednar

Bednar will eventually be our closer or, if the powers that be, or hopefully the powers that be-gone soon, let Weaver close, then he will be a solid set up man and we have him next year as well.

It would have been better the Yankees didn’t give up Rafael Flores. Not too sure Wells is going to be what we hoped and having a catcher who can really hit waiting in the wings seemed like a good idea.  

The Sure, Why Not?

Rosario 

Did we need another utility man? Also an 800 OPS does not a righty masher make. He does hit for contact.

Some guy for Peraza plus international bonus pool money.

Peraza was toast and who doesn’t like international bonus pool money?

Caballero for Pereira and a PTBNL and Cash.

At first I was really excited. Trading Cash! Then I realized they meant money. 

So close…

The Bad

Where to begin…

Doval

A lot of people in NY like the Doval trade but living in Northern California I have access to a lot of friends/acquaintances/neighbors/fans on the street who are SF Giants fans and EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM was glad to see him go.

The consensus is that he’s a "me first" baby with a lot of talent but can’t harness it and is prone to meltdowns. Maybe they can slip him the “supplement” that they give Rodon but apparently that wears off.

Also, after having a rough first outing, he threw his teammates under the bus. 

He was using a translator who altered what he said to make more palatable but, he said in Spanish something along the lines of his bad outing was due to “events outside his control” (Meaning the error) and didn’t take responsibility for the blown save. 

Don’t like him. Don’t like the trade.

Jake Bird for Roc Riggio and Ben Shields. 

Seriously?  A flyer on a future lug nut who has already coughed up two games and is looking for a motel room in Scranton as we speak?  

Riggio can hit and play second and if you think Jazz is getting re-signed after next year, he’s not.  

First of all Jazz is going to spend most of next year recovering from surgery to remove Girardi’s foot from his ass.

Shields floor is Bird’s ceiling.  

How is Bird all they could have gotten for those two guys?

The Laughable

Austin Slater for… it doesn’t matter.

Even a bag of balls has more use than a guy who pulls a hammy in his first at bat.  His first at bat?  His. First. At. Bat.

Wow.  Just Wow.

The only saving grace is that he hurt himself before he hurt the team .

--

In Conclusion 

Maybe not the slam dunk, "Yankees win the trade deadline!" we were led to believe. 

 

 

8 comments:

BTR999 said...

I guess Bird is the (first) sacrificial lamb

TheWinWarblist said...

Look, I like a good slug of Kool-Aid as much as the next guy, but you have to lay off that stuff if it's making you believe the bullshit the Gammonites are spouting about the trade deadline.

DickAllen said...

MLB.com had this to say:

"An MRI showed no acute damage to his ulnar collateral ligament, and he had a platelet-rich injection July 27.

No acute damage?

Can you say Tommy John surgery, boys and girls?

13bit said...

Pass the crackpipe, laddies...

Mildred Lopez said...

I went and did it today, disconnected myself from the YES network. Technically won't go dark on me until the 27th so I have three more weeks of "the best team in baseball".

What a slog this season has become. Least fun, least likable Yankees team since ..... last year's team.



TheWinWarblist said...

Sing it Mildred. Sing it loud and strong.

Publius said...

Judge in the lineup. Welcome back, big guy. Take some hacks against the best pitcher in the AL.

Publius said...

Needless to say, Cashman's Yankees cannot play Judge and Stanton at the same time.