Friday, November 20, 2026

Brian Cashman is "drinking water from a firehose."

 


That was one of Cashie's comments from last night when, as he staged his annual "sleep out"—this time at Yankee Stadium—reporters were actually able to ask him things.


The sleep out, of course, was done to promote giving to Cashman's longtime charity, Covenant House, which does indeed do good work. Brian told reporters that he expected that holding it at the Stadium—"the most impactful night at Yankee Stadium all year!"—to raise some $2.5 million, probably in good part from the other, 500 sleep-outers who were on hand.

A more churlish individual than I might object to Cashie's use of the awful word, "impactful," or point out that 10 times that $2.5 mill would probably be pocket change to Brian's boss. 

Another such churl might note how the charity events that Mr. Cashman seems to participate in are heavily oriented around his own, starring role—such as his famous rappelling down a building in Stamford, Connecticut every December, usually dressed as an elf, in the cause of...something.

These displays seem awfully ostentatious, as opposed to how we're supposed to just quietly go around doing good, instead of bringing all the attention to yourself like it says in that Bible thingie, but who am I to say?

Who are any of us?  

I'm sure that Covenant House and drab Stamford skyscrapers are both great causes, and whatever Brian can do, he should do, and our thanks to him.

Of course, one of those pesky reporters on hand also had the temerity to ask him questions related to his day job of running a baseball team. 

None, of course, so impertinent as to question why his inherited-billionaire boss, Hal Steinbrenner, is leading the charge to wreck the sport of baseball this holiday season—just on the off-chance that he might be forced to spend as little on his team as possible.

Instead, the Knights of the Pressbox hinted coyly, here and there, about just what Cashie might be up to—if anything at all—to improve said baseball team. Hence the remark about how just now, Brian is dealing with SO many queries from agents and other GMs that it's "like drinking water from a firehose."

Beyond that, someone dared to ask something specific. That is, just what he intended to do about the gaping sinkhole that opened at third base this year. To which Cashie, removing his head from the firehose stream for a moment, could only inform us—in his usual, Byzantine way of conversing:

"We're having those conversations including recognition that Ryan McMahon is a better player than what we saw last year."

Well, maybe ol' Brian was in what Shakespeare called, "the giving mood."

Because in fact, McMahon was not. There is no indication that Ryan McMahon ever was, or ever will be a better player than what we saw all last year.

I don't mean to only dwell on M. McMahon's dreadful error to open Game 2 of the ALDS. Actually, to be perfectly truthful, I DO mean to dwell on it, and will dwell on it until the day I die, whenever I see the words "Ryan" or "McMahon" or "error."

But I digress.

Truth is, that it was not just that dreadful choke in the playoffs that defined Ryan McMahon's year, but the whole season—not to mention the entire, 188 games he has played for your New York Yankees.

McMahon—another, abominable Cashman deadline acquisition—has hit a combined .211/.289/.349/.638 with the Yankees in the regular season. (He was all of 5-21 in postseason games, before even Boone benched him in the ALDS.) 

Certainly, that's well below the .240/.323/.420/.743 he posted in Colorado, right? 

But even Brian Cashman is aware—isn't he?—that the Colorado Rockies play a-way up high in the thunder peaks, where the air is thin, the mountain goats roam, and the ball travels far.

LIFETIME—spent almost entirely with the Rockies—LIFETIME, anywhere and everywhere OUTSIDE the friendly confines of Coors Field, Ryan McMahon is a .213/.295/.354/.649 hitter.

Or, YES, almost exactly the same player he was with the Yankees last year, or in 2025.

But wait, I hear you say! Wasn't Ryan McMahon renowned both far and near for his outstanding glove work???

Well, kinda.

It's true that McMahon has a lifetime 10.7 defensive WAR, including an NL-leading 2.7 back in 2021. But that WAR figure had diminished a good deal before he got to the Yanks.

Over the years, McMahon did lead the NL in putouts, assists, and fielding percentage, one year apiece, and three times in range factor.

But...he also led the Senior Circuit three times in most errors committed. 

In other words: once again, Ryan McMahon WAS ALMOST EXACTLY LAST YEAR WHAT HE HAS ALWAYS BEEN...a terrible hitter under earth's full gravity, as well as an erratic and declining fielder.

On Dec. 14th, Ryan will turn 32—hardly an age when most players improve, especially in the field. But the New York Yankees will continue to put him out on third base not because he's about to have a big comeback year, or because they knew the steel of his character or the cut of his jib.

And not because there isn't a promising, younger replacement—just 27!—readily available, for money alone, in the Japanese free-agent, Teruaki Sato.

They will put McMahon back out there because he is owed another $16 million by the Yankees. And because if there is one thing that Hal Steinbrenner absolutely cannot tolerate, it is forcing bad players who make a lot of money to stop hurting his team.

Maybe Brian should get his face out of the firehose from time to time.






 

  




1 comment:

AboveAverage said...

I just hope that they either washed that Hal and Pal Sack several times in
the clubhouse's industrial uniform washers on the sterilize setting or just tossed it into an empty dumpster somewhere close to the stadium when no one was looking.

Ewwwwwwww.

Happy Friday Everyone and Enjoy your Weekends.

AA.