Yesterday, Anthony Volpe - aka: "Teacher's Pet" - had another one of those games.
He came up three times. He struck out three times.
He missed a gettable grounder, wasn't charged with an error, then bounced a throw to first, and was.
He was why the Yankees, in the late innings, replaced 1B Ben Rice - whose HR basically won the game - with Paul Goldschmidt, a superior glove, though hobbled with injury.
In the AL, Volpe ranks last in almost every offensive category. On defense, he leads the league in errors, with 19.
Of course, you already know this. Everybody does. When Volpe emerges from the dugout, the whispers begin, and a sense of dread diffuses throughout the stadium. This is not a glitch, or a slump, or a gutsy guy toiling through injuries. This is his third crapola season in three long years. This is normalcy. This is a reality the Yankees refuse to accept, and it may cost them the AL East, or another postseason. (Last year's ended, more or less, when Volpe botched a throw to third, extending their Doomsday 5th Inning, which - Fun Fact - is constantly on replay in Yankee Fan Hell.)
A home town boy, Volpe is getting booed at Yankee Stadium. In pivotal moments, he is being replaced by pinch hitters. More and more, he is being "rested." It does not work. In an era when star shortstops anchor batting orders - Witt, Bichette, Pena, Henderson, et al - Volpe is failing at both ends of the spectrum.
Full disclosure: I've loved Volpe since spring of 2023 - "Volpening Day," we called it - when he unexpectedly came north with the team as its starting SS, the Jersey boy! the next Jeter! the future of the Yankees! We drank the Kool-Aid: He would settle the infield, grow into a star, become a team leader.
Well, it hasn't worked. Not since Joe Pepitone has more fan emotion and spirit been painfully poured into a Yankee disappointment. (Of course, Volpe is not Pepi, who squandered his great talent. Volpe is earnest and hard-working; in many respects, that only makes it harder to deal with. It's quite possible that Volpe's best chance to save his career will require a change of address - outside of New York.)
But but BUT... the Yankees do have a lifeline: Jose Caballero, a base-stealing terror. He's not perfect. No power. It's not certain whether he can play SS over the long haul.
But this isn't a long haul. It's three weeks - then the playoffs.
It's time to learn whether Caballero can handle the position. (Actually, the Yankees should have tried Caballero two weeks ago. Trump derisively calls Jerome Powell "Too Late." He should have saved that nickname for Aaron Boone.)
And if Caballero blows it? Well, there might be a flashing light at the end of the Scranton coal tunnel. Andrew Valezsquez - age 31, born in the Bronx and a grad of Fordham Prep - has been the Railriders SS since mid-August. He's a switch-hitter, batting .252 with 5 HRs and 24 stolen bases. He's tiny - 5'8" and 170 pounds. He's been around the block, many times - played for the Yankees back in 2021. That year, he hit .225 - lame, eh?But it's 17 points higher than Volpe. It's time to see what other options the Yankees have. If everything else fails, maybe it has to be Volpe. But this isn't working, and yesterday, it almost cost the Yankees their most important win of the season. Time's up.