Sunday, July 16, 2023

For Josh Donaldson and Yankee fans, our long national nightmare is over

Last night, Jackie Donaldson hit an invisible juju god while running out a grounder, and it was all he could do just to shamble towards the dugout like Liza Minelli after a sixpack of Coors Light. He's out for what... four weeks? Six? Eight? Until September? Until Doomsday? Until somebody gives a shit? Because around here, I have the distinct feeling that nobody does.  

Basically, the sinkhole that opened at 3B right around this time last year just unleashed a loud, satisfying belch, as if to say (in native sinkholese:) "Who's next?"

Another Cashmanic trade acquisition - now, long past his sell-by date - will likely end another painful Yankee career in the jacuzzi, while YES truthers faithfully update us on his healing process. We will know when Donaldson can bend over to tie his shoe. We will know when he can it a ball off a tee. We will know when he can eat spaghetti with a fork and spoon, without dolloping sauce onto his chest. 

And with a little luck, we won't see him again.  

Look, I hate being so negative about a Yankee player. If Donaldson had hit for us, if he were five years younger, he'd be one of my faves. In fact, I resent having to root for an endless stream of former stars, who are woefully overwhelmed in their final career incarnations. I'll give credit to Donaldson for valiantly maintaining his defense at 3B, while his bat turned to foam rubber. But his numbers for the 2023 season are an exercise in pain tolerance. On the year, he ranks:

6th on the team in HRs, with 10
13th in RBIs, with 15 (behind Willie Calhoun)
20th in batting average, with .142 (behind Franchy Cordero) 
19th in on-base percentage, with .225 (ahead of Franchy Cordero)

Often, just as they seem ready to pull out of massive slumps, Yankee vets tweak something. (On that note, beware of Giancarlo Stanton, everybody.) That's not the case with Donaldson. Over the last 30 days, he was hitting .150. Over the last 14 days, .138. Over the last seven, .100. To watch Donaldson come to the plate with runners on base was like channeling George C. Scott in the movie "Hardcore," where he screams at the screen, "TURN IT OFF! TURN IT OFF!" And yet, we still watched...

So, now what? Presumably, we will finally get to see what Oswald Peraza can do at the MLB level, at least before the Yankees shop him around for another aging veteran. 

Nobody knows what this team will look like on Aug. 2, after Cashman disassembles the roster in his annual trade deadline game of Scrabble. But many of us were wondering if the Yankees would DFA Donaldson, allowing him to sign with another team, and maybe resurrect his dead career (as Aaron Hicks did with Baltimore.)

Well, Donaldson - (and our true hero, that invisible juju god) - just nixed that concern. Unless Peraza goes 0-for-July, the Yankee offense just improved. I don't think we'll see Donaldson again in a Yankee uniform, and that's okay. 

85 comments:

BTR999 said...

Good thing we signed Jake Lamb, eh?

el duque said...

If they bring up Lamb, we riot.

AboveAverage said...

Watching the way Doneldson ran out that ball last night reminded me of when I was playing our version of pee wee baseball as a child. We were all around seven or eight years old. This kid on the other team pooped in his pants while in the batters box just before hitting a ground ball to the second baseman. He tried to hide it. But the way he grimaced and jiggled as he did his best to run to first base and his parents suddenly whisking the boy off the field, we all knew what happened.

Perhaps the same thing happened to Jackie last night.

No calf or groin or hammy tweak.

No, Sir.

Perhaps…

Colorado cramping led to a

a mile-high mistake

and a pepto-putout

Looking forward to Meredith Marakovits and Jeff Nelson updating us about Jackie’s injury during today’s matchup.

The Archangel said...

I'll bring the mint jelly El Duque

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Peraza isn't the only kid the Yankees should bring up today.

Doctor T said...

Donaldson had a fine career. But he's done. If the Yankees DFA'd him, nobody would pick him up. But, so long as he's injured, the Yankees can recoup salary from the insurance company and his spot on the roster is open. So no pressure, Josh. Enjoy the hot tub. We don't blame you. We blame Cashman.

I hope they bring up Peraza, but he's played only 7 games at 3rd base in his career and 5 of them were with the Yankees. The next most ready is career AAA player, James Westbrook, but he's primarily a 2nd baseman. After that, they have the not-yet-ready, Andrés Chaparro, a powerful, young kid, who has almost as many strikeouts as hits in his career (408 K's,418 H's) and unimpressive fielding stats.

My crystal ball sees DJ carrying 3rd for the rest of the season and Peraza riding the Scranton Shuttle until he runs out of options, gets traded for broken parts or Cashman is fired. As always, I pray for the last option.

Doug K. said...

How about...

DJ and IKF share third. Gleyber is traded as part of a package for a real left fielder. Peraza plays short. (His actual position.) Volpe to 2nd (Where he should be long term.)

I know it ain't going to happen but it should. That's your strongest defense anyway and the guy who plays left will be a better LF and add some hitting. If Peraza struggles with the bat he should still be better than Jackie in the line up with a ton more upside.

edb said...

Unfortunately Perraza's stats have dipped. Knowing the Yankees, they will throw DJ and Cabrera out there. Not having to watch Jackie, as you call him, can only be a plus.

The Hammer of God said...

There is something bothering me about the movie "Hardcore" with George C. Scott. I saw it on tv once. I thought it hilarious, the moment with Scott roaring "turn it off" was one for the ages. But there is a scene where Scott sets up a sting, hoping to catch the guy who kidnapped his daughter, or something like that. Scott puts out an ad that he's a porno movie maker looking for hunks to come (and come again). There is a big one who comes in but Scott (knowing it's not him) says thanks and he'll call him if he chooses the guy. The hunk, thinking he is getting passed over, starts bellowing about his accomplishments. But, for the life of me, I can't remember whether that guy said "I jerk off TEN times a day" or was it "I jerk off TWELVE times a day". Ten or twelve? Ten or twelve? Is it ten or is it twelve? This is killing me. Hmmmmmm.

AboveAverage said...

I vote that Doug should be the next GM of the Yankees (if he chooses to accept the mission).

Because the setup should be exactly as he says above.

These next two weeks sure will be interesting . . .

And Hammer - it seems like you need to dust your your laser disc player, buy a copy of Hardcore and give it a spin. Let us know what you find out.

AboveAverage said...

For Kevin:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beast_of_Blood_(film)

JM said...

Quick. Name the current or last Yankees to wear numbers 10 and 12.

BTR999 said...

Donaldson to IL
Peraza recalled

AboveAverage said...

Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Mr Money Store?

Rufus T. Firefly said...

not the huckleberry

BTR999 said...

12 - IKF
10 - Rick Cerone

JM said...

ding ding ding!

JM said...

Well, we got Peraza, finally. Let's see how Boone fucks him up by playing him in unfamiliar positions.

At least the new batting coach might help him. I say that with a straight face. OK, semi-straight. Honestly? Kind of giggling.

Ya never know.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Munson was my favorite player. Not his fault, but I never liked Cerrone for that stupid reason. And it looked like he had a disco perm.

AboveAverage said...

should the mets and the yankees swap managers?

Doug K. said...

Rufus,

Mine too. Then Mattingly. Then Matsui. No one since.

Vampifella said...

I'd be surprised if they release Donaldson before the start of next year. He's guaranteed 8 million and it's only another 8 million to keep him. If healthy and having a mere 2-3 war season, he'd be worth that 8 million extra as anything better would cost more than that and they probably don't have any rookies to fill in that could do much better. If injured, then the insurance kicks in. I can see him being released if his numbers are terrible and he's perfectly healthy around the All-Star game though.

AboveAverage said...

Doug - I was saddened to see that Rodon took Matsui's number.

BTR999 said...

This is the 5th time in his career JD is out with an injured calf.
Sadly, I don’t think we’ve seen the last of him.
DJLM at 3rd today, Peraza on a plane.

Carl J. Weitz said...

@ Dr T....The Yankees would likely collect nothing in insurance settlement for Donaldson because the shortest waiting period to collect (and the highest premium paid) is 90 days. Additionally, he's only signed for this season which means the team would not collect a dime for Jackie.

Also, I believe that according to MLB rules, when a player is injured ( placed on the IL) the only DFA option is to request a MiLB rehab assignment which a player can refuse with 5 years MLB service under their belt. Almost no player does refuse that assignment but could. But outright releasing a player while on the IL is verboten. Of course, once he's off the IL, they can use the other DFA options. But in practical terms, no team would claim at his salary so the Yankees would be on the hook for another 11 million ( approximately) plus the 4 million buy-out. This brings us back to Hal who would rather have a toe severed than pay 15 million and let him go to another team for nothing in return.

Carl J. Weitz said...

Verboten until the current season has ended*

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Doug,

Of course Mattingly. Out of Evansville. Then of course, if you're counting pitchers, a certain Panamanian...

Carl J. Weitz said...

What the Yankees should do, would have done under George, and will never do under Hal is to make a trade for Arenado should he really become available before the trading deadline in roughly 2 weeks.

TheWinWarblist said...

Could the team surgeon please amputate that putrescent gangrenous fuckers leg?

BOTH OF THEM????

Unwavering positivity.

Doctor T said...

@ Carl J Weitz: Agreed, the Yankees aren't DFA'ing Donaldson. Not while he's injured for all the reasons you detailed. Plus, Cashman's default position is that he would rather pay 20 million to warehouse a player, than let them go and watch him be productive somewhere else. (That said, I'm shocked he DFA'd Hicks. But - as with the hitting coach - Cashman is getting nervous about his job security, so he's throwing ballast over the side.)

According to Baseball Reference, the Yankees can buy out Donaldson's contract for 8 million next season. I would be surprised if they don't. His 2-year Yankee .207/.293/.385 slash line impresses nobody. And he'll be 38 next year. Even Cashman can say goodbye to that. Much as he loves antique cars... er, ballplayers.

AboveAverage said...

Unwaveringly Funny, Winny

JM said...

Today's Colorado starter has an ERA over 18.00 in his last four starts (he's 0-4).

Guess which team hasn't been able to hit him so far?

JM said...

Colace.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Time for Rizzo to get out of his slump.

BTR999 said...

Amazing how Rizzo has turned into IKF. 2 months without a HR.

He needs to come out of the lineup. If Bauers is healthy, he is a natural 1B; If not trashman can add a 1B man with offensive ability to the shopping list.

ranger_lp said...

We have hit into 13 outs so far and NO runs…FFS…

ranger_lp said...

15

JM said...

Helping Anderson bolster his confidence. We're a charitable organization now, aiding disadvantaged pitchers by deliberately not hitting.

ranger_lp said...

And we walk the #9 hitter FFS…

BTR999 said...

Rockies say no thank you’s needed for the runs they gifted us.

BTR999 said...

Cole dealing, but the pitch count means a bullpen game.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Thank you ump!

BTR999 said...

aaaaaaand there’s your game! Gone like yesterday!

Carl J. Weitz said...

I think it's only 4 million.

BernBabyBern said...

The Yankees lose games in the worst ways.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Surprised the Master didn't call for a squeeze there.

BTR999 said...

Really stupid play by Peraza.

With 2 outs he would likely score from 2nd on a hit anyway.
Who is teaching these young players how to run the bases?
They should fire every coach in the org and just start over.

JM said...

Yeah, well....on a hit. Haven't been a lot of those.

JM said...

Do the Yankees have a rally in their spleens?

BTR999 said...

More bad baserunning. Can’t spell Bader without B-A-D
Boone too slow to challenge
Bad team, bad manager…

mik said...

Why does it take Boone so long to challenge? Why don't the coaches teach the fundamentals?

JM said...

Hambletonian did good today.

JM said...

Peraza knocks one in.

JM said...

Oy.

JM said...

It was a pop up, until it became a Coors home run.

mik said...

Why is this last-place NL team playing us so tightly? Are they getting better or are we just that poor a team?

Carl J. Weitz said...

Both

AboveAverage said...

WoW

JM said...

We can't beat the Rockies. We can't beat the Cubs. We can't beat the Red Sox.

We did beat Oakland. Didn't we?

BernBabyBern said...

Ugh.

Carl J. Weitz said...

Every Yankee relief pitcher gives up crushing HR.

mik said...

At least we have a new hitting coach. We can always rally around that.
Somebody needs to contact Hal I'm sure he can be reached on the golf course, or on the yacht, or in the tanning booth, wherever the hell he is, and tell him this ain't working...

BTR999 said...

We are just that bad of a team. The Rockies gave us 3 or 4 runs Gand we STILL LOST.
And why Marinaccio in that spot he’s been terrible.

I give up…hope we go on an epic losing streak that makes us sellers and curs attendance the rest of the year.

I can’t stomach listening to boone.

mik said...

Why did Boone take Cole out in the 6th? Does he think he's saving him for something? Let the "Ace" grind out until the 8th, or how about the 9th.

BTR999 said...

Fair question mik, you know, analytics says take him out, so you take him out.

Scottish Yankee fan said...


It is a worry that even if we go on a losing streak and miss the playoffs nothing will change

If we manage to sneak into the playoffs we will be knocked out by any competent team and again nothing will change

Firing Boone will make no difference it is Cashman who is 100% to blame for the failure of this baseball organization at every level year after year in every single aspect of baseball operations seems to be a badly run shambles

I will ask again is anyone in the media going to call him out on this?

Would any other GM have lasted this long with this amount of money to spend and nothing to show for it?

Why is he bombproof what am I missing I am not asking for personal abuse or character assassination just someone saying this clearly is not working and there is a systematic failure of the team and one man who is in charge of baseball operations fails year after year yet keeps his job why?

It is long overdue for a change but as I said I have no idea how low we will have to sink for Hal to do anything about it as money is all he is interested in I honestly believe he does not care if we ever win a World Series ever again as long as the profits keep going up.

I shudder to think what horrors of trades are going to be made at the trading deadline probably making last year's farce of signing the cast of the living dead who all seemed to be inured within minutes of signing look good.

What I do notice here is a worrying sign a lot of the anger has gone and it is just acceptance that this team and the way it is run is just going to go on being like this and nothing will change and the real diehard fans know that nothing is going to change and the same old story will be trotted out next season alongside some 32-year-old free agents with nice 5 year contracts.





Kevin said...

The problem is that Hal is sulking because the title for his auto-biography was used months before his own publication. "Spare".

The Archangel said...

The combination of Cashamn and Boone is horrific.

Cashman has assembled a bad team made up of over-the-hill regulars and AAAA subs.
Never learned from 2013 and similar debacles about signing, or trading for, old players. Injured players.
His MILB office is mediocre and seems unable to teach basic baseball skills like running and fielding for example. look at how well the O's kids play at fundamentals. Yes, the O's kids may be better talented, but fundamentals CAN be taught.

Boone's lack of skill has cost at least 1/2 doz. games this season.
Imagine a Kevin Cash, Francona or "whitey Herzog" -type manager in our dugout.

Actually, if Hal fired Cashman and the replacement hired a good seasoned manager , Hal could become the absentee owner he really wants to be and just show up once in Feb, Opening Day, First Playoff game and WS and otherwise, just collect money.
Someone should suggest that because I really really think that he would like that the best.

The Archangel said...

Sorry about my terrible grammar, etc., above, but I was just so peeved and vented without even cursory proofreading.

Hazel Motes said...

mlk: Did you notice Cole's pitch cout today and the career mileage on his arm? You and other guys won't be happy until he joins deGrom on the operating table. It's not "analytics," it's medical science.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Kevin,

You are spot on. Mommy/Daddy/sibling issues abound.

And we pay for it.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

What's a pitch cout?
Something like Hoyt Wilhelm?

The Archangel said...

Generally I agree with the "why are pitch counts so sacred", but I would have taken him out too.
I think he labored in the 5th and 6th, and I think the the altitude had a lot to do with it.
I also would be careful with him as he ages and we will need him in future seasons.

Poor job of bullpen management lost this game.
[Pleas see previous point.]

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Excuse me, but is this the pineapple express?

MIK said...

Yes, I did 102 total pitch count, without showing signs of any laboring or strain. I think it's a big jump from expecting a 120 to 130 total to rooting for an operation. Supposed to be an Ace, facing a very poor team hot while we're trying to stay out of the bottom of the East.

AboveAverage said...

I am hopeful that Michael Kay is a member of SAG.

That would be a very bright spot on this Mile High Miscue of a day

Rufus T. Firefly said...

AA,

The downside is, if big head is a member, then the Master probably is

AboveAverage said...

Not necessarily…Roofers T. Pitch Burnicous


There are considerable differences on both of their recent dance cards.

Plus The Master is at the point where he wouldn’t give two Pee Wee league batter poops about being in the SAG so my hope continues to remain UNWAVERING …. whilst my concern about these StankEEZ continues to rise like a pharmaceutically enhanced Giuliani erection.

Joe Formerlyof Brooklyn said...


I don't know if JackieD eats spaghetti at all, but I believe if he does, he smothers it in . . . ketchup.

Kevin said...

https://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/IP_career.shtml
Cole is #574 on the most innings pitched. Hey AA! What does "empirical" mean again?

And careful examination of the list shows that NONE of those pitchers ahead of Cole were "high velocity" pitchers! Do you believe this?

And arm strain is not associated with throwing off-speed pitches such as curves, screwballs (not the ones who show up on this blog), sliders, slurves, etc.
Tom Verducci, were have you gone? "Help us analytics. You're our only hope". When talk doesn't let the facts get in the way. Note that many pitchers on this list ahead of Cole were primarily relievers. "Help us analytics, you're our only hope". "Cocaine is a helluva drug".

Kevin said...

The above post is NOT to be construed as a retort to other posters. I happened to have come across some interesting numbers while doing research on modern pitching usage, and since I was awake I thought that this was the perfect time to share some of my research. "Cocaine is a helluva drug". I don't touch the stuff. Personally.

AboveAverage said...

Kevin - being that it is 2:51 in the morning here it is likely best for you to share what that friend of yours thinks empirical means.

Kevin said...

AA, it's IMPOSSIBLE to even guess what orbit my friend's mind is in...

Kevin said...

AA, a Black empty Hole in the Force I do discern. It's malevolence is exceeded only by it's need to be right. Do you discern the malevolence as well?

Kevin said...

"AA, did you ever read, "The Bell Curve"? I did a number of times. Interesting hypotheses put forth, well researched, interesting conclusions were reached. In SPITE of all of the above I could never totally agree with the premises. The reason is that for all of the numerical modeling, and hypotheses; I was aware that my training in numerical analysis of intelligence, intelligence itself, how to tease the possible biases in the authors out, and many other aspects that didn't occur to me made it impossible for me fully grasp all of the ideas.

Have you ever read interesting ideas, but felt like it was just out of reach. I'm of the belief that many ideas are just beyond the reach of people,but they don't quite have the experience or IQ to even realize that they just don't have command of an idea.It's kind of like understanding the passage of time...