Thursday, October 10, 2024

Giancarlo "Stealin" Stanton has a chance to make complaints about his contract forever disappear

Excuse me a moment, because last night, the world changed. 

I'm referring to Florida, home to family and friends - (candles lit) - where an unfolding catastrophe made a ballgame seem rather inconsequential. Last night should have been a time of joking phone texts, and TV moments shared from a distance. Instead, it was horror. Today, the Tropicana Dome is torn to shreds, thousands are homeless, millions without power - and, honestly, I'm embarrassed to assign a ballgame so much importance when, in fact, it doesn't matter. 

But this is the world we built, right? We cannot change now. Baseball is our diversion from the demons, our escape hatch from the things that go bump in the night. The Yankees are a concept that lets us briefly forget the roof that leaks, the car that does not run, the sciatica that ever worsens - the knowledge that we're getting older. 

Well, last night, the diversion came through. 

I will always remember Giancarlo Stanton's HR, which happened between channel-hops to cable news outlets that conveyed images far more disturbing than the Halloween horror promotions between innings. 

Today, as the world assesses the damage, I want to thank Stanton for coming through. Because of him, I somehow went to bed with a sense of hope. Is that nuts, or what? 

Without Stanton - who has drawn his share of complaints - I have absolutely no doubt the Yankees would have lost that game and would be heading into tonight on a railcar to elimination. 

For six years now, we have lamented Stanton's massive contract, which the Yankee front office neatly blamed whenever it passed on a free agent. (Thinking Bryce Harper and Manny Machado here.) As I always try to remind myself, Stanton's deal was never Stanton's fault. Nevertheless, there he stood, in the eye of a financial hurricane, to be judged more by spreadsheets rather than box scores. 

In fact, in 2018, when he came in a trade, Stanton embodied baseball's new reality: That every great star - be a slugger or an ace - will be, at the end of his career, a massive drain upon the team's finances. If a contract runs for 10 years, it's a given that the player will play his final seasons as a pariah. So it's been with Stanton, who we have through 2028, and he's already hobbling. 

But not last night. Nope. Last night, Stanton lifted the Yankees onto his shoulders and carried them past KC. And now, the Yankees can return the favor: If they can reach the world series, they can forever staunch Stanton's critics, as A-Rod nearly did in 2009 (A-Rod was too famous, too controversial, to silence everyone. By comparison, Stanton is much less polarizing.)  Can you imagine Stanton appearing at the 2035 Old-Timers Day and receiving gales of applause?

If the Yankees rally behind Stanton - (this means you, Mr. Captain) - we will never have to whine about his contract again. And when bad times converge, maybe we can still think about 2024 and smile - though that might not be easy. 

As the Wicked Witch of the West once said, while melting, "What a world, what a world!" Yep. What a world...

26 comments:

acrilly said...

I was watching live when Mike tore ass off to second base and I stood up out of disbelief! I take back all the bad things and "losing to a tortoise” haiku I’ve ever said about him. Maybe if Judge can’t hit in the playoffs, he can try stealing bases too. It’ll be our new thing as a team. I loved how the after game interviewer asked Mike if he was gonna challenge Ohtani next year for 50/50. The big man laughed.

The Hammer of God said...

Well, ain't we seen it all now, Stanton's greatest game as a Yankee. Dare we hope for more? I don't know about that. The Bronx Bums better get this thing done in K.C., if they're serious about moving on up. If it comes down to a final game, you know they'll fuck it up again.

Doug K. said...

The Yankees are truly the Island of Misfit Toys.

JM said...

Every dog has its day. Except Droopy. He's doomed.

BTR999 said...

Hardly a dominant win, but we’ll take it. Let’s take care of business tonight and not let it go 5.

JM said...

It's good to know that Keefe is also fallible:

"I would sit Stanton in Game 3. Stanton is 1-for-8 with a walk in the series and has cost the Yankees two runs with his jogging (at best) on the bases. After Game 1, I wrote about why Stanton’s supposed postseason greatness isn’t so great (unless you remove from the fans from the stands and play the games at a neutral site). The only reason to play him is because you think he can get into a mistake and hit it over the fence. The problem is the level of pitcher he is seeing each at-bat isn’t making mistakes."

The Hammer of God said...

Well, Stanton got some mistake pitches last night. And when he got 'em, he didn't miss 'em. The home run ball was not a terrible pitch, let's give him some credit for that one. Low under the knees, on the inside corner. But three straight off speed had Stanton sitting junk ball. He got what he was looking for and took care of business. Which is a lot more than what most of the other Yankee hitters (and pitchers) are doing right now.

13bit said...

"Forever" lasts for ten minutes in OUR Yankiverse. Much as I have always relished those dramatic moments when Yankees become made men in pinstripes, and much as I always respect your opinion, El Duque, it'll take more than one admittedly clutch game - from a sample group of ten million games that he has played - for me to deliver the "forever" verdict. In other words, don't start mapping out the plot for a statue in Yankeeland Park yet. I think of other Yankees who had great moments - Bucky Dent is a forever Yankee. Aaron Boone had that one glorious hit, but what do we think of him n now? Even as a player, he comes in very low in that "forever" cohort. Anyway, let's see what he does in the next game. I am still rooting for Captain "Tiny" Judge to bust out. HE is someone I could get behind as a made Yankee.

AboveAverage said...

“I’m looking at YOU, Aaron Judge.

Time to make the f@cking donuts!”

Doug K. said...

Is that a "Homer" Price reference?

AboveAverage said...

4 total references, (including Scott Pilgrim vs The World)

JM said...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=petqFm94osQ

DickAllen said...

One game does not make the man. Not by a long shot. He has too many low and away whiffs piled up to have this one game make up for all the chances he's missed over the years, stolen base or not.

If the Yankees have to depend on Giancarlo to pull their asses out of the fire, they are truly fucked.

DickAllen said...

Amen to that, bitty.

DickAllen said...

If he somehow becomes part of a winning world series team this year, he only gets to rise up somewhere in the Yankeeverse vicinity alongside Arod.

mik said...

World Series championships cover up a lot of bad feelings.

AboveAverage said...

that's one of them

HoraceClarke66 said...

Yeah, I have mixed feelings on Stanton.

True: he was traded to the Yankees with a ridiculous contract already in place. Not his fault.

True: he has generally been a stand-up guy, not turning the team into his own private psychodrama, the way that A-Rod did.

(Little known fact: "Your own private psychodrama" was the original title of the B-52s "Your Own Private Idaho."

JM said...

Back in June, he was on the way to a pretty good year, especially with RISP.
In 72 at bats: .292/.363/.583, .946 OPS, 5 homers, 6 doubles, 29 RBI, 8 BB.

But it didn't turn out too terribly bad:
"Now it’s the end of September, and Stanton has 27 home runs and a .781 OPS. Not his MVP-era numbers, but much better than what, say, the Mets received from their designated hitter, J.D. Martinez. And proof that he was not in fact headed for the scrap heap last year."

HoraceClarke66 said...

But also True:

—Unlike A-Rod, Stanton has not done anything close to winning two MVPs, and leading us to numerous first-place finishes.

—Stanton has missed nearly as many regular-season games in his 7-year Yankees career as Mickey Mantle missed in his 18-year Yankees career. He would have missed more, save that the shortened, 2020 Covid season kept him off the DL for 100 games or so.

—Stanton had to beg out of 4 of the 6 ALCS games in 2019 against Houston—despite homering in Game 1—because of injuries that had also kept him out of 144 regular-season games that year.

—Stanton has made zero, no, nada (0) attempts to change his game in any way that I can see, despite years and years of under-performance. Only after hundreds of games on the DL did he change his workout regime.

—Without Stanton, the Yankees almost certainly would have signed or traded someone else. Someone like Bryce Harper, yes. Maybe someone like J.D. Martinez, who probably could have secured the team at least 3 more rings.

HoraceClarke66 said...

As for those special Yankees...good points, Bitty.

Dent was a bit of an under-performer at the plate, during most of his time with the Yanks. But he was a superb, underrated shortstop in the field (on a team with some leading groundball pitchers), and of course there was Boston, and an MVP in the World Series that year...

HoraceClarke66 said...

Boone was generally a disappointment before and after that Game 7 against Boston—starting with his inability to hit a fly ball that would have plated the winning run in Game 4 of the World Series that year, and probably given us another ring.

He never should have been on the Yankees, really—and would not have been, if that idiot Cashman had not trade Mike Lowell for 4 useless pitchers. Having Lowell would not only have spared us all the A-Rod psychodrama, but probably netted us another 4-5 rings.

HoraceClarke66 said...

And yes, Aaron Judge has to hit. Now.

JM said...

From The Athletic:

"Among all Yankees with at least 30 postseason games in franchise history, Stanton’s .964 OPS ranks fourth all-time. You know the other three by one name: Ruth, Gehrig, Reggie."

"[Yesterday's] was his 12th home run in just 30 postseason games for the Yankees, pushing them ahead 3-2."

"Hours before first pitch, Stanton was on the field taking early batting practice...In between swings, Stanton, Rowson and Ausmus would watch the video to make sure Stanton’s mechanics were in sync."

Again, it's not that I think he's been consistently great since he got here, and the injuries have really been killer, but he's better than he gets credit for being.

acrilly said...

Wow…i’m wordless, that’s so damning

acrilly said...

Just being honest, JM, you could pick out another 200+AB stretch in Mike’s Yankee career that is absolutely terrible too. Playoffs yes, but I’d still rather Steve Balboni up there. At least he could play the field.