By far, the most pleasant surprise of 2024 was
In the months of July and August, he came out of nowhere - or at least Wilks Barre - to hit .300 with 9 HRS and protect Aaron Judge in the batting order. Not since the immortal Kraken, Gary Sanchez, waaaaaay back in 2016, had a young Yankee catcher conjured so much hope. Entering September, Wells was odds-on favorite to win AL Rookie of the Year.
Then came that fateful month, with the falling leaves drifting by our window panes. In the last six weeks, Wells hit .111 with 1 HR and 20 whiffs, surely his most awkward period since puberty. It was painful. Also, his slump carried into the postseason, when he batted .120, though one HR did come against the ultra-rich Dodgers, briefly bringing hope in that otherwise dreadful week.
We must also note that Wells made himself into a MLB-quality defensive catcher, which had been our fears, early on, when he was tabbed as a 1B who could occasionally catch. Not anymore. He is our front line catcher, no turning back, and nobody behind him in at depth chart that used to be - (thinking Higgy and Jose Trevino) - rather formidable.
Right now, the Yankee roster shows Wells and somebody named J.C. Escarra, a 29-year-old mope who hit .201 last year in the minors. There's also Alex Jackson, also 29, who hit .122 last year for Tampa. And Ben Rice, last year's momentary wunderkind, who might be a 1B who can occasionally catch. (And who needs a few months at Wilkes Barre.)
So, which Austin Wells will show up this season?
The one who mashed in midsummer, or the one who ran out of gas on Aug. 1?
If Wells hits, the Yankee lineup looks formidable. If he doesn't, things could go sideways by June 1. We might need that A.I.-powered toilet - for the paperwork, of course.