Thursday, October 17, 2024

In Cleveland, Yankees will need lefty hitting in the center of the order

Hot scoop: Monday night, in the 8th, Austin Wells actually looked good. Well, decent, maybe. A big AB. He whacked a few foul liners, then hit one directly at the RF. In the box score, just another out from a guy who is 2 for 24 this postseason. I'm not gonna write the BA. Let's just say, it's the stuff of Joey Gallo.

But here's the thing: Wells actually barreled a few balls, and he didn't strike out - (as he has 10 times in six games) - and then trudge back to the dugout hearing boos. (Yes, in Yankee Stadium, boos.) So, symbolic victory, right? 

Well, dunno. The problem with Wells - whose slump began in late August and might not even be a "slump" - is that he bats cleanup, right after the (hopefully) awakening volcano called Mt. Judge. He's supposed to break up the string of RH bats that includes Gleyber, Judge, Giancarlo and Volpe. Thus far, it hasn't worked.  

The Yankees made their late-season run with a lefty boost: Jazz Chisholm at 3B, Alex Verdugo and The Martian in LF, Anthony Rizzo back and Wells hitting. The team punted on DJ LeMahieu, a painful divorce, but he was getting nowhere. Ever since, they have beaten up on RH pitchers, but floundered against lefties. 

So, who is likely to give a lefty lift? 

1. Wells? Don't want to mimic Boone, and assign significance to a few swings, but that's all we've got. If Wells doesn't start hitting, he must be dropped in the order (swapped with Jazz or Rizzo) or replaced at catcher by Slow Hand Trevino (against a LH pitcher.) His slump has reached DefCon mode, especially if Judge is heating up. Somebody must protect the Captain. 

2. Chisholm. Either he starts hitting, or his cocky manner takes a hit. Nice to see him fake a bunt two nights ago. I love to see Yankees bunt. It fucks up opposing pitchers and defenses. Chisholm's double Tuesday night was negated by a ridiculously bonehead base running move, something that might be becoming a problem. Imagine the cold winter if Jazz brings a world series-killing rally on the base paths?  

3. Rizzo. He's 3 for 7 since returning. Too small a sample. Smashed a double, then got picked off, horribly. Dare we dream he's all the way back? A candidate to take over cleanup, in place of Wells. And he's eliminated concerns that Oswaldo/Berdi should be playing first.  

4. Verdugo. His stellar LF fielding has justified his presence. He's 5 for 20 - not bad - and when he gets on base, we roll into Gleyber/Soto/Judge, which has the Guardians shitting their knickers. All he needs to do is grind out a few walks. 

5. Of course, Soto. Our best hitter in the postseason - 7 for 20. He has the greatest protector in baseball. And all we need is somebody hitting after Judge. 

24 comments:

Celerino Sanchez said...

Beware of the Midges!

Pocono Steve said...

And--Metropolitans down 2-1! Liberty up 2-1!

JM said...

Mets and Dodgers trading whomp-downs. This is weird.

Saw the same thing with Wells. He nailed a couple of pitches even though they ended up as outs. We could use him waking up, not just to get past the Guardrails, either. Against LA, we'd need some production from the guy. And it wouldn't hurt against the Mets.

BTR999 said...

I’m down on Wells, but what else do we have? The entire bottom of the order is sub-par. I have a tough time believing that Rizzo, whose power has completely disappeared, is suddenly able to hit again. Facing a LHP tonight, and that ain’t good,

JM said...

Don't forget--the game is at 5 o'clock today. Schmidt versus yet another great Guardrails pitcher. Yeah, we'll see about that.

ZacharyA said...

I've noticed Wells has had a lot of trouble with fastballs. I looked it up on Statcast and teams have been pounding him with fastballs the last two months, and that strategy is working. He can't catch up.

I don't know if he's hurt or just worn down by the long season. This is the biggest catching workload of his career.

Wells hit .111/.217/.194 in September and now .083/.154/.083 in October. I'd definitely drop him in the order to take some pressure off.

I'd guess Jose Trevino starts tonight against the LHP Matthew Boyd.

Like el duque pointed out, we don't have a lot of good options if we insist on putting a LHB in the no. 4 spot.

Chisholm isn't hitting, Rizzo has broken fingers, Verdugo's not a cleanup hitter.

I might gamble and roll the dice on Chisholm. He hit .245/.373/.469 in 14 games in the cleanup spot this year. Not a big sample size or anything. But maybe he gets some better pitches to hit behind Judge. I don't know.

HoraceClarke66 said...

I've been pounding the drum for moving Wells down—it has to be—but I don't want him out. First, as Duque pointed out, he seemed to be finally having some good swings on Tuesday. Second, the Guardians of Traffic will run wild on Trevino-not-Trivino, WHO ALSO WAS ONLY A .189 HITTER AGAINST LEFTIES THIS YEAR. (Wells: .197)

I like Judge-Soto-Stanton...but of course Boone (Cashman) won't do that. Too big a change. So at least make it Soto-Judge-Stanton. Keep Wells in the lineup, move him down to 8th or so, sez I.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Nice to see the Liberty pull out a win. Hope they clinch it. As for the Mets-Dodgers, so far they are using each other up admirably, the relievers throwing countless innings. Let's hope the Metsies bounce back and it goes the full seven.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Also...interesting to see how Ohtani is playing: a monster with guys on base, something like 1-20 with nobody on. I would think that would indicate NOT pitching to him, no matter what. And of course it would also seem to mitigate AGAINST the Dodgers batting him first, but they won't change that.

We should learn the same lesson when it comes to Judge, an keep him in that third spot, or even move him to fourth.

JM said...

That was some game-winning shot in the Liberty game. Wow.

Mets and Dodgers are trading nights to kill each other, though LA is killing more thoroughly. But to paraphrase the Master, it doesn't matter whether it's 10-0 or 1-0, it still only counts as 1 in the win column. So, let's see what tonight brings.

JM said...

Pitch to him with nobody on, walk him whenever possible with a man or men on base. No other way to deal with him effectively. Let's see if Mendoza understands that.

JM said...

Nick Power on Pinstripe Alley:

"the current buzz is that Trevino will take over for Wells with Boyd on the mound. As good as Wells has been behind the plate, the Yankees shouldn’t suffer any drop-off going to Trevino’s glove should they go with him for Game 3."

Wtf is he talking about? Trevino's defense has gone straight into the toilet. His hitting, not much better. This is what happens when a fan in California doesn't watch every game during the regular season and relies on stats that don't reflect current reality.

AboveAverage said...

Allow me to state, for the record, JM - that THIS FAN IN CALIFORNIA would never make this mistake. I do not butter my bread on the outside . . .

13bit said...

I'm not going to future trip or anything...

13bit said...

AA - who can afford bread or butter?

Doctor T said...

There are two problems here.

Problem A: Wells is struggling at the plate.
Problem B: Judge has no viable offensive threat to force the pitchers to throw fat strikes at him. So they don't.

Mix them together and you have the makings of classic, bad Yankee decision-making.

While we're all grateful that Cashman finally learned the importance of left handed bats in the lineup after 25 years on the job. The Yankees seem to be embracing that fact like a non-dancer learning how to tango.

Problem A is not solved by sitting the best catcher on the team. It's solve by dropping him in the lineup. Say 8th?

Problem B is best solved by putting Stanton in the cleanup spot. He seems to have found his mojo. He even stole a base! And he's the best bat on the roster to protect Judge. whatever flaws he may have. Leave Soto where he is. It's working. Don't mess with it.

Yes, Brian. I told you you needed to get some leftie bats, for 20 years or so. And yes, that's so you can stagger them in the lineup and stifle your opponent's bullpen choices. You finally learned that rudimentary lesson. Congrats.

But its a guideline, not a rule. Tell your analysts to take a long lunch (and don't come back) and bring in some veteran ex-managers to explain to you and the other trust-funders in the executive suite, why my idea is the best option you have.

You will be judged on your answer.

JM said...

Not even if it's avocado butter?

JM said...

Sound health advice from Doctor T.

BTR999 said...

Jose Trevino starting with LHP Matthew Boyd on the mound. Jon Berti at first base.

Joe of AZ said...

Mendoza seems to have carried on the Yankee way of "challenging" their most feared hitter ...only to add it blow up in their face ala Devers etc...

JM said...

I bet we pay for this mistake. I know Wells isn't hitting, but Trevino is a step down in defense and probably no improvement in offense.

Kevin said...

Batting Ohtani first is like trying to reinvent the wheel. Idiocy.

BTR999 said...

I’d expect to see both Wells and Berti off the bench at some point tonight.

AboveAverage said...

The Who