Sunday, September 28, 2025

Tied and fried, but are the Yankees better off without a first-round bye? Yes.

LISTEN: The Yankees are better off losing the first-round bye to the hateful Jays.

There. I said it. Fill me with bongwater, and zip-tie me to your unicorn. Cover me with kitty litter, and exile me to Utica. Yeah, I spake it, and I meaneth it. Here's why... 

1. Whatever happens in '25, the '25 Yanks must beat the '25 Redsocks. There is no end-run, no secret passageway, no magical incantation that unlocks the glistening of Jack Curry's hair. We either beat Boston this week, or we piss away Grisham's rise, Schlittler's breakout, and another great Judgeian season. We haven't beat the Redsocks in a critical postseason series since Javier Vasquez flushed away The Curse. So, here it comes: I say, if we're going to lose, let it happen now - this week - rather than deeper into October. Same outcome. Let's not waste time.

2. We're better off facing Boston in a three-game set. That way, we don't face Garret Crochet twice. Don't get me wrong: I love Max Fried, and the aces might go toe-to-toe, aura-to-aura. But I'd prefer not to face Crochet twice.

3. Year after year, first-round winners roll into the next level on wild emotional upswings, if not walk-offs. If the Yankees beat Boston next week, they will roll into the second round against whomever with fire in their bellies, rather than Doritos.

4. Year after year, no matter how hard they practice, first-round bye teams go flat during their off-weeks. They do interviews. They play "simulated" games. They watch TV. They go stale. The Yanks are better off playing - not sitting around. 

That doesn't mean they should lose today. Nope. They gotta beat Baltimore, for old time's sake. But don't sweat the bye. Next week, let's play Boston in the Bronx.  

10 comments:

AboveAverage said...

Fellow Ladies and Cashmen,

We must maintain our decomposure.

Those flies you hear are not
warning track bound

Instead, they will be our guides to an end of season feast like no other.

Never mind what’s on the menU

It’s 2025










JM said...

Flies are always a sign of very bad news on cop shows. The young patrol officer always pukes, too.

BTR999 said...

I feel the same way, basically. On the other hand, the extra series is just an additional way for us to be exposed. But your point about Crochet is well taken.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Whatever the outcome, the Martian will be well rested.

Which means he will be thrown into a wholly inappropriate pressure situation by the bonehead.

Plus Glassman will strain a gonad and be day to day until the Yankees are eliminated.

It's what they do.

But I want them to win every game and the carmines to lose every game.

Publius said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Publius said...

Inclined to agree, duque. It's not just for 2025. The Yankees must confront, and defeat, the Red Sox. Now is as good a time as any.

edb said...

Agreed, Byes have not ended well in general.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Good point about the BYEs. On the other hand...I can easily see us getting shut out twice in as many games against the Sox. Can't see anything like that happening with any other AL team. If we DON'T play the Sox first round, maybe somebody else knocks them off.

The prospects of ol' Sweats Profundo celebrating on the mound after their two-game sweep in the Stadium...I'd rather lose to the Big Dump.

TheWinWarblist said...

This is a mirage, an unclean phantasm. BEWARE. Do not go into the light! DO NOT!!!

Publius said...

Sweats Profundo!

Worthy of Ring Lardner, or a Frank DeFord facsimile thereof.