Sunday, February 15, 2026

Attack of the unheralded and undervalued Yankee breakout prospects

Have you heard about the tidal wave of under-appreciated Yankee prospects, soon to overwhelm the Gulf of America coastline?

With respect to fellow bloggers, whom I read faithfully, everywhere across Tampa, it's raining potential breakout Yankee prospects. These are the young - (twentysomething, anyway) - lug nuts who, if they hit .350 in April or throw a shutout in May, will abruptly vault onto the Top 20 Prospect pig lists, to be endlessly hyped by us, the hyperest of  hypers.

I believe that's why the Yankees face their current crisis.

Every winter and July 31 deadline, they trade multi-prospect packages for former all-stars, who have overstayed their welcomes in places like Miami, Colorado or Pittsburgh. In the 2020s, the front office came to realize that, unless a traded player becomes a major star, it will pay no price for dealing away young talent.

When all is said and done, the ever-shrinking platoon of Gammonites - whittled to a handful by the media's trillionaire oligarchs - will not squawk about a JP Sears, a Greg Wissert, a Thairo Estrada, a Carlos Narvaez, or anybody else who goes elsewhere and becomes a legitimate MLB player. 

Last month, Brian Cashman dealt four no-name prospects for Ryan Weathers. There was no outcry, no questioning of the price tag. In his early years as GM, Cashman notably avoided such deals, fearing a career-killing misstep. He'd never allow ex-Yanks to go to the Mets or Redsocks. Now, it happens regularly. And Cashman knows: When the Yankees trade another bundle, there'll always a new group to fill the Top 20 list. The "potential breakouts."    

But but BUT... the Yankees have a problem. By hyping one or two prospects relentlessly, they annually paint themselves into a corner. They cannot trade their Number One prospect without blowback. They're stuck with him. Anthony Volpe can have three rotten years, but he's still their golden boy. Look at this week's reaction to the idea that Jasson Dominguez - the Martian - might be ticketed to Scranton. The fans have waited seven years for him. Now, traded for a bullpen cog? Say it ain't so.

I believe the Yankees are one or two players shy of taking the AL East. You see the infield, the rotation, the bullpen. There is no free agent out there. And having cratered their farm system, they have only their top prospects to deal. The thing about "potential breakout" prospects - they're always a month away.

Wait... The Dow is over 50,000 right now. The S&P at almost 7,000, and the Nasdaq smashing records. THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD BE TALKING ABOUT.

9 comments:

13bit said...

Are you saying that we are only concerned with optics? Would AI - something I loathe and think will destroy the planet - be able to comprehensively track the trajectory, impact and cost to us of every prospect we have traded in the past? Who pays for these tariffs/trades, us or the other guys? Why is Brian so much smarter than we are? His record is the proof of the pudding. How much more winning can we handle? I'm so tired of all the winning. Brian Cashman, you are my GM for life!

Carl J. Weitz said...

Forget the major exchanges in the stock market. My crypto investments have yet to create my vast fortune. In fact, they've gone in the opposite direction. But there's still the future crypto summer and bull run. Sometimes, I feel that if I bought a pumpkin farm, they'd outlaw Halloween.

AboveAverage said...

I use to paint scary pumpkins and other ghostly ghastly creatures on store front windows in a town they call Branford for Halloween back before they discovered electricity (aka the 1960s) Carl.
Do they still do such a thing in our modern age ?

HoraceClarke66 said...

Oh, Duque, you cockeyed optimist! The Yanks WERE, maybe, 1-2 players away from winning something of note. Now that's more like 4-5, on the pitching staff alone. And the infield and catching positions are subpar. This team really needs to be rebuilt already.

BTR999 said...

They are indeed far, far away from being a true contender. Despite the gaslighting they care not a whit, so long as the cash registers keep on ringing

The Hammer of God said...

Are they really that far away from being championship caliber? Well, let's start with 3B, right? Work a trade for a 3B. I still think we should trade away Jazz Chisholm. Wells too. And Stanton. Volpe too, but nobody will take an injured player, so have to wait 'til he's healthy. Okay, that's five guys already. I guess Hoss & BTR999 are right. That's a lot of work.

Stanton, however, you only have to get rid of the guy. Anything you can get. His replacement will probably be Jasson Dominguez. So at least that problem is not really a problem. But Cashman will never do that. In the immortal words of Lynyrd Skynyrd, "and that's fuhr shure".

AboveAverage said...

Perhaps Judge and Stanton could form a curling team.

Yeah - that’s something that I like to see.

(But only if they were in Drag)

Doug K. said...

Fix the Yankees in two players... OK

If, somehow we could trade for Nico Hoerner and put him at his original position of SS. Then the infield would be fixed.

Rice - good hit - getting better in the field.
Jazz - is Jazz
Nico - excellent fielder - lead off guy. contact hitter
MacMahon - strong field. can't hit.

I'd take it.

RF Judge
CF Grisham
LF Belli

Top five outfield easily.

C: Wells. Sure

Pitching:

They need a bullpen set up guy. The starters are ...

Fried
Rodon
Cole
Schlitler
Gil

Getting a guy who is lights out setting up Bednar moves everyone else down a role and is more than sufficient.

Then again... even with all that... the Dodgers.

AboveAverage said...

Did you have to type the Dodgers….

I need another cup of coffee