2b DJ LeMahieu
rf Aaron Judge
ss Gleyber Torres
dh Giancarlo Stanton
lf Miguel Andujar
c Gary Sanchez
1b Luke Voit/Mike Ford
3b Gio Urshela
cf Brett Gardner
(Note: This lineup wins the AL East. But it also tilts hard right. Against dominant righties, Mike Tauchman might play LF, and Gardy would probably move up. Not sure about Gleyber hitting third and playing SS; that's a lot of pressure. He might need to work his way into that role. By July, we should have Aaron Hicks, whatever that means.)
Bench
Tauchman
Ford
Kyle Higashioka
Tyler Wade
Thairo Estrada
(Note: In case you didn't notice, there is no spot for Clint Frazier. If he is sent back to Scranton - again - the poor guy will be a basket case. The big question is whether Andujar can play LF. If not, Frazier has a foot in the door (assuming he can play LF). As it stands today, either Andujar or Frazier needs to be traded. Andujar would bring more, but he's a great young bat. Do they really want to let him go?
This should be Tyler Wade's year. With a 26-man roster - the new normal - Wade looks perfect. Not only does he bat LH, but he can play the OF and he is the fastest player on the team.
Finally, before Gerrit Cole, our big winter acquisition was scrubino OF Zack Granite. To save Gardy's legs, Granite might be a late-inning replacement.)
Rotation
Gerrit Cole
Luis Severino
Masahiro Tanaka
James Paxton
J.A. Happ
(Note: This rotation wins the AL East. But Happ will almost certainly be traded, leaving an opening for Jordan Montgomery, Jonathan Loaisiga, Luis Cessa or Deivi Garcia. Trouble is: No one on that list is a sure thing. So who pitches fifth?
This is why Gammonites keep postulating trades of Happ, Andujar/Frazier and a young arm... for a solid pitcher. But for whom? That's a substantial package. Cashman better not blow it.
Finally, for a team of china dolls - Hicks, Stanton, Severino, Judge - is it wise to cut ourselves thin?)
Bullpen
Aroldis Chapman
Zack Britton
Adam Ottavino
Tommy Kahnle
Chad Green
Jonathan Holder/Ben Heller/Stephen Tarpley/ Cessa/Loaisiga
Whomever stands out in Tampa
(Note: This bullpen wins the AL East. The Yankee surplus is why we keep hearing rumors about Milwaukee's Josh Hader. He would certainly buttress our late innings, especially if Smiley Chapman goes down.
(In a perfect world, we would wait until March - see who looks good - before doing a major deal. Trouble is, other teams won't wait on Happ. Something will have to Happen. We are clear front-runners in our division. But there is a lot of winter yet to play.
(Am I wrong to suspect that some of you have different opinions?)













