Tuesday, September 3, 2019

The "Next Man Up" phenomenon has not applied to the bullpen

Vast Gammonitic rain forests of words have sprouted over the 2019 Yankees "Next Man Up" movement... and rightfully so. If the Death Star super-brains did one thing well this year, it was in building a massive NAPA-style replacement database for spare parts... but only among position players.

All year, the vaunted Yankee bullpen has remained at the crossroads of Heaven and Hell. After the Fab Five - El Chapo, Otto, Tommy K, Zack with a K, and Mean Chad Green - the pickin's grow incredibly slim. At that point, it's "Next Prayer Up."

Aside from David Hale - currently injured - the 2019 Yankees have failed to develop, even temporarily, one honest-to-goodness, newly functioning bullpen lug nut. Nobody stepped up. When the starter gets whacked - always a possibility - Aaron Boone quickly faces a doomsday decision: Bring in the A-team, or watch the game quickly disappear. 

On the season, we have thrown the hordes of Hell at that final piece. Nobody succeeded. 

Jonathan Holder couldn't hold. Then came Nestor Octavio-Cortes Jr., Johnny Lasagna, Fat Chance Adams, Luis Cesspool and Stephen Tarpley. We tried "Moon Goggles" Harvey and "Mickey" Mantiply and - lately - we've been literally turning over sea shells - Ryan Dull, Tyler Lyons, Cory Gearren, the toe-tapper - in search of alien life. Tomorrow, if he's ready, Billy Crystal could be warming up.  We will take a flier on anybody - anybody. But a month from now, if Tanaka can't place his splitter, we could be watching "Boone's Goons" take a game off the rails.  

Yesterday, Cortes turned a 3-0 nail-biter into a joke. Two days ago, it was Dull, (who is anything but.) No one has stepped from the Abyss. In the Yankee bullpen, Boone's cry of "Next Man Up" is a sad wail in a godless universe.

Which is why we cling to what is, realistically, a ridiculous hope: Dellin Betances. As much we dream of the old Betances - the fearsome, dominating, Cat 4 force - it just doesn't seem possible. Betances has too many moving parts, too many physical and mental issues, and barely a month to conquer them. Today, he'll throw off the mound. The Yankees will announce that "all went well!" and he'll throw again later this week. But the minors are done, we're in a dogfight with Houston over home field advantage, and the Yankees cannot afford many horrible outings from Betances, as he rounds into shape. 

The other hope - far lesser, in my opinion - is CC Sabathia suddenly transitioning to a role he's avoided in the last 20 years. Once again, it's a war between the heart and head. First off, anybody who bunts against CC gets a gift single. His best response is to scream at the opposing dugout and maybe bean the next batter. While the bunt is truly a lost MLB art, I would hate to rely on Sabathia covering first in a close playoff game. Really... a LOOGY? Nah. 

When the Yankees set their October roster, they will surely name 12 to 13 pitchers. After four starters and the Big Four Five, that leaves at least three mop-up bodies. God help us if they pitch.  

61 comments:

Scottish Yankee fan said...

I hope you dont mind me reposting part of a post I did on another topic not sure anyone saw it (or did and died of boredom reading it!!!!)

Brian Keller is my new Mike Ford he had a dodgy start in AAA but is now figuring things out and worth at least a look maybe?

I know his recent stats dont jump out at you but he seems to do this every time he is promoted he gets off to a slow start then gets better and better

http://www.milb.com/player/index.jsp?player_id=662144#/career/R/pitching/2019/ALL

PREVIOUS POST BELOW

My new pet project is Brian Keller

He was drafted in the 39th round and seemed to be a non prospect in every site I checked
He was good at every level and threw a 70 pitch shutout in AA.
He has been promoted to AAA and the results have been mixed with him getting battered for 11 runs in one start and his walk rate is way higher but Im sure he will figure it out as he has done each time he is promoted and he still strikes out a lot of batters and if he ever throws an inning in the Majors it will be pretty amazing he is a very easy player to root for.
Maybe a long shot but he is perhaps quietly good and he could be added to the 40 man roster?

Anyway thanks for making me so welcome on this blog it makes the games so much more fun when you can have a wee laugh and joke with fellow fans.

JM said...

I applaud any player championed by a man who uses the word "dodgy." (Pardon my American punctuation.)

What happened to the kid they signed this summer? You know, the one who was a gift from the Almighty, ready to buzz down batters in AAA and the Stadium? Forget his name. Age.

The bullpen is yet more evidence that Cashman and the Statmen cannot figure out how to assess pitchers like they assess position players. Is it just them, or do other teams have the same issue? Mysterious.

Bring up Keller. He can't be worse than the warm bodies we've been using up until now.

Hell, bring up everybody and see if one of them can pitch. Nothing to lose. Except Man Boobs fucking up their heads and deliveries.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

JM, would you say Man Boobs is "knackered"?

I nominate Scottish Yankee fan to be Yankees Farm Director. Worth at least five wins over the course of the year.

As for Duque's original post, forget LOOGY. I'd nominate Carston Charles to be the designated lost cause inspiration for the playoffs.

When the Yankees are down three from bad umpiring and opposing pitchers throwing at our guys, bring him in in relief. Can't be worse than the NAPA OEM parts. Have him bark at the opposing players and the umps, hit a few batters and get ejected. He won't face too many batters and won't be able to do too much damage.

Worse case, it puts the opposing team on their heels for the next game. Best case, he gets the boys charged up for a rally win. Especially if we face the Satanic DEVIL Rays.

Yankee Daddy Roger said...

Why does Boone leave Cortes in when he is clearly unravelling? Second guess, sure, quit while you are ahead, won't you, but you got a good inning and two thirds out of him, don't put the game out of reach. Just saying.

JM said...

Boone is keeping the good bullpen arms rested. The fucking moron.

Rufus, Man Boobs must certainly be knackered after all the pole dancing. I wonder if he wears pasties.

What we need is a non-pitcher, a guy who can only throw a Folly Floater or drill someone. He takes the assignment knowing he'll be drummed out of the league in short order, but takes the money and the Yankees benefit.

Think Winnie is up to it?

JM said...

Of course, the guy does not HAVE to be a guy.

Just saying. Bonus PR points.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Winnie for Drillmaster!


...and Man Boobs is both knackered *and* knockered!

HoraceClarke66 said...

I don't know how you guys can concentrate on such unimportant issues while Scranton's entire season is on the line today.

"One day more
One day more to take for us the North
To beat the Mets up in their Sky
One day more to dream of the Governor's Cup
Or on defeat's bitter meal to sup!
One day more
One day more to live or die for Cashman
To take the prize he prizes most
To vanquish mighty Syracuse
Where El Duque sips his booze.
One day more!"

Anonymous said...

It's a Hobson's Choice and I don't mean Butch. Boone needs to find additional bullpen arms he can rely on.

1) The only way to find out who has the right stuff in high leverage situations is to pitch them there. Boone has to bring these guys in close games.

2) There's no place to hide. When a bull pen guy has a bad game or isn't up to it they generally lose the game or put it out of reach.

As opposed to a position player. The worst that guy can do in get a golden sombrero, hit in to rally killing DPs, or make a big error in the field. The other players can pick him up. Not so the pitcher. There were games where the "next man up" sucked. It's just harder to notice.

3) Boon e needs to find this guy/s now!

4) I'm not worried about winning home field (although I would like to.) because...

If we lose the home field advantage we get to face Minnesota before we have to face Houston.

Also, and this is interesting, the Astros are 3-4 against Tampa. So maybe they can get knocked off.

4) If we win home field advantage we have to face the winner of TB /OAK. And they both play us tough But... the Astros are 3-4 against Minn. So there's that.

There's no conclusion here. The games will play out. There is no easy road. If you want to be the champion ya gotta beat em all.

As to the rotation... I understand why Boone keeps sending these guys out there.

Personally (and I am wrong a lot)I think if Sevi can come back as an effective opener our rotation becomes...

"Playoff" Tanaka
Newly revised Paxton
AL Wins leader Domingo
and a Sevi to Green opener game.

We should be more or less OK.

Doug K.

ranger_lp said...

Mets winning 2-0 still batting first inning.

Retired Stratman said...

Nice Les Miz tribute, Hoss!

“To vanquish mighty Syracuse
Where El Duque sips his booze”

Beautiful, man.

ranger_lp said...

Mets beating Yanks 5-0 end top 1. Ervin Santana pitching for Mets.

JM said...

Doug, you speaketh wisdom. Yes, verily.

JM said...

Ranger, what year are you reporting from?

ranger_lp said...

Live JM...Syracuse vs SWB. AAA. Minor League playoff.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Thanks, Stratman! I'm putting it up for the Tony's this year.

And ranger, this is terrible news. I fear that if he's already lost the Governor's Cup, even a World Series ring will seem like ashes in, uh, ON Cashman's finger. We can hardly expect him to concentrate for the rest of the season, much less put together a champion.

ranger_lp said...

LOL...

If you care to listen...

https://tunein.com/radio/ScrantonWilkes-Barre-RailRiders-Baseball-Network-s199409/

ranger_lp said...

End 2 5-0 Mets.

ranger_lp said...

End 3. 6-0 Mets.

Anonymous said...

Ranger,

Five runs given up in the first two innings? So what you are saying is... whoever started for Scranton is our next man up.

Doug K.

Anonymous said...

Hoss,

What show is that from?

Doug K.

ranger_lp said...

Adonis Rosa gave up 5 in the first. Joe Multiply gave up one in the second. Deivi Garcia pitched a clean 4th.

Retired Stratman said...

Doug K. - One Day More from Les Miz https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-qkf0fLU2Ao

ranger_lp said...

End 4. Mets 6 Yanks 1.

Mediasavvy said...

This is inning eater time. Yankees will push the Quad A gang into as many innings as possible between now and the playoffs. Only when home field advantages are truly in danger, will you see the A-Team coming to the rescue.

Anonymous said...

Stratman,

Thanks. I haven't been to the theater in years. Never got over when they replaced Jerry Orbach in the Fantasticks.

Doug K.

Retired Stratman said...

I’m trying to remember that kind of September...

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 7th Mets 7 Yanks 2. Bases loaded no outs. Santana being lifted. Higgy homered in this inning.

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 7th Mets 7 Yanks 4. Bases loaded still no outs. Rumberlow pitching for the Mets.

ranger_lp said...

End 7th. Mets 7 Yanks 6.

ranger_lp said...

Top 8th. Mets 13 Yanks 6. 1 out in inning.

TheWinWarblist said...

Keep it going ranger.





FYFyH.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Les Miz is not really my idea of a top Broadway show, Doug K.—too many ballads and too much by-the-numbers emoting. But it does have some good, rousing stuff.

Such as...

"Do you hear the Metsies cry
As they tumble from the Sky?
It's music to our ears
As we Ride the Rails again.
Will you win the Cup for Coops
Or sit there upon your stoops?

Do you hear all Scranton sing?
Singing the songs of angry fans
It's the music of a city
That will not be foiled again!
When the beating of your heart
Echoes the beating of our bats
There is a Cup about to be won
If tomorrow comes!"

Or, something like that.

TheWinWarblist said...

You realize Austin Romine was as effcetive in his one inning of relief for the Yanks as Ryan Dull?



Fuck you FuckyouHal, you fucking Hal!!

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 8. Mets 13 Yanks 7. No outs 2 on.

13bit said...

Can we get back to the important stuff, the original spirit of the comments on this post, namely: "bad Anglicisms?"

Because, if for a second, you'll indulge my inner 8-year old's anglophile and logophilic tendencies, I have been longing for weeks to say: "Imagine a world where Rothchild's bollocks are thwapping against Boonie's bum as the team watches their batsman coach get buggered again by the syphlitic sybarite of a cricket bowler."

Okay, I'll get back to serious business now.

And yes, Doug K, on that ideal playoff rotation scenario. By the way, can you recommend some lotto numbers for me to play this week?

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 8. Mets 13 Yanks 9. One out bases loaded.

TheWinWarblist said...

I checked in on MiLB Gameday. Who is this terrible D Hernandez pitching for SWB? Oh, oh he's that Dave Hernandez. https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/h/hernada01.shtml Note that the career journeyman (lifetime earnings $14.4 million) has been more or less bad at major league baseball. He pitched to a negative 1.8 WAR for Cincinnati this year!! Why is he fucking up SWB!?



Fuck you FuckyouHal, you fucking Hal!!

TheWinWarblist said...

SYR 13 SWB 9, bottom of the 8th, bases loaded and 1 out.

TheWinWarblist said...

NOW SYR 13 SWB 10, still bases loaded one out in the bottom of the 8th with the Mighty Breyvic Valera striding to the plate. The earth shakes at the approach of the Might Colossus !!

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 8. Mets 13 Yanks 11. 1st and 3rd 2 outs.

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 8. Mets 13 Yanks 12. 1st and 3rd 2 outs.

ranger_lp said...

Bottom 8. Yanks 14 Mets 13. Runner on 2 outs.

Kratz!!!

ranger_lp said...

Heller coming on in 9th. 14-13 Yanks.

ranger_lp said...

Ball game over...Yankees win....theeeeeeeeeeeeeee...Yankees win. Mets lose....theeeeeeeeeeeeee Mets lose. 14-13 final.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

13bit,

Do you have any recommendations on how to unsee the visual of what you just provided?

I've ruled out hot poker in the eye, since it's only a visual, not an actual vision -- thank god.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

Ranger, to steal Hoss's phrase, because Mets.

13bit said...

Rufus, it's a tough job, but I'm trying to help us to collectively build character. Just breath deeply and think about how good it was for both Boner and Nutsack, the scene I described. It might be hard on the rookies to witness such carnage, but they're in the big leagues now and it will help them to build character, as well.

Anonymous said...

So basically one of the greatest "playoff" games in history. Thank you Ranger for the updates. It was almost like being there.

Doug K.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Indeed, ranger!

And now...EVERYBODY SING!

"DO YOU HEAR THE CASHMAN SING
SINGING THE SONGS OF THE GM?
IT'S THE SOUND OF THE MAN WHO WILL NOT LOSE THE CUP AGAIN...!"

HoraceClarke66 said...

And why do I have the feeling that—presuming we are able to go anywhere in the playoffs—we're going to be watching a lot of games like that?

Anonymous said...

Hoss,

I get my music about the French Revolution from Alan Sherman

Louie the Sixteenth was the King of France in 1789.
He was worse than Louie the Fifteenth
He was worse than Louie the Fourteenth
He was worse than Louie the Thirteenth.
He was the worst... since King Louie the First.

I suppose if I had to be more recent, the revolution music would be of the Prince and the... type. You know,

"Little Red Cosette"

Doug K.

13bit said...

I'm henery the 8th I am
henery the 8th I am I am
I got married to the widow next door
she's been married seven times before
and every one was an henry
she wouldn't have a willy or a sam.
I'm her 8th old man, I'm henry,
henery the 8th I am...

TheWinWarblist said...

It is clear from today's action in SWB that neither NY franchise has a damn bit of bullpen help coming from Triple A. (Small nod to Deivi García, but not quite yet.)



Fuck you FuckyouHal, you fucking Hal!!

ranger_lp said...

Second verse same as the first...

So here's the summary of today's game.

https://www.milb.com/milb/news/scrantonwilkes-barre-railriders-punch-ticket-to-playoffs-with-big-comeback/c-310518030

SWB has earned a 9 and 1/2 hour bus ride to Durham for the the first game of the playoffs tomorrow night.

Local Bargain Jerk said...


No Sam!

Local Bargain Jerk said...


I'd nominate Carston Charles to be the designated lost cause inspiration for the playoffs.

When the Yankees are down three from bad umpiring and opposing pitchers throwing at our guys, bring him in in relief. Can't be worse than the NAPA OEM parts. Have him bark at the opposing players and the umps, hit a few batters and get ejected. He won't face too many batters and won't be able to do too much damage.


Perfect. This is a great idea. To echo a recent Tweet from our Commander-in-Chief, I hereby nominate you to be the new Yankees Manager.

Local Bargain Jerk said...


Ranger: Excellent job on keeping us informed on the IL Championship game. I couldn't watch or listen, but your updates here were just what the doctor ordered.

Anonymous said...

WHAT A GREAT MET GAME TONIGHT!

ranger_lp said...

Mets giving up 7 in 9th and SYR Mets giving up 8 in 8th on same day...has to be astrological...or numerological if you believe in vibration and names.

Isiyku Abdulahi said...


I really want the world to know about this great man who brought back happiness into my life again after my husband left me and the kids 3 years ago for another women online when i contacted Dr Believe he cast a love spell for me within 48 hours my ex husband start calling me and begging for forgiveness for everything that have happened between us. I was so happy to have my family back together with love again here is the email of Dr Believe via believelovespelltemple@gmail.com a man with the great powers you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2348156148821
God bless you
I am very grateful for your help in my marriage.