Thursday, November 15, 2018

A look at Blake Snell shows the messy fingerprints of Prince Hal Steinbrenner

Hooray for Blake Snell, the American League's 2018 Cy Young winner. Not only does he deserve it, but it's always refreshing - a bolt of Florida sunshine! - to see a Redsock get stiffed. And once again, Tampa's front office shows why it is the gold standard in the AL East. For all the loving ink bestowed upon Cooperstown Cashman by his Gammonitic supplicants, year after year, Tampa fields a surprisingly solid team at a fraction of the Yankee payroll. Amazing.

But how did they get Blake Snell, and what could it tell us about 2019?

Let's return to those thrilling days of yesteryear, the cold, cruel winter of 2011, soon after the Granderson/Teixeira/Cano-led Yanks had been bumped from the playoffs by the Tigers. Brian Cashman had just said publicly that he did not want to sign a top free agent, if it meant losing a first-round draft pick. Days later, Hal overruled him, signing Rays' closer Rafael Soriano to a three-year deal.

As a result, the Rays received the Yankee first-round pick, number 31. The Yanks wouldn't get a shot until the 51st selection, in the sandwich round. The Rays also received a sandwich round choice, number 52.

The draft began with Pittsburgh selecting Gerritt Cole, whom the Yanks had drafted three years earlier, out of high school, and failed to sign. Eight picks later, the Indians took Francisco Lindor, and the Cubs followed with Javier Baez. A few more picks, and the Astros grabbed George Springer, and Miami took Jose Fernandez. At No. 18, Oakland picked Sonny Gray. Jeez, you get the picture. A lot of talent off the board. With pick No. 31, the Rays took OF Mikie Mahtook, now of Detroit, whom they eventually converted into Lucas Duda. 

With the 51st selection, the Yankees chose... drum roll, please... third-baseman Dante Bichette Jr.

Okay, where do we start? You could blame bad scouting, bad luck and nepotism, as it soon came out that Joe Girardi was Bichette's godfather. The Yankees projected Dante - or DBJ - as a heart-of-the-order slugger, a premier talent who could have been a professional tennis player. DJB hit well in the rookie league, then - well - years upon years of struggling. (It's tempting to rip on draft picks that don't pan out, but what's the point? It's not as if the players themselves deserve blame. For every star, there must be ten whose dreams get obliterated. Last year, Bichette played for the Saint Paul Saints of the American Association of Independent Professional Baseball. Dreams die hard.)

Oh, and with the next pick, at 52, the Rays chose Blake Snell.

Hopefully, Hal learned not to overrule the so-called experts. And maybe the Yanks learned not to draft nieces and nephews. But Hal might have had reason to prefer Soriano to the team's recent top picks. In recent years, they had included Andrew Brackman, the unsigned Cole, Slade Heathcott, Cito Culver, Bichette and Ty Hensley - choices that set the table for what might be the worst decade in Yankee history. 

So, here we are - back in a winter and looking to sign free agents. If they sign a Bryce or a Manny, the Yankees won't lose their first pick, but they would surrender a fourth rounder and international spending money. But there are some exceptions: Nathan Eovaldi, J.A. Happ, Zach Britton, David Robertson, and the lefty from Japan - Yusei Kikuchi - will cost us only money.


I have an idea: Let's ask ourselves, what would the Rays do? Would they trade Clint Frazier and Justus Sheffield for a pitcher over 30? Would they empty the farm system for a reliever? Just askin'. Because in an alternative Yankiverse not far from here, we could have had Blake Snell. 

8 comments:

KD said...

It's a shame we can't be smart like the Devil Rays but with money. we'd be like Boston!

If the Yanks move Andujar, expect him to end up at Boston playing 3B. We'd deserve that and so would Miggy. I'd then have a redsock player i'd root for. a first!

Iftikhar said...

so informative post. keep it up sharing good content with people cloud hosting | cloud hosting providers | best cloud hosting

Local Bargain Jerk said...


Dear Iftikhar,

Don't be shy like that. Please let us know your real thoughts. Should the Yanks trade Frazier?

Vampifella said...

Yeah, I (and so many others) had questioned that pick as soon as we found out about it. I remember doing research on him that day and he just really wasn't good enough to be drafted that high and certainly not for what they gave him as a signing bonus. Obviously it happened because of nepotism.

But you know what? The Red Sox had won that draft! They got Mookie Betts in the 5th (172th overall). He probably would have went higher but I think the story went that he wasn't planning on signing as had a great scholarship somewhere. The Sux somehow convinced him to go from HS to the minors.

Little known fact but Judge was drafted by the A's out of high school. We lucked out there but I'm still a little pissy about Cole not signing with us so many years ago. I'm pretty sure we would have broke him like we did with Joba and so many others, so whatever.

Anonymous said...

Young players don't like to sign with a team that keeps them buried in the minors in favor of crappy aging veterans.

TheWinWarblist said...

We could have had Blake Snell sure, but then we would have destroyed his development and he'd just be some career minor league palooka in some sad independent league. It's not enough to draft talent; you have to be able to develop it too.

HoraceClarke66 said...

It is infuriating.

When we identify good prospects like Cole, we don't sign them. And let's not forget all the years that Cashman and Hal decided to ignore the talented Latin talent they could have signed outside of the salary cap: Yu Darvish, Cespedes, Jose Abreu, and Chapman from the get-go, among others.

Cashman's failures are so thorough and massive you have to break them down into separate categories:

Failures to Find a Worhwhile Successor to Jeter:

C.J. Henry
Cito Culver

Failures to Identify the Third Baseman of the Future:

Mike Lowell (traded, ended up on Sox championship team, AND on Marlins championship team that beat Yanks)
Drew Henson
Dante Bichette, Jr.
Eric Duncan

Strong Young Pitching Arms of the Future:

A cast of thousands

Isiyku Abdulahi said...


I really want the world to know about this great man who brought back happiness into my life again after my husband left me and the kids 3 years ago for another women online when i contacted Dr Believe he cast a love spell for me within 48 hours my ex husband start calling me and begging for forgiveness for everything that have happened between us. I was so happy to have my family back together with love again here is the email of Dr Believe via believelovespelltemple@gmail.com a man with the great powers you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2348156148821
God bless you
I am very grateful for your help in my marriage.