Tuesday, August 9, 2022

On a morning we should be celebrating, a dark and painful loss

We've said this before, but it bears repeating, loudly and without malice. It's merely a statement of fact: 

The juju gods are assholes. 

Seriously. I hope they get monkey pox. I hope they lose everything on crypto. I hope they pick Buffalo Bills in their fantasy drafts, and I hope they cannot sleep at night because those stupid Roomba vacuum cleaners are barging around their bedrooms, and that they mistake dried globs of toothpaste for candy mints, and that they pee down their legs while reading on the john - and other partial payments for their crimes against the Yankees. They deserve to rot in hell. Or Utica. 

Last night, they took out Matt Carpenter - after Nestor and maybe Trevino, the single-most feelgood Yankee story of 2022 - for almost surely the rest of the season. In case you missed it, because who stays up until dawn to watch a stumbling team, Carpenter fouled off a pitch and broke his foot. At 36, his year is done. He'll surely get offers over the winter, but his time with the Yankees might also be done. It aint right, I tell ya. At least he got those standing O's in St. Louis, and his comeback outlasted Kim and Pete Davidson. Still, it's a dark day in the Yankiverse, and I blame those surly, graveyard-shift, minimum-wage deities, who do nothing more than fix ballgames. Assholes. I hope they need to wear compression socks.

(The Yankees won last night, thanks to a gamer performance from Jameson Tailion, and those are words you haven't seen here in a while. Tonight, the ever-faltering Gerrit Cole goes against Luis Castillo, who has become the Yankee Babadook, popping up on doorsteps and window sills. Three weeks ago, he was a throwaway line in a Gammons column; how did we end up on this guy's shit list? What did we do to this guy, aside from not drain the farm to get him?) 

How will Carpenter's loss affect us? Let's count the ways.

1. We need Anthony Rizzo back more than ever. Without the Carp, our batting order lists dangerously starboard. Last night, Anthony Benintendi came alive - 2 for 4 with 3 RBIs - but after Barren Aaron Hicks, he was our lone LH batter. That's trouble, especially heading into the postseason. (Houston RHs: McCullers, Verlander, Garcia, Javier...)   

2. With the trade deadline mercifully passed, we might need help from - gasp! - Scranton. First up would likely be lefty OF Estevan Florial, the perpetual prospect, now 24 and in his second season at the Anthracite Capital. But a dirty little secret is that Florial is slumping - hitting .213 over the last month, with an On Base Percentage of just .276. He's a swing-and-miss hitter, not a grinder, and the Yankees don't seem to think he's a solution. Sad.

3. What about all those the grizzled vets which the Yankees annually stash in Moosic? Where the hell are Chris Gittens and Socrates Brito! (Answer: Nobody knows.) But but BUT... there is someone who actually might be interesting: Ronald Guzman, 27, a former BJs prospect, is hitting .388 over the last 30 days. He's 19-49 with 3 HRs, and he's a hulking LH 1B-DH. I don't want to hype this guy, because he's not on the roster, and I kinda doubt he ever will be. But, well, he's there. Would look good coming off the bus.

4. Quite likely, this could be Miguel Andujar's last shot with Yankeehood. In the last month, Miggy's hit .250, though his mental state must have been awful, having been shipped out and then untraded. He or old friend Tyler Wade - a LH infielder - might get a call. Could Wade platoon with IKF or Donaldson? Maybe. Would it solve the problem? Probably not.

5. Cashman finds somebody off a scrap heap. The trade deadline has passed, but old players are like Marvel superheroes - they never truly leave. Cash's greatest talent has been in finding lost souls - like, well, Carpenter! - who are stumbling through Triple A Twilight Zones, waiting for one last call. Is there somebody out there, perhaps who has contemplated retirement, who plays the OF, who bats LH and maybe even has a track record for the Yanks?

6. Like... Gardy? 

OK, shoot me, but I had to say it. Crazy longshot, for sure. And it makes no sense, none whatsoever. But what a story? Nah. Aint gonna happen.

7. We hope for the juju culling of herds on our enemies. That's right. Don't look into my eyes. I've become what we all despise - a jaded, malignantly vile creature who would sit here and call upon the juju gods to foul pitches off of certain opposing batters' kneecaps. Yes, I revel in my foul, fetid evil. But then again... how many sacrifices to the juju gods must the Yankees make? They have now lost the entire center of their batting order - Stanton, Rizzo and Carpenter - dwindling the offense to LeMahiue, Judge and opposite-field bloopers. (And last night, Donaldson.) We are a beaten up team, hitting the point where minor injuries are season-killers. We've paid our price. It's time for somebody else to step into the target range.

Not wishing anybody particular to get hurt - well, okay, yeah, that's a lie, there's a little runt fuckwad in Houston I wouldn't mind getting shingles - but all I'm asking, juju gods, is to even things up, okay? Do your jobs, but do it fairly. And, by the way, I didn't mean that thing about monkey pox. You guys are great. Really. Love ya. Hey, have you lost weight? 

42 comments:

JM said...

Bad bad bad news about Carp. He worked hard, he made it back, he's doing great, then boom. A shitty meaningless injury. The gods should be ashamed of themselves.

ZacharyA said...

We need Josh Donaldson more than ever. He needs to provide Judge with some form of protection with Stanton, Carpenter, and Rizzo out.

By the way, Judge now leads all of MLB in:

HR (44)
R (93)
RBI (98)
SLG (.677)
OPS (1.068)
OPS+ (200)
Total Bases (273)
bWAR (6.7)
fWAR (7.1)

That is extraordinarily impressive.

I dread to think what this lineup might look like without him next year.

Rufus T. Firefly said...

We all know the intern will do the wrong thing.

That's what he does.

ZacharyA said...

Clay Holmes last calendar month:
9.2 IP, 11 H, 10 ER, 9 BB, 12 K, 4 HBP

That's 24 baserunners in 9.2 innings.

Huge problem.

Joe Formerlyof Brooklyn said...


I re-read your list, and did not find the name Giancarlo on it.

Yankee injury dingbat quotes Lorna Boone saying Stanton had soreness in the AM that "continues to improve." Dated 8/2

Doug K. said...

The brutal irony is, a big part of Carpenter's comeback had to do with his ritual of walking the field barefoot to ground and center himself before games.

Maybe his ovations in St Louis was the fitting sendoff he never got and he will retire on top instead of fading away.

Great ballplayer.

AboveAverage said...

~sigh~

c r a p c a r p

The Hammer of God said...

Carpenter, Stanton, Rizzo all out right now. It's a young man's game. It's not surprising to get these kinds of injuries to old players. These guys are all old, especially Carpenter. Yeah, bad luck and all, but the fact remains that his foot probably doesn't break if he's only 24.

And yet, there really is some juju weirdness attached to all this. So Cashman traded for a guy with a broken foot to play CF, er, I mean sit on the bench and hope to play CF by playoff time or next year, and now, one of our best hitters breaks his foot. Perhaps it's punishment for Cashman's hubris?

Two questions now come up: (1) who takes the roster spot and (2) how long will they play short because of Rizzo's back.

I think chances are Cashman goes dumpster diving again and brings in some washed up old guy to replace Carpenter's bat. Whoever they get will go 0 for 196 to close out the year.

I have noticed that Cashman likes to play a man short. The smart move would've been to DL Rizzo when his back spasms flared up again. These things take a minimum of a week, maybe two weeks to calm down. Someone has to come up from the minors to replace his roster spot. Instead, we play a man short for many days on end. This stupid practice nearly burned Cashman again last night when Carpenter broke his foot. Locastro, effing Locastro had to replace Carpenter in the batting order!

Isn't it about time we brought up both Florial and Andujar? Having them here would sure solve a lot of issues.

Doug K. said...

Hammer - good point about age.

Too bad this happened after the trade deadline. (Well, too bad it happened at all.)

Watch Brain spin it as, "Stanton will return soon and be the DH so in a way losing Carpenter clears up a potential log jam."

That said, they really, really need to bring AnDUjar back. His absence is inexcusable and inexplicable.

Doug K. said...

Zach,

Some possible issues with Holmes

Mechanical - Is he tipping his pitches?

Physical - He has never had to pitch so many "stress" innings. Did he tweak or worse, blow out something?

Mental - Is he trying too hard, like a big contract hitter that feels he always has to hit a HR every time as opposed to just being who he is?

Or, is he like the golfer who can't handle success and gets a birdie and then hits his next drive into the woods?

They need to figure it out and fix him fast or we are back to Chapman.

DickAllen said...


Even if Holmes was tipping his pitches, it wouldn’t matter: he couldn’t find the plate last night if he had been sitting at the dinner table - he was all over the place, and leaving pitches to lefties out over the plate on 0-2 counts that wound up in left field. Terrible command.

Must be nice to have hitter who can hit oppo.

Hinkey Haines said...

Speaking of injuries and the juju gods - I realize the Ref Dox are basically irrelevant at this point (17 games out) but Chris Sale fractured his wrist in a bicycle accident and is done for the season.

Hinkey Haines said...

The Red Sox are irrelevant, too.

ranger_lp said...

Thought that we could all use a laugh...

https://twitter.com/TalkinBaseball_/status/1556682345238986752

ZacharyA said...

Amazing how quickly Chris Sale's career fell apart.

In his 20s....

103 W
1500 IP
1800 K
2.89 ERA
144 ERA+
40 WAR
7 x All Star
6 x Top-5 Cy Young vote
1 x World Series champion

It honestly looked like he was going to the Hall of Fame.

But his 30s hit hard.

DickAllen said...

Last night:

Top three in the batting order: 2 hits
Middle three: 8 hits
Bottom three: 1 hit

Benny has come around. Let’s pray Booooone has the sense to move him up to the 3hole.

Jiminy Cricket. Boooone make sense? What was I thinking?

Either way, the bottom of the order is a black, Gallo-sized hole

The Hammer of God said...

The effing Red Sux are paying for their cheating ways & their last WS, which they won by cheating. And that is a fact, confirmed by major league baseball suspending their manager for a year.

Chris Sale: his list of career injuries notably includes a fractured rib. (Raised eyebrows) Apparently, he also was a client of Viscount Victoria's Voluptuous Viking Vixens and Vassals Volcanic Vault of Vampirism, located in midtown Manhattan. Along with Judge, Phil Hughes, Carlos Correa. All victims of fractured ribs. Must have been the $2,500 leg scissors special from Viscount Vicky herself. "Vicky ... I can't breathe ...."

AboveAverage said...

The Hammer of God COMPELS YOU . . .

. . . to visit Viscount Victoria's Voluptuous Viking Vixens and Vassals Volcanic Vault of Vampirism.

Clearly you just earned a commish - and I'm not talking about a party date with Manfreddy

HoraceClarke66 said...

I guess Mustard just couldn't cut it. Or didn't put any, um, mustard on it.

HoraceClarke66 said...

So IS Andujar coming up? And why—YET AGAIN—is this handled like top secret news out of the Kremlin?

ranger_lp said...

So is Hicks our Mustard?

Pocono Steve said...

You have to wonder if the spate of Sale injuries also secretly includes the foot he used to apply a serious of violent Rockette kicks to a defenseless Worcester clubhouse television.

I'd say I can't wait for the Colace Experience tonight, but I'll be mercifully sleeping through it.

ranger_lp said...

In other news (8/5)

Stephen Ridings (shoulder) announced Thursday via his personal Twitter account that he completed a bullpen session.

Ridings has been on the injured list all season while recovering from a right shoulder impingement that surfaced early in spring training. Due to his lengthy layoff, Ridings will likely require at least a few weeks to build up and complete a minor-league rehab assignment before being activated from the 60-day IL.

BTR999 said...

Per Marley Rivers, Miguel Andujar will take Carpenters place on the roster and join the ream in Seattle.

AboveAverage said...

Andujar IS back!!!

BTR999 said...

Sorry that’s Marley Rivera (ESPN). Damn spell check.

HoraceClarke66 said...

FINALLY. And who knows, maybe now he will flop. But at least we will KNOW.

ranger_lp said...

tnx 999 and AA....

08/09/22 New York Yankees placed 3B Matt Carpenter on the 10-day injured list. Left foot fracture.
08/09/22 New York Yankees recalled 3B Miguel Andujar from Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders.

The Archangel said...

nothing to worry about, we just acquired Joey G.
Oh, not that Joey?
Never mind.

Hazel Motes said...

ZacharyA, the self-anointed stat maven, ought to know that the concept of lineup "protection" is a myth that has been disproved since forever by statistical studies. There are loads of studies on this. For example:

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/what-would-lineup-protection-look-like/

Hazel Motes said...

On Carpenter: a player of any age can suffer an injury, but this is the rotten fruit of Cashman's over-reliance on fading veterans. The Yankees' roster of nonpitchers is the oldest in baseball (average age 30.6). Cashman's years of promising to get younger and more athletic is simply a chronic lie--he doesn't have the smarts or the guts to build that kind of team.

DickAllen said...

It only took a major catastrophe to compel The Intern to promote Andujar.

Fucking moron.

13bit said...

I remember the days - and those days went on for decades - when I would stay up for every minute of every west coast game.

Those times are behind me. And it's' not because I have changed, but because these bums are not worth it.

Maybe that means I have changed? Maybe my self-esteem has improved?

ranger_lp said...

Miggy not helping his cause by striking out…

HoraceClarke66 said...

Well, a three-pitch strikeout by Andujar first time up. But then, Castillo a hard guy to face on your first at-bat back.

He looks a litttttttle bit less dominant than last time, though. We'll see.

AboveAverage said...

Players strike out sometimes

HoraceClarke66 said...

Scratch that. Now he seems to be rounding into form. Damn, we're actually going to lose three games to this guy? Oy.

AboveAverage said...

Cole didn't seem happy at all about that catch. He's a sour puss

AboveAverage said...

defense defense defense

Doug K. said...

I started a new game thread.

AboveAverage said...

we will win tonight - ALSO - if you're on the east coast - WAKE UP AND SUPPORT YOUR TEAM - sleep is over rated

Hazel Motes said...

Condemning a player on the basis of one at-bat against one of the toughest pitchers in the game. The spirit of Psycho George lives on in this blog.