Happy Lou Gehrig Day

On this day in 1925, Lou Gehrig began his 2,130-consecutive game streak, pinch-hitting for the immortal Pee Wee Wanninger against Walter Johnson, before 10,000 fans at Yankee Stadium.

The Iron Horse flied out to left against The Big Train, as the Yankees lost, 5-3, to fall 11.5 games behind the—and this will sound funny—defending world champion Washington Senators (even weirder:  at the time, the Yankees and the Senators had the exact same number of rings).

A couple of interesting historical quirks here: Wanninger had ended shortstop Everett Scott's 1,307-game consecutive streak—the longest before Gehrig's—back on May 6.  And Wally Pipp was playing first on that long-ago June 1, and stroked a single.

The next day, though, Gehrig started at first, pounded two singles and a double, and the rest was history.

Weirdly, the reasons for Pipp's benching are STILL disputed.  Some attribute it to Pipp's life-threatening, batting-practice beaning at the hands of Ray Caldwell (they took batting practice seriously, back in the day), one that left him in the hospital for a month.

That happened—but only on July2, after Gehrig had already taken his position.  Others attributed it to another beaning, during an earlier game.

Some feel that manager Miller Huggins simply wanted to shake the team up, and the aging Pipp was slumping.  There were even rumors—subscribed to by Gehrig's wife, among other, who was a former baseball annie and not always the most reliable of sources—that Wally was away betting on the horses, though his kids vehemently deny that.

Whatever the case, the streak started on this day.  And the usual what-ifs are intriguing.

If Gehrig had not contracted ALS, his streak could easily have lasted through at least 1941, when he would have been 38, and put another 450 games or so on it.  And with the weakening of wartime competition, he might have been able to play right through 1945—over 600 games more!—before the boys came home.  (Though it's difficult to conceive of an upstanding individual such as Lou Gehrig ever being a slacker.)