Friday, October 28, 2022

"WE didn't chase Aaron Judge away. You fans did!"

Up in the Bronx, we can already hear the rumblings of the Yankees' latest disinformation campaign, this one carefully calculated to shift the blame should Aaron Judge walk.

As our Peerless Leader alerted us, Andy Martino ran a piece on SNY the other day, headlined: "Will the Yankees' external toxicity problem cost them Aaron Judge, other free agents? More than one Yankee player has told his agent this week that playing at the Stadium was an unusually brutal experience."

Hmm, "more than one," you say? Meaning, uh, two?

Amongst Martino's other, conveniently anonymous sources, was "One longtime exec" who texted him that he was especially taken aback by:

"the irrational opinions on Cashman and Boone. I get that it's World Series or bust but damn they're spoiled."

Uh-huh.  I wonder who that "longtime exec" could be.  I'm guessing it's Thing One or Thing Two.



Unless, of course, it's the Cat in the Hat himself.


Martino goes on to note that "even before the Astros swept the Yankees in the ALCS last weekend, the clubhouse and the front office had quietly noticed that the external energy surrounding the team felt as angry as it has been in ages."

He added that "If you're Aaron Judge, booed in the playoffs days after setting an American League home run record, why wouldn't you prefer sunny Los Angeles or familiar San Francisco? 

"And if you're a free agent talking to your friends already on the team, why would you subject yourself to the experiences they describe?"

You see, good people?  

If Aaron Judge should walk—AND if the Yankees should fail to sign any future free agent, ever...well, it's OUR fault, NOT theirs. Is that foresight, or what?

I shouted out who killed the Kennedys, when after all it was...YOU, not me!

You gotta hand it to the Yanks' front office. They are absolutely BRILLIANT at buck-passing and blame-shifting, if nothing else.

And as if weasel words such as "external toxicity" were not bad enough, reporter Martino—

Wait. Full stop. Titles such as "reporter," "journalist," or "writer" have much too honorable a pedigree to apply to someone like Martino, who moonlights as a corporate flak for the Mets' own network, and MLB itself. We need something more appropriate. Maybe "lickspittle." Yeah, I think I'll go with "lickspittle."

—Lickspittle Martino went on to disavow that any of this was coming from him:

"First, this is not a criticism of folks who feel angry and disappointed that they don't get to cheer for their team in the World Series. It's just an objective truth that the team is taken aback by the level of negativity hitting them after a division title and a 99-win season. Those feelings could have real consequences for the roster."

Like what?

"Even a difficult person and underperformer like Josh Donaldson was turned into a somewhat sympathetic figure internally [corporate-speak much, Andy?] by the force of the jeering."

oh no. We could lose Josh Donaldson!

Even worse, we could lose, well, gulp:

"The gap between industry [how are you not ALREADY in p.r. full-time, Andy?] and fan perceptions of Cashman and Boone is particularly striking. Rivals consider Cashman one of the greatest executives in sports, and say that Boone will immediately become a coveted free agent if the Yankees fire him. Other GMs and agents are genuinely baffled by the fan hatred toward those two."

Right. It couldn't possibly be that other GMs—unlike Cashman himself—DON'T like to reveal when they have a real patsy in place. 

Martino claims he learned all this "after embedding with the team through a difficult month."

Yeah, he actually wrote "embedding." As if he were in Fallujah with the Old Breed, as opposed to traveling with the team, staying in nice hotels, sitting in the press box, and talking with players from time to time in the clubhouse.

But I digress. 

To start with, let's sift the obvious lies here. Free agents don't want to come to New York? Funny, they seem to show up here as faithfully as the swallows return to Capistrano. Witness Bryce Harper and Manny Machado. I guess Hal must have warned them about the booing.

The players found the last week at the Stadium "an unusually brutal experience"? Mr. Martino ought to try embedding with the average fan for a month, sitting out in the cold through hours-long rainouts—or hours-long strikeout fests.

And just who were those fans, during the playoffs? Well, a disproportionate number of them were not from the Yankees' main fan base at all, obviously, but the sorts of filthy rich folks who are pretty much the only people who can afford playoff tickets these days.  

Of course, the entire thrust of the Yankees organization for decades now has been, in one way or another, to price out the ordinary fan, and bring in richer and richer ones.  Hence, Hal rewarding enormous taxpayer subsidies by lopping thousands of seats out of his Second Gift Stadium, and replacing them with luxury boxes.  

So what we actually have here is rich people booing other rich people for not performing well enough. Does that say America today, or what?

And Hal Steinbrenner doesn't like the attitude of the fans he labored so tirelessly to bring in? That's rich.

It's a longstanding belief of local sportswriters that New York fans are so tough on their own players. I don't know how true that is. I seem to recall an awful lot of football fans, in an awful lot of cities, wearing bags over their heads.

And a few weeks from now, with the World Cup, we're going to witness millions of fans, from all over the world, who routinely boo, whistle, snap their fingers, and otherwise show their extreme displeasure. Not only if their team isn't winning, but if the style of play has become less than enchanting (and these days, baseball is nearly as soporific as soccer).

In the real world, people who don't do their work well—or even people who do their work great—routinely have their pay and hours cut, are yelled and screamed at by their bosses, or are fired. Ballplayers endure absolutely nothing like that, even if they're awful, too hurt to work, or just don't feel like really putting in the effort.  

People boo them when they stink? Gee that's terrible.

It's probably true that baseball fans in most cities today don't boo as much as they do in New York. They show their displeasure in other ways: by staying home, and changing the channel. Attendance and viewership is way down all over baseball. Would the Yankees prefer THAT means of protesting? 

Ol' Lickspittle concludes by telling us who's REALLY behind our bad attitudes:

"The Yankees created this problem long ago. George Steinbrenner's oft-repeated theme, later adopted by Derek Jeter and others, that a season is a failure if it doesn't end in a championship has come to define the Yankee brand."

That's right! Damn you, Derek Jeter, and your unceasing commitment to excellence! You're making Josh Donaldson uncomfortable!

16 comments:

el duque said...

Josh Donaldson mockingly called Tim Anderson "Jackie," as in Robinson.

We should call Josh "Mario," as in Mendoza.

Publius said...

An unusually brutal experience last weekend, huh? Sure was.

13bit said...

Oh god I’m livid….

EDB said...

Fat Slob Levine and Lost Lon Trost are so full of shit that the smell comes through my computer.

MJ said...

Judge has been gone since one second after Cashman told the terms he'd turned down the morning of Opening Day. It's an extreme credit to his skills and character that almost no one knows that. All this "feelings" nonsense is an enormous pile of excuses, carefully orchestrated and no doubt well paid for.

Shoot Dropsy the Ancient Daring Mouse with truth serum (call it a booster if you have to) and ask him why he leaked those financials about that offer. Then, after carefully assessing the answer, cease giving a shit about this collection of flaming assholes.

Or don't.

The Archangel said...

HC66, Pulitzer worthy prose.

The management and Martino must never read any blogs like this.
NOBODY likes Hal, Assman and BaBoone and the fans out in the bleachers and upper decks are booing them.

Bosch, don't worry, there is just a few more days until we can vote out the people that gave us high inflation, no energy and such disdain for police that it unleashed a virtual "Escape to New York" landscape
(Here's looking at you Lightfoot, etc.).
Meanwhile, you folks in Europe keep electing Socialist Democrats who turn off your energy and open your borders..

Stang said...

If that's what they think of us, let's stop giving them money.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Thanks, Archie, but I could not agree LESS with your politics. The assholes you support are going to end the Republic.

I think we should continue to stay away from politics here, particularly in the days and weeks just ahead.


HoraceClarke66 said...

And yeah, from what I could see, surveying the other fan blogs, NOBODY is fooled by this.

A few people write that Judge should not have been booed. I agree completely. Fewer feel that you should never boo your team. i think that's ridiculous, at least in pro sports.

If they really do let Judge walk, the Yanks are done in this town for years to come, maybe decades.

13bit said...

when you come into this blog and talk politics, it's like going to your neighbor's house and taking a shit in their foyer

The Hammer of God said...

@The Archangel, Hoss is right about the assholes who are trying to end democracy. America can end up just like Putin's Russia, holding fake elections while a fascist asshole stays in power until the day he drops dead. And fascism is alive and well in Europe, as Italy is once again proving.

Now that I got that off my chest, on to Judge. And you're right about that too, Hoss. This situation is a public relations dream for Yankee management. There are a zillion ways that they can spin this and make Judge out to be the ungrateful turd that walked away. And you know what? If and when he walks away, most fans will buy the Yankee management version of the story. "He turned down 360 million? Why, that's more than most of us fans make in 500 lifetimes. How dare he sign elsewhere for 600 million. He only cares about the money." And, "if I was Judge, I'd play here for FREE!" Whilst ignoring the fact that Judge's money is literally peanuts compared to what HAL makes from the Yankees, all while sitting on his comfortable ass making imbecile statements like "Boone ... is a very good manager" while Judge sacrifices his body in a futile attempt to make up for the shortcomings of his team.

The Archangel said...

Sorry guys, I did not bring politics into the blog.
I have been in the belly of the beast working for years in the court system and have observed the degrading of the public forum and regard for law and order and the ability to voice contrary positions.It is stifling and shocking and it is coming to a society near you because lawyers in all their various forms, run the country.
If the Republic is in jeopardy it is not from people of my ilk, but those who toss out terms like fascist against those with whom they disagree.
If we don't right the ship soon, we will be like Europe before you know.
End of political digression

But we can all agree that Ashman and Harold suck, as well as their pet BaBoone.

Local Bargain Jerk said...


I'm late to this discussion but please allow me two points:

     1) Hoss, that was a great piece.  Nice job.

     2) In response to this from your post:

          It couldn't possibly be that other GMs — unlike Cashman himself — DON'T like to reveal

          when they have a real patsy in place.


     I say, EXACTLY.  It reminds me of Hogan's Heroes when Colonel Wilhelm Klink would raise his index finger and brag that there had NEVER been an escape from his POW camp!  The obvious joke, of course, was that the Allies "had a real patsy in place" and used him to conduct one successful clandestine operation after another, for six long seasons.

What we have on our hands here is Colonel Wilhelm Cashman giving orders to Sgt. Hans "I see nussink!" Boone.

Kill me now.

Local Bargain Jerk said...


Sorry guys, I did not bring politics into the blog.

Actually, AA, you did.

Whenever you encourage someone to vote in a particular direction that's the very definition of politics and/or a turd in 13Bit's foyer.

Joe of AZ said...

I like you work in the court system as an officer in AZ....and I can tell you that relationship with law and order has soured because all 3 branches of govt have failed in their overall duty in serving it's citizens in every conceivable way... Start doing that again and you'll see an INSTANT improvement.... But I do join you in saying Fuck Hal, Fuck Cassman and Fuck Boone

HoraceClarke66 said...

Archie, we have all been guilty of violating our best rule. Myself included.

I'm sorry I lost my temper before. And I have plenty of problems with people on "our" side.

But I think that since the two sides don't even agree on basic points of reality anymore, it really makes no sense to talk politics. It's like people who can't agree on what color the sky is, trying to have a debate on meteorology. I joke, but it's a truly tragic set of circumstances, and I think there is a very, very dark future just ahead.

That said, I would like to preserve some little space for friendly conversation about something as wonderfully frivolous as baseball, before it all comes apart.