Wednesday, February 19, 2020

Judge's injury raises the question: Was last year the "new normal?"

As you all know, Aaron Judge has been relegated to the Peloton and extreme kegels for the first week of spring training, and he'll miss Saturday's crucial game against always-tough Toronto. (1:05 p.m., YES, and/or John & Suzyn, on the Yankee Radio Network, driven by Sleep.) Somehow, he strained his shoulder, and he'll be shut down for a few days, maybe a week, two at the most, probably not more...

Translation: There's a chance he's out until the All Star break.

OMG. WTF? HDIKEPO! ALEPCXZ? Talk about doom and gloom? Why would I speak such horrible acronyms? 

Well, because...

a) Last year, the Yankees said the exact same thing about minor boo-boos - "just a flesh wound, ma'am" - to Luis Severino and Aaron Hicks, and they missed most of the season.

b) Over the years, the Yankees have shown no compulsion or duty to disclose the truth about injuries to the general public. It's not like stealing signs. 

c) Judge has proven to be an enormously fragile giant, to the point that missed service time is threatening to define his career.

d) It hasn't been explained how he hurt himself. Henry Cotto once blew out an ear with a Q-Tip. Graig Nettles fought a lawn mower and lost. How did this happen? 

e) More importantly, when did it happen? How long has this lingered? Judge underwent an MRI a week ago. Supposedly, it showed nothing serious. But how long was this hurting before he requested the scan?

f) The Ellsbury Effect: Last year, the Yankees were able to injure players while they were rehabbing other injuries. Last month, they cleaned house on the training staff. The question: Does modern baseball demand such peak athleticism that every bone, muscle and ligament is now tweakable, and  players have become human potato chips?

Aw, I should lighten up, right? The first week of spring training is filled with nonsense. Clearly, the real story is the continuing "days of rage" against the Astros, with MLB players emulating the students of Hong Kong. Still, this Judge injury is another sign that injuries don't follow random patterns, and just because the Yankees experienced too much rain last year, it doesn't mean a drought coming in 2020. 

Continuing waves of injuries may just be the new normal.

If so, there is actually cause to for hope within the Yankiverse. Shane Robinson is not coming. If anything, Judge's injury opens a lane for Clint Frazier and Miguel Andujar, and maybe even the lost prospect of yesteryear, Estevan Florial. Just like James Paxton's injury creates competition for the fifth starter and justifies the decision to keep J.A. Happ, the Yankees can actually make use of the opening... as long as it doesn't continue into April.

The Yankees may have the deepest roster in baseball. It extends beyond the 40-man into the taxi squads of Triple A, where Cooperstown Cashman is always combing the scrap heaps for recycled clutches and brake pads. 

Nobody wants to see Judge miss time. But if this is the new norm, perhaps the Yankees can find a new Gio Urshela and Mike Tauchman. That would sure be nice.

14 comments:

JM said...

All we can hope is that all of our "stars" are healthy in time to destroy the team's chemistry and lose in the postseason. Because, after all, that is the Yankees way.

Anonymous said...

At least the Yanks are not paying Stanton-esque millions for Judge to sit on the sidelines for the entire decade. But then again, the Yanks did sign Ellsbury to a stupid contact knowing full well he's more injured than healthy. Still it has to be serious if he's not keeping it to himself long enough to sign that huge albatross of a contract beforehand.

Anonymous said...

WATCH THE MEDIA START WITH THEIR "GIANCARLO STANTON CAN CARRY THIS TEAM IN JUDGE'S ABSENCE" BULLSHIT...

I CAN SEE IT NOW, OUR "BOOK OF SECRETS" HAS:
SANCHEZ CATCHING 1O5 GAMES.
JUDGE PLAYING 110 GAMES.
STANTON PLAYING 70 GAMES.
GLEYBER PLAYING 125 GAMES.
LUKE PLAYING 85 GAMES.

THESE GUYS SHOULD ALL GET HALF-PAY.

MAYBE HALIGATOR TELLS THEM THEY ONLY HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT PLAYING LITTLE MORE THAN HALF A SEASON FOR FULL PAY? (PART OF THE "PERKS" FOR BEING A YANKEE)?

ALL PART OF THE YANKEES "INSIDE-SABERMETRICS", "BOOK OF SECRETS".

CROCK OF SHIT.

13bit said...

I love Judge and, two or so years ago, thought he could be the next Captain. Last year, though, at the risk of sounding like the old scold that I am, I kept whining and moaning about trading him at peak value - already off by last year, by the way - and I was NOT the only one on this blog to advocate that.

I still feel that way. Give me a solid guy who's a doubles machine any day over his style of hitting.

HoraceClarke66 said...

Bitty, I've been saying that for two years, and I feel the same way about Judge. He SHOULD be the next Yankee immortal. But he ain't.

I just wish that, instead of Stanton, we had picked up Christian Yelich from the Miami fire sale. Who, I know, got hurt last year. But who is not CHRONICALLY hurt.

Ken of Brooklyn said...

I still hold out a sliver of hope that Judge can mature into the next Yankee immortal, but it doesn't look good,,,, Hmmmmm, isn't Mookie available next year?

ranger_lp said...

Quote from Stanton:

"If I knew what was coming in '17, I probably would have hit 80-plus home runs," Stanton said Wednesday.

Anonymous said...

@Hoss, Christian Yelich would've made us legit a WS contender. Being a lefty hitter, he would've balanced the lineup. Surely, the decision to get Stanton was sabermetrics b/s.

HoraceClarke66 said...

But of course he DID know what was coming in 2017, ranger. Overwhelmingly, fastballs, as opponents just wanted to get done playing his punk-ass team and hit the beach clubs in Miami.

"Well, we're up 14-3, let me see if I can throw my heat past Giancarlo. Nope! Oh, well, now it's 14-4."

TheWinWarblist said...

Carney Lansford (Yes, Carney Lansford. Yes, I'm old.) nearly killed himself racing snowmobiles. Not racing around on any old snowmobile. No. Racing in snowmobile races on an actual racing-car-like racing snowmobile. Dislocated both hips and fractured his pelvis. Nearly died. Now that was a real man's injury.



Fuck you all, each and every one.

Retired Stratman said...

Last year I suggested trading Judge and Stanton for Mike Trout. Hoss said no, that was giving up too much. What do you think now?

On another note, I think I’ve come up with the perfect penalty for the Astro’s cheating. For the next three seasons all Houston pitchers have to tell the opposing batters what pitch is coming. Every time. Poetic justice. Then we’ll see if it impacts the games.

ranger_lp said...

@Hoss "Man, that ball got outta here in a hurry"

Alex said...

I am not sure where you're getting your info, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for magnificent information I was looking for this info for my mission.
Neck Pain Frankfort

Isiyku Abdulahi said...



I really want the world to know about this great man who brought back happiness into my life again after my husband left me and the kids 3 years ago for another women online when i contacted Dr Believe he cast a love spell for me within 48 hours my ex husband start calling me and begging for forgiveness for everything that have happened between us. I was so happy to have my family back together with love again here is the email of Dr Believe via believelovespelltemple@gmail.com a man with the great powers you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2348156148821
God bless you
I am very grateful for your help in my marriage.