Wednesday, March 2, 2022

They did it. They really did it. They had one job. They blew it up.

On Dec. 2, all 30 of baseball's oligarchs unanimously voted to impose a lockout on the game. Explained Commissioner Rob Manfred: "We hope that the lockout will jumpstart the negotiations." 

Six weeks later, they made their first offer. 

Six weeks of nothing.

Throughout the "negotiations," the owners never once addressed the key issue separating the sides: Their "luxury tax," which serves as a de facto salary cap. 

According to Tyler Kepner, under the owners' most recent proposal, a $220 million franchise tax threshold would remain in place for three years. They knew the players wouldn't accept it. They were willing to cancel opening day. And now it's gone. 

It's time for baseball fans to take a page from the brave people of Ukraine. 

I don't mean to take up arms. Baseball is, after all, a mere distraction to the crapola we swallow in everyday life. We don't need violence or threats. But we need to stand for something. 

At a certain point, we - as Americans, as fans, as the true keepers of the pastime - must register our disgust over what these oligarchs have done. I've mentioned this in the past, and I believe that the entire international fan base yearns to be heard. Right now, there is no conduit, no means to vent our anger. 

Right here, I'm struggling to sound rational - to not scream obscenities in caps. America supported baseball through the Covid pandemic, filling stadiums when such crowds actually presented a threat to our health. On blogs like this, we have passionately followed the Yankees, showing a loyalty that the owners clearly take for granted. 

From birth, Hal Steinbrenner has "owned" not just a ballclub, but a piece of America. Hal voted for this lockout. Shame on him. 

Shame on him... forever.

I believe that, like Putin, the czars of baseball have made a horrible miscalculation. They have underestimated America's reaction to their greed. Yeah, we all know it's crazy for a player to be paid $35 million a year, but nobody ever forced an owner to shell out such an amount; they do it because they inhabit a world of infinite wealth, and such ridiculous sums are simply a checkbook away. 

There is no big-market competitive imbalance in baseball. In recent years, the Missouri teams - the Cards and Royals - have won more world series than the Yankees, Mets, Dodgers and Angels, combined. If the Pirates and Orioles suck, it's not because they represent smaller cities. It's because they made horrible trades.

On this blog, we talk a lot about a boycott. And that's a start. But here's the reality: The owners think our condemnations, our raw anger, will simply disappear after the first walk-off homer. History tells them that, by July, their hold on us will be as strong as ever.

The world has reached the point where it's not enough to simply say, "I stand with Ukraine." It's time for nations to do something, to make a difference. And so it is with baseball. 

We need a plan.

28 comments:

Doug K. said...

I couldn't agree more.

This is a major miscalculation on their part. They want to maximize profits for their business? Here's a hint, don't have total disregard for your customers. I've already cancelled my MLB TV subscription. But there's more that can be done...

For openers, they should lose their anti-trust exemption. At a minimum we need a form letter to send to congress. But really we should use our considerable combined creative abilities to write/produce a you tube video to enlist people to that cause.

Another thing we can do, although I'm not sure how, is to make the designation, "The Official XXX of Major League Baseball" a pariah. Not quite like, "The Official XXX of the Klan" but let their precious sponsors know that enriching this group of owners doesn't "endear" them to the fans but has the opposite effect.

Perhaps there is a video to be used here as well.

Whatever we decide, sign me up.

BTR999 said...

Love the idea about about repealing the ant-trust exemption (which is a joke) but it would take years. Let this be not the winter, but the season of our discontent. Boycotts? Yes. Civil demonstrations at games (if there sure any) why not? I’m not advocating anyone break the law, but there are many peaceful ways to make your displeasure known. I would certainly be open to any reasonable organized protest. We should clap back at these corporatist clowns! Meanwhile take that interest, that PASSION, for baseball and try to channel it into something else. Let’s not wallow in our in our displeasure. We’re not sheep, and we don’t have to accept this bullshit.

DickAllen said...


I cancelled my MLBTV subscription this morning.

Fuck you Hal and fuck all your fellow owners.

JM said...

I suggest dog poop in the luxury boxes.

I would've said the owner's box, but he's already there.

Carl J. Weitz said...

Obviously, social media is the proper venue to get a viral national movement started. Exactly how is the million dollar question. We should spend the next few weeks discussing this idea and nailing it down. If a dog licking his balls can gain a million plus viewers on Facebook, Twitter or TikTok, a well-developed video properly placed should do the same. Maybe a few here have some connections to help facilitate this project.
Count me in and maybe we can all chip in the dollar equivalent of an afternoon out at Yankee Stadium to make it so.

el duque said...

I like the idea of launching a national boycott of all products that claim to be "the official whatever of Major League Baseball."

From there, we should push to boycott all sponsors of MLB games on TV.

That's where we hit them.

Carl J. Weitz said...

El Duque....sounds like a reasonable start.

DickAllen said...


WB Mason - up yourself!

HoraceClarke66 said...

Wow, I feel like I'm at Carpenters Hall at the start of the Revolution!

I'm thinkin...maybe something like those "red nose" or "ice bucket" challenges. If you think the baseball owners are full of it, you do...x.

The question is what.

Doug K. said...

https://www.mlb.com/sponsorship/official-sponsors

DickAllen said...

Here’s a brief list of MLB sponsors:

Arm&Hammer
Budweiser
Chevrolet
Camping World
Draft Kings
Geico
Google
Lysol
OxiClean
SiriusXM
Taco Bell
T Mobile
Audi
Toyota
H&R Block
Bank of America

I’m sure there are many more

DickAllen said...


Sorry Doug. I missed seeing yours before I posted

Doug K. said...

Dick,

All good. :). There are some differences in the two lists. Both good places to start.

ZacharyA said...

If we try to start a social media movement boycotting MLB sponsors, it needs to be a very clear correlation between cancelling a subscription/service and the lockout. Something like this on Twitter:

"Today I cancelled my phone plan with @TMobile since they are a sponsor of @MLB. I will have nothing to do with the league or any of its sponsors due to the owner-imposed lockout and cancellation of games."

We should also hit the gambling sites.

"Today I withdrew all my funds from @DraftKings and will not be placing any more bets due to the league-imposed @MLB lockout. I placed 25 bets at a total of $2500 in 2021."

Gotta tag the corporations in this so their PR branch sees what is happening. We're facing an uphill battle here since the average MLB fan is in his/her 50s and not as tech saavy as the younger generation. We really need to get the kids on board. I know the reddit baseball and team-specific subreddits would be on board.

Carl J. Weitz said...

There needs to be an initial attention grabbing banner so people watch. And then a clear mission statement of what we want to accomplish.

Unknown said...

Think of the Moon Big Papi movement and how much steam that garnered. We can do this! Especially because it’s not just one fan base angered, it’s all 30.

-Yankees Shamus

Doctor T said...

Its time to take baseball away from the owners. I'm done with these welfare-kings. Strip baseball of its anti-trust protections and jack their rent on the stadiums. And while we're at it, let's do some forensic work on their taxes.

That should focus their minds a little more.

Hazel Motes said...

Every ten years or so the Ayn Rand ideologues in the owners' group try to blow up the players' union. Every ten years they fail. They will fail again this time. These idiots make Putin look sane by comparison.

DickAllen said...



I just called the MLB public relations office in NYC. Not surprisingly, my call went to voicemail. I left a message informing them that I hold the owners personally responsible for taking the game away from us - that it is OUR game, not theirs, and that I cancelled my MLBTV subscription today and would boycott any and all sponsors of corporate baseball until the owners gave the players what they have earned the right to.

Please feel free to call them: 212.9317800

Power to the people.

AboveAverage said...

They should downsize the 2022 season to a handful of community softball game fundraisers . . .

DickAllen said...



OR...

...you can send then an email:

publicrelations@mlb.com

They actually call it public relations.



AboveAverage said...

Dick - That's great - I wish I could see the response of the person that retrieves those messages, even if it is only an eye-roll and a quick press of the delete button.

13bit said...

Whatever we do, it needs to be publicized. That is the one thing they make take note of. And, with that Internet thingie and social media, we do have the means to create a movement.

We can start by coming up with clever hashtags. We might want to start a Twitter account - yes, I hate Twitter, but it would be useful - and then we start tagging stories and try to define the narrative.

We are all so familiar with our assessment of and hatred for the current system that it has become a kind of shorthand to us, but we need to speak clearly, as Vlad recently said, and to educate people.

I'm tired. I'll try to think up some stuff after this nap.

Local Bargain Jerk said...


I saw Duque's call to action this morning and I thought to myself, if ever there was a worthy cause, this is it.  Nothing came to me immediately so I decided I would walk around with it for a while to see if I could come up with anything.  So far, unfortunately, I'm still dry.

Maybe it's the swirl of major issues right now -- the war in Ukraine, the concerning state of our democracy -- or maybe it's just a vague sense that I'm not even sure who I'm tilting at (the 30 domestic oligarchs?).

I love ZacharyA's suggestions above about tagging the sponsors in some well-placed Tweets and FB posts. I'm trying to think how it can be executed. More to come.

Maybe we take a page from those who are famous for misinformation campaigns (e.g., Brad Parscale, QAnon) and plaster FB, Twitter, etc. with information campaigns outlining in simple, brief terms what a bunch of scumbags these 30 oligarchs are ... i.e., by name. E.g., #HankSteinbrennerRuinedYankeesBaseball, #PeterAngelosRuinedOriolesBaseball, etc.

I'll continue to stew on it some more.  Meanwhile, let's all keep the ideas flowing.

13bit said...

Let's keep stewing and brainstorming. Maybe one campaign at a time, but WE ALL PILE ON and make some noise. One that I'd like to pursue would be #DUMPCASHMANFORJETER

Just tag the living shit out of that. Email sportswriters, write in comments sections, everybody email and write the Yankee front office. Even if nothing happens, we - to use a modern term I absolutely LOATHE - we become DISRUPTORS.

We just keep pushing the same old shit until it becomes part of the zeitgeist. One campaign a week. We become trolls for the greater good. I think it can be done.

Good to see you on the case, LBJ!!!

MJ said...

Could just take the year off and do our own things. Maybe not waste any time pretending to give a shit what any of us think MIGHT concern these people. That's my trip. Nothing against protests (I'm all for them). I guess the collective MLB idiocy drove the give-a-shit right out of me. I wish everyone happiness in their plans and their implementation. Different roads for each of us. None of them wrong ones. As for me? Catch me in '23.

EDB said...

El Duque:
Morons act like morons. Hal does not enjoy owning The Yankees. He was handed the team and has done all in his power to make The yANKEES A MESS.

TheWinWarblist said...

I love you all. ❤️