Wednesday, July 15, 2020

"Throughout that entire run, the Core Four clearly played massive roles in New York’s dominance. But Williams outshone almost all of them. According to WAR, only Jeter (25.9) provided the Yankees with more regular-season value than Williams (24.5) during the span of those World Series-winning seasons... By any measure, Williams was (at worst) the second-best position player on a team that ranks among the greatest dynasties in baseball history."

The woefully dismissed case for Bernie Williams making The Hall, from yesterday's fivethirtyeight.com. God bless you, noble wonks!

This post should be screen-printed onto facial masks and mandated to be worn in anti-Yankee hotbeds across the "hoax" pandemic. There is one reason - ONE - why Bernie Williams has not been long ago enshrined into baseball's Hall of Fame: 

He played for the Yankees.

As a result, the goose-fleshy, intellectually unresponsive, morally corrupt, spittoon-mouthed, tick-brained dwarfs who cover baseball regularly refuse to acknowledge great Yankees, while honoring racist Tom Yawkey and one-hit wonders like Bill Mazeroski - (lifetime BA: .260; best season BA: .283) - whose lone moment in the sun, of course, came against New York.

Not to single-out Maz - a tribal elder and fine sportsman - but why the hell is he in the Hall instead of Bobby Richardson? (Fun fact: Bobby was the 1960 World Series MVP; if Maz doesn't hit that homer... well, think about it.) But let's not go down a rabbit hole. Let's look at the Yankees of the late '90s - Torre's Yankees - the last great dynasty in your miserable lifetime. But don't expect to find evidence in Cooperstown. Nope. Your grandchildren will find two players - Jeet and Mo - leaving them to wonder if this team really won four rings in five years. Why was Gramps always talking about them? They only had two great players.

Listen: There's nothing worse than self-loathing Yankee fans, who accept the Hall of Fame voting each year, buying into the false narrative that to play in New York brings excessive fame, so Craig Biggio belongs and Jorge Posada doesn't. What NYC brings is excessive pressure, and not many players hold up under it for the length of a career.

Bernie fucking belongs in the Hall. It's that simple. Thank you, wonks. Now, get back to rating the election. 

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bernie is a Hall of Famer in my book. I thought he was the best player on the team for a span of about five years ('96 through '00). Eventually, in 2001 and onward, Jeter succeeded him as the best player on the team. But the dynasty occurred during Bernie's tenure.

Some of the amazing things that Bernie did that I remember fondly, for no particular reason: (1) He reached base safely in something like 16 out of 21 plate appearances, an amazing hot streak. (2) In a game in Oakland, he once mistakenly thought a ball three call was ball four and went to first base. The ump had to call him back and everyone was laughing. Then he hit the next pitch out for a home run. (Everyone said that only Bernie could have done that.) I think one of the reasons that I remember Bernie so fondly is that he was a Yankee farmhand who came up when the team was terrible. As he got better, so did the team, culminating in the dynasty years.

Anyway, so Bernie was the switch hitting center fielder with power, who hit for average and on base percentage, driving in runs too, with four World Series Championships. Yet, he's not in the Hall of Fame. What gives?

I think that a guy who was one of the best players at his position for at least 4-5 years should be in the Hall. Particularly when he was one of the best clutch hitters of his era and won four WS championships.

I agree that the only reason Bernie is not in the HOF is the stupid bias that the HOF voters have toward NYY players. People talk about the "core four", but it was really more like the "fab five". This guy was as important, or probably even more important, to the team during the dynasty years than any one player of the core four.

The Hammer of God

JM said...

Bernie don't get no respect, I wanna tell ya.

Beauregard Jackson Pickett Burnside said...

He ain’t gonna be in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame neither.

TheWinWarblist said...

You forgot toilet seat licking.

TheWinWarblist said...

One more thing. New York State and City are seeing a significant spike in new COVID-19 cases after a rash of risky behavior over July 4th weekend. Far more so than that after the George Floyd protests. Which tells us a couple of things. 1) Coronavirus is still endemic in the population and can spread like wildfire if given the chance, and 2) the protestors behaved much better than your average backyard cookout attendee.

WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH THESE PEOPLE!? HOW MANY MORE HAVE TO SICKEN AND DIE!? JUST SO YOU CAN HAVE A NASTY BURNT HOG DOG AND SHITTY BEER!? FUCKING ASSHOLES!!! STAY OUT OF MY EMERGENCY ROOM!!! DON'T YOU DARE SET FOOT INSIDE MY HOSPITALS!! DIE AT HOME!! I SWEAR I WILL KICK YOU UNTIL YOU BEG FOR DEATH RATHER THAN HELP YOU, YOU GOAT BLOWING, TOILET SEAT LICKING ASSHOLES!!!!!


DO NOT LET YOUR GUARD DOWN!!

Stay safe!! Stay distant!! Wear a mask!! Wash your hands!! FUCK YOU HAL!!!!!!!





Seriously, forever and always, fuck you Hal.

Anonymous said...

I HAVE ALWAYS SAID BERNIE WAS AND STILL IS THE MOST UNDERRATED YANKEE OF ALL.

HE DESERVES TO BE IN THAT "CORE FOUR" PACK WHICH REALLY SHOULD HAVE BEEN NAMED SOMETHING LIKE THE "THRIVE FIVE".

HALL OF FAME?

YES.

IF HAROLD BAINES IS IN, SO SHOULD BERNIE.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, I think Bernie was a much better player than Harold Baines. There are a whole lot of players in the HOF who weren't anywhere near as good as Bernie. I don't begrudge it to any of them. God bless 'em all, but it don't mean Bernie should be locked out.

The Hammer of God

smurfy said...

Amen, and Posada was key over and over. A real hero, like Bernie, due for recognition.

Isiyku Abdulahi said...


I really want the world to know about this great man who brought back happiness into my life again after my husband left me and the kids 3 years ago for another women online when i contacted Dr Believe he cast a love spell for me within 48 hours my ex husband start calling me and begging for forgiveness for everything that have happened between us. I was so happy to have my family back together with love again here is the email of Dr Believe via believelovespelltemple@gmail.com a man with the great powers you can also call him or add him on Whats-app: +2348156148821
God bless you
I am very grateful for your help in my marriage.